I spent many happy hours in my late teens and twenties trawling used bins for CD bargains. I gained a lot of great music this way, and it became even easier as people converted their music collections to mp3. It was never difficult to find Sugar’s albums – while the albums from Bob Mould’s Hüsker Dü years in the 1980s were rare finds, Rykodisc must have over anticipated demand for his edgy power pop with Sugar, and they were easy to nab for $3.
While they were great value, I never connected with Sugar the way I connected with Hüsker Dü or with Bob Mould’s 1989 solo album Workbook. Hüsker Dü had the benefit of two contrasting writers and vocalists to keep things interesting, while Workbook explored new territory for Mould, dour folk rock inspired by Richard Thompson.
Comparably, Sugar were stuck in one gear, angsty overdriven power pop, and as a result their albums were often less than the sum of their parts. My favourite of their records is easily their 1993 EP Beaster, where Mould’s at his most aggressive, giving the songs an engrossing edge. Mould was joined in Sugar by drummer Malcolm Travis and bassist David Barbe. Barbe opened his own studio in 1997, after Sugar’s dissolution, and has served as a producer for southern rock band Drive-By Truckers.
‘Needle Hits E’ is a b-side from the sessions for Copper Blue – it’s a terrific song, but it’s not missed from Copper Blue – it would have been too much of a good thing. It’s quintessentially Sugar, brimming with power and tune. I didn’t realise what the title referred to initially – the word needle can have different connotations in pop lyrics, including drug use and spinning vinyl. But in this case it’s a reference to the fuel gauge in a car – it’s a warning from Mould to a friend who’s running on empty.
Been selling it short I’m seeing sunlight for the very first time And I’m changing my ways Hanging out on the roof in the rain
The tragic comedy I hit the station as the needle hits E The needle hits E Fill it up and take another twenty
You’re living in desperation Half the time you don’t even know I’m hanging out your frustration On the laundry line
Hang you out to dry You drag it around You got a bone in front of your face And you’re dragging me down
I feel for you when I feel out of place It doesn’t bother me I hit the station as the needle hits E The needle hits E You’re running out ’cause you’re running on me
Somebody should tell your mother All the things you’re carting around Stop kicking the wall, my brother Have you lost your mind? All you do is watch the tank run dry
Been living it large Fill it up and gimme the wheel And I cherish the day When you say the things that you feel
Your storm is over now I hit the station as the needle hits E E E The needle hits E Empty empty empty empty empty
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
18 Comments
I agree with you on the Husker Du/ Mould solo vs Sugar. I haven’t done any thinking on it but I’d have a hard time I think coming up with an album I liked more than Workbook the year it came out- 1988 if I recall correctly? Easily the album I played most that year. Loved Husker Du-
Workbook is 1989 – I’d definitely take Pixies Doolittle over it in terms of alt-rock.
Doolittle was a good one.. looking at the list of albums from 1989 I think on second thought my favorite is Lou Reed-New York.
Patch The Sky was brilliant. This is a top drawer jam too. Beaster is the business Copper Blue is the CEO
Yeah, I’ve heard Patch the Sky is good – I have almost everything up through 1994, then nothing – guess I should go a bit deeper one day.
Nice point about a stellar b-side being too much of a good thing – I feel that way with the cure’s “a pink dream.” among my favourites, but it wasn’t needed on Wild Mood Swings for similar reasons
Do you have any recommendations for a Cure b-side? They have a lot of good ones, I’ve heard, but I only really know their big 1980s albums.
I think I have most of the 90s singles, they all have good non-album b-sides. The Mint Car single is my favourite of the lot (with b-sides ‘waiting’ and ‘a pink dream’)
Man do I like that sound. I might have told you that i seen Bob on an episode of Austin City Limits a few years ago. Fantastic. And yes ‘Patch The Sky’ is good. catchgroove is a big Mould guy and has lots of good pieces on him. Good choice on this one.
Excellent choice.
If you have any bsides you want to recommend for the series, let me know!
Thank you. the one that springs to mind is:
Tori Amos – Silent All Those Years
I love that song. I am mainly thinking of non-album b-sides though.
Sorry, I mean the Bside of it – the cover of ‘Smells Like Teen Spirit’.
Great pick. I first heard this one as part of the Copper Blue deluxe a few years back.
As for Sugar vs. Hüsker Du vs. Mould solo, I gravitate towards Sugar. Copper Blue and (especially) Beaster were huge for me; a pal introduced me to them and really turned me on to Mould’s stuff.
I can’t remember what my first Mould album was, but it might well have been Husker Du’s Warehouse Songs and Stories. Even though it’s certainly not Hart’s best stuff, I like having him there to balance Mould.
I think that was my first Hüsker Dü hit. I’d certainly agree that it was good having Hart’s contributions there too.
The importance of Beaster to me is really the sole reason Sugar is my favourite Mould stuff. Copper Blue too. I’ve never cared for File Under Easy Listening, though.
Warehouse has a bunch of songs that pretty much set the course for Sugar – less punky, more mainstream alternative guitar rock.
File Under Easy Listening has a couple of songs I really like – Panama City Hotel has an acoustic jangle that makes it stand out, and Explode and Make Up is a great closer.
Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
Review Pages
Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:
Formed around former Box Tops lead singer Alex Chilton and Chris Bell, Big Star existed for a brief period of time in the early 1970s. They were spectacularly unsuccessful during their lifetime due to poor promotion and distribution. But their influence has spread far and wide – the group have […]
Because I was a teenager through the 1990s, my relationship with the decade’s music is a little different; I’d probably appreciate bands like Oasis and Nirvana more if I wasn’t saturated with them. I also think that mainstream rock largely ran out of steam, and the most interesting music is on […]
Richard Thompson left Fairport Convention after 1970’s Full House, his reputation secured as an excellent songwriter and guitarist. He released a spectacularly unsuccessful solo album, Henry the Human Fly, in 1972. He then married Linda Peters and they released six albums between 1974 and 1982; their relationship broke down before […]
Introduction Born in London, Cleopatra Nikolic’s parents met in a jazz band – her Jamaican dad plays bass and piano, while her Serbian/Spanish mother sings and plays guitar and flute. Cleo Sol was inspired to take up music by Stevie Wonder’s ‘Don’t You Worry ‘Bout A Thing’. Early singles like […]
The members of The dB’s are all from Winston-Salem, North Carolina, also the birthplace of Mitch Easter (Let’s Active) and Ben Folds. As teens, future dB’s Chris Stamey and Peter Holsapple joined Easter in a band named Rittenhouse Square, playing Wishbone Ash covers and recording a six-song album. Holsapple also […]
Americana artist Gillian Welch was born in New York and adopted by a pair of comedy music entertainers. Welch later learned that her mother may have grown up in the mountains of North Carolina, possibly an explanation for how her music is able to tap into a bygone era. Songs […]
Blog Posts
I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:
Power-pop legend Matthew Sweet was born in Nebraska, but moved to Athens, Georgia, to join the local alt-rock scene. He recorded two unsuccessful records in the 1980s, before his 1991 breakthrough Girlfriend. The record showcased the brilliant lead guitar of Richard Lloyd and Robert Quine, as well as Sweet’s warm […]
Jeff Buckley is best known for his sensitive reading of Leonard Cohen’s ‘Hallelujah’. It’s well done, but taken alone it undersells Buckley’s immense talents. Far more than a crooner, he was also a talented guitarist and a sophisticated songwriter – other artists were capable of a lovely cover of ‘Hallelujah’, […]
The Beach Boys emerged from Hawthorne California, with Brian, Carl, and Dennis Wilson, along with their cousin Mike Love. Their first top ten hit was ‘Surfin’ USA’, derived from Chuck Berry’s ‘Sweet Little Sixteen’, but the group’s ornate harmonies oozed with musicality. Brian Wilson soon developed into an outstanding composer […]
There’s a stereotype in popular music of youth and charisma, but not everyone fits the mould. Here are five very talented individuals whose personal style choices are more suited to the public library than to the pop charts. Lisa Loeb I’ve never heard anything else that Loeb’s released, but ‘Stay […]
Todd Rundgren emerged in the late 1960s as guitarist and songwriter for the Philadelphia rock band The Nazz. He’s scored a few recognisable hits – the early 1970s soft-rock of ‘Hello, It’s Me’ and ‘I Saw the Light’, as well as the goofy 1980s singalong ‘Bang the Drum All Day’. […]
If I were in charge, The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame would have capped membership years ago. There’d be a small and select field of fifty entrants, limiting it to household names like Elvis Presley, James Brown, and The Beatles. But it’s soldiered on, with 351 inductees to date. […]
I agree with you on the Husker Du/ Mould solo vs Sugar. I haven’t done any thinking on it but I’d have a hard time I think coming up with an album I liked more than Workbook the year it came out- 1988 if I recall correctly? Easily the album I played most that year. Loved Husker Du-
Workbook is 1989 – I’d definitely take Pixies Doolittle over it in terms of alt-rock.
Doolittle was a good one.. looking at the list of albums from 1989 I think on second thought my favorite is Lou Reed-New York.
Patch The Sky was brilliant. This is a top drawer jam too. Beaster is the business Copper Blue is the CEO
Yeah, I’ve heard Patch the Sky is good – I have almost everything up through 1994, then nothing – guess I should go a bit deeper one day.
Nice point about a stellar b-side being too much of a good thing – I feel that way with the cure’s “a pink dream.” among my favourites, but it wasn’t needed on Wild Mood Swings for similar reasons
Do you have any recommendations for a Cure b-side? They have a lot of good ones, I’ve heard, but I only really know their big 1980s albums.
I think I have most of the 90s singles, they all have good non-album b-sides. The Mint Car single is my favourite of the lot (with b-sides ‘waiting’ and ‘a pink dream’)
Man do I like that sound. I might have told you that i seen Bob on an episode of Austin City Limits a few years ago. Fantastic. And yes ‘Patch The Sky’ is good. catchgroove is a big Mould guy and has lots of good pieces on him. Good choice on this one.
Excellent choice.
If you have any bsides you want to recommend for the series, let me know!
Thank you. the one that springs to mind is:
Tori Amos – Silent All Those Years
I love that song. I am mainly thinking of non-album b-sides though.
Sorry, I mean the Bside of it – the cover of ‘Smells Like Teen Spirit’.
Great pick. I first heard this one as part of the Copper Blue deluxe a few years back.
As for Sugar vs. Hüsker Du vs. Mould solo, I gravitate towards Sugar. Copper Blue and (especially) Beaster were huge for me; a pal introduced me to them and really turned me on to Mould’s stuff.
I can’t remember what my first Mould album was, but it might well have been Husker Du’s Warehouse Songs and Stories. Even though it’s certainly not Hart’s best stuff, I like having him there to balance Mould.
I think that was my first Hüsker Dü hit. I’d certainly agree that it was good having Hart’s contributions there too.
The importance of Beaster to me is really the sole reason Sugar is my favourite Mould stuff. Copper Blue too. I’ve never cared for File Under Easy Listening, though.
Warehouse has a bunch of songs that pretty much set the course for Sugar – less punky, more mainstream alternative guitar rock.
File Under Easy Listening has a couple of songs I really like – Panama City Hotel has an acoustic jangle that makes it stand out, and Explode and Make Up is a great closer.