The Butterfly Collector by The Jam: Great B-Sides

The Jam are arguably the most British band ever, with all the telltale traits. They:

  • started young
  • never made it big in the USA, at least partly because of frontman Paul Weller’s thick English accent
  • released some of their best material on non-album singles and b-sides.

Although they were from the class of 1977, The Jam were never punk. They were often fast and frenetic, but they were 1960s revivalists, taking a healthy dollop of inspiration from 1960s acts, particularly The Who, and bringing back mod fashions.

‘The Butterfly Collector’ is the b-side to the 1979 single ‘Strange Town’. It was perhaps relegated to the b-side of the single because it owes a significant musical debt to a song from another 1960s British act, The Kinks’ ‘Shangri La’.

Perhaps it was relegated to B-side status because it’s a little saucy. I’ve read different reports about the song’s subject. One theory is that it’s a rebuke to Soo Catwoman who’d moved on from The Sex Pistols’ entourage by this time. The butterfly being collected is Weller himself, and it’s a scathing put-down of groupies.

Another theory was that it was written about NME music journalist Julie Burchill, a riposte to a scathing review of The Jam, cleverly dressed in sexual metaphors.

Either way, “There’s tarts and whores/But you’re much more” is a memorable opening line for the chorus.

The Jam released a lot of great songs during a five-year recording career. They’d already broken up by the time Weller turned 25 – but the b-side ‘The Butterfly Collector’ is my favourite Jam track.

The Butterfly Collector Lyrics

So you finally got what you wanted
You’ve achieved your aim by making me walk in line
And when you just can’t get any higher
You use your senses to suss out this week’s climber
And the small fame that you’ve acquired
Has brought you into cult status
But to me you’re still a collector

There’s tarts and whores but you’re much more
You’re a different kind ’cause you want their minds
And you just don’t care ’cause you’ve got no pride
It’s just a face on your pillowcase
That thrills you

And you started looking much older
And your fashion sense is second-rate like your perfume
But to you in your little dream world
You’re still the queen of the butterfly collectors

As you carry on ’cause it’s all you know
You can’t light a fire, you can’t cook or sew
You get from day to day by filling your head
But surely you must know the appeal between your legs
Has worn off

And I don’t care about morals
‘Cause the world’s insane and we’re all to blame anyway
And I don’t feel any sorrow
Towards the kings and queens of the butterfly collectors

There’s tarts and whores but you’re much more
You’re a different kind ’cause you want their minds
And you just don’t care ’cause you’ve got no pride
It’s just a face on your pillowcase
That thrills you

You carry on ’cause it’s all you know
You can’t light a fire, you can’t cook or sew
You get from day to day by filling your head
But surely you must know the appeal between your legs
Has worn off

And I don’t feel any sorrow
Towards the kings and queens of the butterfly collectors

Read More

6 Comments

  1. I really liked this song from the Snap! collection, although I have to admit I never paid attention to the words – I assumed it was related to the John Fowles novel The Collector.

Leave a Reply

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

More review pages

Rich Mullins Album Reviews

Richard Wayne Mullins was one of the most beloved figures...

Phoebe Bridgers Album Reviews

Indie singer-songwriter Phoebe Bridgers was born in Los Angeles and...

The Zombies Album Reviews

The Zombies get lost in the shuffle of British invasion...
Zombies Odessey and Oracle Review

1980s Miscellany

This page collects odds and ends from 1980s artists: Beastie...
Tracy Chapman 1988 Debut

Cat Stevens Album Reviews

His birth certificate says Steven Demetre Georgiou and he later...

John Martyn Album Reviews

John Martyn was born Iain David McGeachy, the son of...

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

More blog posts

I Wish You Wouldn’t Say That by Talking Heads: Great B-Sides

New York’s Talking Heads are one of my favourite bands...
Talking Heads: 77

Talking Heads Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

New York rock band Talking Heads started their career as...

The Beatles: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

Miraculously, two of the most talented vocalists and songwriters in...
The Beatles Help

10 Best Songs by The Soft Boys

Robyn Hitchcock started his recording career as the frontman for the...

10 Best Bangles Songs

The Bangles’ work has two facets. There’s the 1960s garage...

Subscribe

Subscribe to receive new posts from Aphoristic Album Reviews.