Maggie Rogers Album Reviews

Margaret Debay Rogers grew up in Maryland, the daughter of a Ford salesman and a nurse. She began learning the harp at seven and writing songs by thirteen. In high school she indulged a wide range of musical interests, playing the harp in the orchestra, singing in the choir, learning the banjo, and dabbling in jazz. Before her major label debut album Heard It In A Past Life, Rogers self-released two folk albums in 2012 and 2014.

Introduction

Rogers discovered dance music while clubbing in Berlin. She started to blend folk and dance music, and while studying with Pharrell Williams at New York University, she played him a song she’d written. Williams’ reaction to ‘Alaska’ went viral, and three years later ‘Alaska’ has been included on Rogers’ major-label debut album, Heard It In A Past Life.

Maggie Rogers Album Reviews

The Echo

2012, not rated


Blood Ballet

2014, not rated
I’ve never heard Rogers’ first two self-released albums. They’re not available in full on Spotify – instead, the highlights are compiled on to the compilation Notes From The Archive: Recordings 2011-2016.


Heard It In A Past Life

2019, 8/10
For all the talk of blending folk and dance, I don’t hear a lot of folk on Heard It in a Past Life. The finished product is essentially an electronic pop album, reminiscent of HAIM’s more synthetic moments. Rogers’s voice is a beautiful instrument – it’s warm yet authoritative. Her backing vocals are often used as an instrument – ‘The Knife’ features beautifully arranged choirs of Rogers’ voice.

There are plenty of nice tunes on Heard It in a Past Life, although Rogers’ lyrics are lacking in personality. There’s lots of twenty-something romantic ennui – hardly unusual territory for pop music, but it would be nice to hear this lovely voice put to better use.

With the synthetic sounds, often the up-tempo songs sound better. ‘Give A Little’ is supposedly inspired by school anti-gun protests (“Drop your weapons, drop your guard”), but still sounds like a relationship song. ‘Overnight’ sounds closest to Haim’s template, while ‘Past Life’ is the only song that breaks significantly from electro-pop, with a sparse piano backing. The sparse live version of ‘Fallingwater’ allows Rogers’ voice to shine better than the studio take.

Heard It in a Past Life was released in January 2019, and Rogers has already released newer material – ‘Love You For A Long Time’ sounds closer to the promised folk/dance crossover. She hopefully has an even better album in her; with a great voice and some sharp melody writing skills I’ll be watching Maggie Rogers’ career with interest.


Notes From The Archive: Recordings 2011-2016

2020, 7/10
In this era, with easy access to recording technology, it’s common for artists to self-release albums in their teens. If they get a record deal, they then relegate these early efforts out of their canon. Rogers has taken the approach of cherry-picking highlights from her early releases for Notes from the Archive. As you’d expect, it’s all over the place stylistically and it’s uneven. But it’s also a worthwhile endeavour – Rogers’ vocals are reliably lovely, and there are a couple of first-rate songs.

On Twitter, Rogers wrote about ‘James’ “He’s one of my best friends to this day. He’s the trumpet player on ‘Satellite.'” It’s a lovely and evocative acoustic song – “may your snow-capped mountains carry you far” is a great line. ‘Wolves’ is from Rogers’ 2012 album The Echo, released when she was still in her teens. The strings from Katherine Haroldson and Courtney Chang are gorgeous. 2013’s ‘New Song’ debuted on the compilation, a duet between Rogers and Del Water Gap.

Repackaging her early work was a good move from Rogers, showcasing her best work before Heard it in a Past Life.


Surrender

2022, 9/10
Rogers has raised the bar with her second record, which pretty much does everything you want from a sophomore effort – it’s more confident and expansive. It comes off the back of some time away from music for Rogers – in 2021 she attended Harvard Divinity School, where she was “studying the spirituality of public gatherings and the ethics of power in pop culture.”

She’s brashly confident on the single ‘Want Want’, where she adds a pop edge without sounding contrived. Rogers is a gifted vocalist, and her soaring melodies on songs like ‘Honey’ and ‘Horses’ allow her to shine. Rogers is assisted by Kid Harpoon, a Kent-born producer who’s also worked with Jessie Ware, Harry Styles, and HAIM, and he helps her capture a range of sounds and emotions, from the lush R&B-flavoured ballad ‘Begging for Rain’ to the tough guitars on the sparse closer ‘Different Kind of World’.

Surrender has proved a successful second outing for Rogers, peaking just outside the Billboard top ten – she deserves stardom with her vocal and songwriting chops.


Don’t Forget Me

2024, 8.5/10
Rogers started her career strongly with Heard It In A Past Life. But she keeps getting better. Her rootsy pop doesn’t reinvent the wheel, but she does everything well. She writes memorable tunes, sings beautifully, with just a hint of grit, and provides enough stylistic variation to stay engaging.

Rogers works with Ian Fitchuk on her third album. Fitchuk is a Nashville-based producer and musician, who has worked with Kacey Musgraves. Rogers and Fitchuk are almost self-contained, handling the songwriting, production, and most instrumentation.

‘So Sick of Dreaming’ with its sparkling sound and vocal harmonies is reminiscent of Fleetwood Mac’s Tango in the Night era. It also works when she adds a dance beat behind her songs, like in the opener ‘It Was Coming All Along’, or in ‘On & On & On’.

Rogers saves the best song for last, with the title track. Her voice suits the country-tinged chorus, while it starts with a great verse:

My friend Sally’s getting married
And to me that sounds so scary
I’m still tryin’ to clean up my side of the street
Can’t imagine what would happen
‘Cause I’m still acting out of habit
Hoping dirty words just don’t escape my teeth

Rogers isn’t doing anything groundbreaking, but she’s making excellent music nonetheless.

Best Maggie Rogers Songs

Don’t Forget Me
So Sick of Dreaming
Love You For A Long Time
Alaska
Horses
Want Want
Give A Little
Wolves
Begging for Rain
James
It Was Coming All Along

Leave a Reply


Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

  • The Smiths Hatful of Hollow