Wilco Kicking Television

Album Battle – Wilco vs Radiohead

A game I like to play on my cycle commute from work is figuring out the best band of each ten year era. For instance, The Beatles and Bob Dylan are contenders for 1960-1970, while 1985-1995 has a few contestants, including Pixies, Sonic Youth, and Public Enemy.

I’ve been covering Chicago’s Wilco recently on my blog, and their best decade was 1995-2005, during which they released their first five studio albums, as well as two collaborations with Billy Bragg. Over this ten year period they evolved from the straightforward alt-country of 1995’s A.M. to 2004’s experimental A Ghost Is Born.

But plenty of other acts had great album catalogues during the same era; PJ Harvey, Bjork, Sloan, Ween, and Air are all strong candidates, and I’m sure I’m forgetting others. But I’ve decided to pit Wilco against acclaimed Oxford band Radiohead, who established their career with second album The Bends in 1995. It seems tidiest to compare the band’s first six albums – so Radiohead’s catalogue from 1993’s Pablo Honey to 2003’s Hail To The Thief. and Wilco’s from 1995’s A.M. to 2007’s Sky Blue Sky.

Round 1: A.M. (1995) vs Pablo Honey (1993)
This is the battle of the two underwhelming debut albums – both were derivative: Wilco stuck to lightweight alt-country, while Pablo Honey is generic 1990’s alternative. It’s very close, and they’re easily my least two favourite albums on the list – but I give it to Wilco, as I’d rather listen to generic alt-country than generic alternative. Wilco 1, Radiohead 0.

Round 2: Being There (1996) vs The Bends (1995)
Both bands grew markedly after their debut; Wilco’s Jeff Tweedy gained an excellent collaborator in Jay Bennett, while Radiohead matured and became far more interesting. Both of these are favourites, but Wilco’s Being There takes this for me – if nothing else, there’s more of it to love. Wilco 2, Radiohead 0.

Round 3: Summerteeth (1999) vs OK Computer (1997)
I find both of these albums a little overrated – I find the poppy sound of Summerteeth a poor fit for Wilco, while OK Computer simply can’t live up to the greatest album ever hype, and has a little bit of filler. But OK Computer clearly wins this for me. Wilco 2, Radiohead 1.

Round 4: Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (2002) vs Kid A (2000)
Again, two of the groups’ best albums are drawn against each other – both show their respective bands delving further into electronic soundscapes, with Radiohead in particular going away from conventional songwriting with an emphasis on rhythm and sound-sculpting. Two terrific albums, but I’ll give this to Kid AWilco 2, Radiohead 2.

Round 5: A Ghost Is Born (2004) vs Amnesiac (2001)
Both bands followed up with their acclaimed album with albums that were similarly experimental, but less highly regarded. A Ghost Is Born is a little messy, but has some of my all time favourite Wilco songs, while Amnesiac feels like leftovers from Kid AWilco 3, Radiohead 2.

Round 6: Sky Blue Sky (2007) vs Hail to the Thief (2003)
I’ve come around to Sky Blue Sky a little – there’s a lot of craft beneath the smooth veneer, and there are great songs like ‘Impossible Germany’. But Hail to the Thief sounds like the work of a band still in its prime, and is the easy winner here. Wilco 3, Radiohead 3.

That leaves us locked in at 3-3. You could argue that Wilco has a couple of great albums in the Mermaid Avenue series that could be used as a tie-breaker, but at the same time, Radiohead have a ton of great non-album material from the same era. I think the fairest thing to do is to discount the debut battle – I regard A.M. and Pablo Honey as warm-ups, and not essential to either band’s catalogue.

That gives Radiohead the victory, 3-2, and I think it’s deserved. If asked to pick a personal favourite, I’d take the more sincere Wilco any time – but the excellent and consistent Radiohead deserve the official title.

Who do you think wins? Can another act take down Radiohead as champions of the 1995-2005 era?


Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.


  1. Nice idea for a head to head matchup – I suppose the initial 3-3 tie is a fitting result, they’re both wonderful!
    Personally, Radiohead would be my pick for that 10-year era, not sure if anyone else is close for that 95-05 range.

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Ray LaMontagne Album Reviews

Ray LaMontagne worked in a shoe factory in Maine. One morning he was woken by his alarm at 4am for work. The alarm clock’s radio served up Stephen Stills’ ‘Treetop Flyer’. At that instant, LaMontagne decided to become a musician. It took him more than a decade from this epiphany […]
Scott Walker Album Reviews

Scott Walker was born Noel Scott Engel, in Hamilton, Ohio. A former child actor, he left his career as a singer to become a session bassist. In 1965 Walker moved to London with his band The Walker Brothers. Scott became the focal point of the trio, fronting the number one […]
Caroline Polachek Album Reviews

Caroline Polachek grew up in Connecticut and was formerly the vocalist for the indie-pop duo Chairlift. Chairlift enjoyed a surprise hit in 2008 with ‘Bruises’, which featured in an Apple commercial. Polachek’s previously flirted with a solo career, releasing albums under the aliases Ramona Lisa and CEP, but 2019’s Pang was her […]
Marlon Williams Album Reviews

Marlon WIlliams grew up in Lyttleton, New Zealand. He toured Europe as a member of the choir of the Cathedral of the Blessed Sacrament and started playing guitar in high school. His band The Unfaithful Ways, formed with two friends and his school’s science teacher, were successful. They released the […]
Nilüfer Yanya Album Reviews

Indie artist Nilüfer Yanya was born in Chelsea, West London. She’s the daughter of two visual artists, with Turkish, Irish and Barbadian heritage. Yanya grew up listening to her father’s Turkish music and her mother’s classical, but gravitated to the guitar in adolescence. She rejected the offer to join a […]
Radiohead OK Computer
1990s Album Reviews

Because I was a teenager through the 1990s, my relationship with the decade’s music is a little different; I’d probably appreciate bands like Oasis and Nirvana more if I wasn’t saturated with them. I also think that mainstream rock largely ran out of steam, and the most interesting music is on […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

Queen Made In Heaven
Queen Albums: Ranked from Worst To Best

Queen formed in 1970 in London, originally a hard rock band with shades of progressive rock and metal. They adapted as musical fashions changed; they flirted with disco on 1982’s Hot Space and produced stripped-down, synthesizer-fuelled pop hits on 1984’s The Works. But over their twenty-year recording career, certain hallmarks […]
10 Best Yellow Magic Orchestra Songs

Harry Hosono recruited keyboardist Ryuichi Sakamoto and drummer Yukihiro Takahashi to record a quickie cover of the 1950s exotica tune ‘Firecracker’. The trio quickly became superstars in Japan, and influential elsewhere. The austere electronica of Kraftwerk was a major influence, but the three members of Yellow Magic Orchestra brought a […]
Hokey Pokey Richard and Linda Thompson
Richard and Linda Thompson Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

English folk-rock duo Richard and Linda Thompson’s career resembled a soap opera. Active as recording artists between 1974 and 1982, they married, released three albums in quick succession, then spent three years in a Sufi Muslim commune where Richard’s religious leader forbade him from playing music. Leaving the commune, their […]
Jason Isbell Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

If you’re an old man, shouting at the clouds about how modern music isn’t the same as it was in your heyday, you would probably enjoy the recent output of Jason Isbell. Isbell’s an Americana artist, whose sincere albums are timeless and elegant, and could have been made any time […]
Jackson Browne's 1970s Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Jackson Browne is the quintessential 1970s singer-songwriter, a sensitive individual who analysed his difficult relationships into songs. He was extremely well connected into the 1970s soft-rock scene – he dated Laura Nyro and Joni Mitchell, wrote the Eagles‘ first hit single, and produced Warren Zevon’s breakthrough album. Primarily, Browne’s a […]
10 Best Albums of 2022

Even in 2022, the COVID-19 pandemic still looms large over popular music. Many of these albums were affected by events – forcing delays or changes in personnel. As always, there was a wealth of excellent music recorded in 2022 – here are my ten favourites that I covered through this […]
%d bloggers like this: