Lindsey Buckingham Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

It’s difficult to blame Lindsey Buckingham for having a chip on his shoulder. He’s the studio mastermind, the live spark, and the restless creator behind the imperious pop era of Fleetwood Mac. But Buckingham is little known by the general public, for whom Stevie Nicks and Mick Fleetwood are the most recognisable faces in the band. Whenever he makes a solo album, it sells a fraction of a Fleetwood Mac or solo Stevie Nicks record. But his solo career has been very satisfying – if you’re a fan of his work in Fleetwood Mac, it’s worth spending time with his solo albums.

Buckingham’s solo work is more mainstream than you might expect based on his experimental songs on Fleetwood Mac’s Tusk. While Law and Order employs the garage rock of his contributions to Fleetwood Mac albums like Tusk and Mirage, 1984’s Go Insane is surprisingly heavy on synth-pop and 1992’s Out of the Cradle is lush like a Fleetwood Mac record. In the 21st century, his records have been more reliant on his acoustic guitar skills.

Lindsey Buckingham will be most remembered for the trio of pop albums he made in the 1970s with Fleetwood Mac – the band reboot on the 1975 self-titled record, the blockbuster Rumours from 1977, and 1979’s decidedly weirder Tusk. But his solo career is an excellent companion piece for his Fleetwood Mac work – here are his solo albums ranked from worst to best:


#7 Law And Order

Buckingham’s first solo album feels like a reaction to the months of painstaking studio time that went into shaping Rumours and Tusk – it’s a fun, garage-rock album that throws in a handful of covers from his father’s collection of 45s. Law and Order is often retro, with Buckingham’s originals like ‘Mary Lee Jones’ fitting beside covers like ‘A Satisfied Mind’ and ‘September Song’. Law and Order is often slight, but it features Buckingham’s best-known solo song, the dreamy, neurotic new wave of ‘Trouble’.

#6 Lindsay Buckingham

Buckingham’s seventh solo album precipitated his firing from Fleetwood Mac, after he requested delaying a band tour to promote it. It’s more adventurous than any solo album he’s made since the 1980s – it’s fun to hear his guitar against a breakbeat in ‘Swan Song’. But Buckingham’s voice has lost its suppleness with age and his vocal melodies aren’t exciting – his guitar work is the main drawcard at this point of his career.

#5 Under The Skin

Buckingham spent much of the 1990s working on a solo album that was eventually split into three different records – at his record company’s insistence, it was cherry-picked for songs for Fleetwood Mac’s 2003 album Say You Will, while the other songs turned up on here and 2008’s Gift Of Screws. Emerging fourteen years after Out of the Cradle, Under The Skin is often hushed and acoustic, hinging on Buckingham’s gorgeous fingerpicking. Despite gorgeous covers of The Rolling Stones’ ‘I Am Waiting’ and Donovan’s ‘Try For The Sun’, Under The Skin is sometimes too low key – when Mick Fleetwood and John McVie play on the jaunty ‘Down On Rodeo’, it’s like a breath of fresh air.


#4 Seeds We Sow

Buckingham was in his sixties when he recorded his sixth solo album. It’s in the vein of his previous two records – the acoustic fare of Under The Skin and the popcraft of Gift of Screws. While it’s the first Buckingham album that feels like a retread, it’s still accomplished and vital. The pretty ‘When She Comes Down’ is reminiscent of the traditional staple ‘Wild Mountain Thyme’, while the warm, harmonised ‘End of Time’ would have made a good Fleetwood Mac song.


#3 Go Insane

In 1984, Buckingham embraced synthesisers and drum machines for his second solo record, like he’s been listening to Prince. It’s a product of its time, but the pop hooks are there on songs like ‘I Must Go’ and ‘I Want You’. There’s more esoteric fare, like the ‘D.W. Suite’, a tribute to Beach Boy Dennis Wilson, who’d dated Fleetwood Mac’s Christine McVie, while ‘Loving Cup’ is lusty and direct.


#2 Gift of Screws

Gift of Screws has some of the hushed acoustic guitar-based songs of Under the Skin, but the lasting impression is from the jangly pop songs in the centre of the record like ‘Love Runs Deeper’ and ‘Did You Miss Me’. The record’s a family affair; Buckingham’s wife penned the lyrics to several songs, while his son wrote the melody to opener ‘Great Day’. My favourite is the intense, bluesy riff of ‘Wait For You’, with Fleetwood and McVie as the rhythm section.


#1 Out of the Cradle

Buckingham’s most polished, Fleetwood Mac-like album was recorded while he was on hiatus from the band. It’s mostly warm, pretty, mid-tempo pop-rock songs like ‘Countdown’ and ‘Surrender The Rain’, although the prickly ‘Wrong’ addresses over-embellished rumours in Mick Fleetwood’s recent autobiography. It was dedicated to Buckingham’s recently deceased older brother Gregory, a silver medallist in swimming in the 1968 Olympics.

Are you a fan of Buckingham’s solo work? Do you have a favourite?

Read More:


Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.


    • That’s a bit of a collector’s item, right? I heard it hasn’t been reissued since 1973, and you’d think there’d be a market with Fleetwood Mac’s subsequent success. I think Buckingham’s songwriting got better afterwards – it’s probably my least favourite studio album that he’s done. He’s been pretty consistent as a solo artist, so if you like him, it’s probably worth a punt on any of his solo discs.

  1. Lindsey is one of my favourite musicians and my ranking is pretty much the same as yours, Out of the Cradle is one of my all time favourite albums, although I would put Under The Skin a little higher. The progression of his solo sound is very interesting, and goes hand in hand with his development in Fleetwood Mac. Underrated that’s for sure!

  2. i always thought rusk was lindseys grand statement that he didnt quite have the artistic or emotional maturity to pull off. i think it got away on him. when i heard out of the cradle thats when i got l lindsey buckingham. its what tusk should have been. its by far the best solo album from fleetwood mac.

    • I feel like there’s some other decent solo Fleetwood Mac out there – maybe Welch or Green? I’ve never liked Nicks’ solo stuff enough to check an album out.

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Townes Van Zandt Live at the Old Quarter
Townes Van Zandt Album Reviews

Born into a high-profile Texas oil family, Townes Van Zandt was groomed as Texas governor, but inspired by songwriters like Bob Dylan, he dropped out of college in the 1960s to pursue a musical career. Of MENSA level intelligence, and diagnosed as a manic-depressive in his early twenties, Van Zandt […]
Erika de Casier Album Reviews

Smooth R&B artist Erika de Casier was born in Portugal with a Belgian mother and Cape Verdean father. She’s now based in Copenhagen, Denmark, starting her career working in a kindergarten. She spent time in the duo Saint Cava – they never released a full-length album but played the Roskilde […]
Jimmy Webb Album Reviews

Jimmy Webb wasn’t the only prominent person to enjoy success as a songwriter in the 1960s before launching a career as a singer. Isaac Hayes, Carole King, and Neil Diamond all followed similar paths. As a songwriter, I rate Webb among the 1960s greats – like Brian Wilson, Stevie Wonder, […]
Crosby, Stills & Nash 1969 Debut
Crosby, Stills & Nash Album Reviews

David Crosby, Stephen Stills, and Graham Nash all started their careers in other notable 1960s bands. Crosby left The Byrds after disagreements over counter-cultural songs like ‘Triad’ and ‘Mind Gardens’, Stills’ Buffalo Springfield broke up after tensions with band-mate Neil Young, while Nash left The Hollies after their decision to […]
Television Marquee Moon
Television Album Reviews

There were a plethora of musical acts that originated from the CBGBs club in New York in the mid-1970s; The Ramones, Talking Heads, Patti Smith, and Blondie all went on to achieve acclaim, while all occupying different niches in the punk and new wave spectrum. Television are the least well-known […]
Tyler, The Creator Album Reviews

Tyler Gregory Okonma, better known as Tyler, the Creator, has enjoyed a rapid career evolution over the last decade. He’s of Igbo ancestry on his father’s side. He started as a brash teenager, gaining attention with his provocative lyrics for hip hop crew Odd Future. Along the way, he’s toned […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

10 Best ABBA Songs

Swedish quartet ABBA were massively popular from the mid-1970s to the early 1980s. They were effectively a supergroup when they formed in 1972 – Agnetha Fältskog was already a solo star in Sweden while songwriting team Björn Ulvaeus and Benny Andersson had served their apprenticeships in 1960s folk acts. The […]
10 Best Albums of 2022

Even in 2022, the COVID-19 pandemic still looms large over popular music. Many of these albums were affected by events – forcing delays or changes in personnel. As always, there was a wealth of excellent music recorded in 2022 – here are my ten favourites that I covered through this […]
The Go-Betweens Send Me A Lullaby
The Go-Betweens: Albums Ranked from Worst To Best

Brisbane’s The Go-Betweens are one of my favourite bands, but it’s sometimes difficult to explain their appeal. Robert Forster and Grant McLennan are limited as guitarists and vocalists, but they balance each other beautifully; the edgier Forster was a fan of The Velvet Underground, while McLennan was a fan of […]
Television Adventure
10 Best Television Songs

The band Television emerged from the same CBGB scene that produced Talking Heads, The Ramones, Blondie, and Patti Smith. The group was started by Tom Verlaine, Richard Hell, and drummer Billy Ficca. Verlaine and Ficca were childhood friends, while Hell met Verlaine at high school in Delaware. Hell was replaced […]
Joni Mitchell Clouds
Joni Mitchell: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

Joni Mitchell emerged at a time when the women’s rights movement was still building steam and had to fight for recognition as a serious artist. Her image was often defined in terms of whom she was dating – a Rolling Stone article dubbed her “The Queen of El Lay”. As Mitchell’s […]
Genesis Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Originating at Charterhouse School, one of England’s most prestigious public schools, Genesis recorded their first album as teenagers in 1968. They spent their early years losing money and making long-winded progressive rock albums. Their use of gentle 12-string guitars and bass pedals, coupled with Peter Gabriel’s wordplay, gave them a distinctive […]
%d bloggers like this: