The Blue Nile Album Reviews

The three members of The Blue Nile all attended Glasgow University in the late 1970s. Vocalist Paul Buchanan studied medieval history and literature, Robert Bell studied mathematics, and Paul Joseph Moore studied electronics. The three members found their synth-drenched, sophisticated style almost by accident. Unable to find a drummer and hampered by Buchanan’s lack of ability on the guitar, they found themselves playing atmospheric, electronic music out of necessity.

The band’s 1984 debut A Walk Across the Rooftops wasn’t a huge-seller initially, but it gained a devoted following, earning praise from fellow musicians like Peter Gabriel and Rickie Lee Jones. Buchanan’s voice is warm and soulful, and the band’s records are lovingly arranged. The band have been far from prolific, only releasing three more albums through to 2004’s High, while Buchanan released the solo album Mid Air in 2012.

The Blue Nile were influential on a younger generation of UK musicians – the introduction of The 1975‘s ‘Love It It We Made It’ has marked similarities to ‘Downtown Lights’, while Buchanan duetted with Jessie Ware on her 2017 album Glasshouse.

The Blue Nile Album Reviews

A Walk Across the Rooftops | Hats | Peace at Last | High | Mid Air (Paul Buchanan)

A Walk Across the Rooftops

1984, 8.5/10
The Blue Nile released an unsuccessful single, ‘I Love This Life’ in 1981, which disappeared when RSO Records went bankrupt. The group eventually released their debut album through Linn Records, the first record released on the label, as engineer Calum Malcolm had contacts in the company. It was a coincidence, but the group’s hi-fi, detailed music fitted naturally with Linn’s hi-fi brand. The seven tracks on A Walk Across the Rooftops took five months to record; the group’s attention to detail resulted in a sparse but beautifully crafted record that’s held up to passing trends.

The best-known song is ‘Tinseltown in the Rain’, a song where the mid-tempo pace is giddying compared with the glacial pace of the rest of the record. Buchanan delivers his most iconic lyric; “Do I love you ? Yes I love you/But it’s easy come, and it’s easy go.” The opening title track is a terrific mood setter, with its atmospheric synth strings, while ‘Stay’ is closest in tone to the soul music that’s a subtle but important part of The Blue Nile’s DNA.

Lovingly recorded, and topped with Buchanan’s yearning voice, A Walk Across the Rooftops transcends its era with some beautiful music.


1989, 10/10
After touring A Walk Across the Rooftops, The Blue Nile were sent straight back into the studio to record a follow-up. With no new material prepared, the sessions were tough and the tapes were scrapped. The group returned home to Glasgow, where ideas flowed more easily, and by the time that Castlesound studio was available two years later, the group had songs prepared that they were able to record quickly. The record follows the same elegant sophisti-pop template as A Walk Across the Rooftops, but with lusher sounds and more memorable songs, making Hats the pinnacle of The Blue Nile’s discography.

As a microcosm of what makes The Blue Nile work, closer ‘Saturday Night’ is a gorgeous song that would have lapsed into mawkish sentimentality in almost any other hands. But Buchanan elevates it to greatness with his yearning voice and his unexpected lyrics about how an “Ordinary girl will make the world alright.”

There’s more gorgeousness with the lovely melody and synth backdrop of ‘The Downtown Lights’, while ‘Headlights on Parade’ is elegantly shaded with tinkling synths. Buchanan gives a gorgeous vocal performance on the swooning ‘Let’s Go Out Tonight’. Balancing the pop-oriented songs, there’s more atmospheric material like ‘Over the Hillside’ and ‘Seven A.M.’

Hats is a career pinnacle for The Blue Nile, a band making gorgeous music that’s pitched perfectly with their pragmatic romanticism.

Peace at Last

1996, 7/10
Following the success of Hats, The Blue Nile were invited to work with Michael McDonald, Robbie Robertson, and Annie Lennox. Buchanan moved to L.A. for several years, where he was in a relationship with Rosanna Arquette. The Blue Nile’s third album continues the hallmarks of their signature sound, with the same sparse elegance, but Buchanan’s guitar is more prominent. Acoustic guitar is the primary instrument on songs like the opening ‘Happiness’ and the urgent strum of ‘Love Came Down’. The last three tracks feature a synthesizer-driven sound that’s akin to their earlier work, but Buchanan’s electric lead guitar is still prominent in ‘Soon’ and ‘God Bless You Kid’, where previously the sound was sparse.

The changes in instrumentation don’t affect the record’s quality – Peace at Last still follows the classy sophisti-pop lead of their previous albums, even if it’s more conventional. But the faster tempos and busier arrangements take away the band’s uniqueness, and the result’s an enjoyable record that doesn’t threaten the peaks of Hats.

The most memorable piece is the opening ‘Happiness’, with its gospel choir and the line “now that I’ve found peace at last/Tell me Jesus, will it last?” Christian themes are more prominent on Peace at Last; ‘Love Came Down’ opens with the lyrics “angels walking in the starlight”. The last two tracks of Peace at Last are the most familiar sounding to fans of the band’s first two records; in particular, ‘Soon’ slows down the tempo and turns up the synthesizers, backing a vulnerable, athletic vocal from Buchanan.

It doesn’t touch the peaks of their first two records, but Peace at Last is a worthwhile album that introduces new elements to the palette of The Blue Nile.


2004, 7.5/10
High capped off a 20-year recording career, during which The Blue Nile released 33 songs on studio albums, a snail-like pace of 1.65 songs per year. It’s a return to the stately synth-based sound of Hats. It might have been anachronistic in 2004, but in hindsight, it’s a fine addition to The Blue Nile’s catalogue.

It largely lacks the magic of their first two records, but the title track is excellent, utilising piano and Buchanan’s aching upper register. ‘I Would Never’ is memorable, one of the more conventional songs in The Blue Nile catalogue. The acoustic guitar of ‘Because of Toledo’ is the only textural change from the keyboard instruments that dominate High, while the soulful closer, ‘Stay Close’, is the longest piece in The Blue Nile’s catalogue.

High is likely to stand as The Blue Nile’s final album; PJ Moore is estranged from the other two members, and his stately electronics were a key part of the band’s sound. But Hats is a fine sign-off.

Paul Buchanan

Mid Air

Paul Buchanan Mid Air

2012, 8/10
Paul Buchanan released his solo debut at the age of 56. Its sparse elegance is a natural follow-up to The Blue Nile. Without Moore, the electronic textures are gone, and the songs are centred around piano, with a dash of orchestral instrumentation like the string filled ‘Fin de Siecle’. While The Blue Nile’s songs were often lengthy, the songs on Mid Air are short.

It’s difficult to pick highlights from Mid Air as, with short tracks and musical uniformity, it folds into one song cycle. The opening title track features a signature Buchanan couplet, romantic yet thought-provoking; “I want to live forever/And watch you dancing in the air”. Lyrically it’s even more oblique than The Blue Nile; one prominent line is “the cars are in the garden now.”

If you’re a fan of The Blue Nile, it’s worth checking in on Mid Air, Buchanan’s finest record since Hats.

Ten Best Blue Nile Songs

Saturday Night
Tinseltown in the Rain
The Downtown Lights
Headlights on Parade
A Walk Across the Rooftops
Let’s Go Out Tonight
I Would Never

Back to 1980s Album Reviews….


Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Tracy Chapman 1988 Debut
1980s Miscellany

This page collects odds and ends from 1980s artists: Beastie Boys | Tracy Chapman | Rush | Toto Beastie Boys Paul’s Boutique 1989, 9/10Paul’s Boutique was initially a commercial disappointment for hip hop trio the Beastie Boys after the enormous success of their 1986 debut Licensed To Ill, although it’s since been […]
The Band Music From Big Pink
1960s Album Reviews

Rock and roll launched in the 1950s, but in the 1960s the rock LP as an art form came into its own. Artists like The Beatles, Bob Dylan, and The Beach Boys are perennial favourites on greatest albums of all time lists. Rock and pop music became more complex in […]
Arcade Fire Album Reviews

For a band, there are essentially two different career trajectories for a recording career. Like Radiohead or The Beatles, you can start your career with a promising album and work your way up to your masterpiece. Or, like Montreal’s Arcade Fire, you can begin with your masterpiece and spend the […]
Portishead Dummy
Portishead Album Reviews

Portishead formed in the city of Bristol, where a vibrant, multi-cultural music scene spawned trip-hop in the early 1990s. Trip-hop took the beats from hip hop, and slowed them down, adding textures and songs. Alongside Portishead, essentially the entire trip-hip scene originated in Bristol, with Massive Attack and Tricky also […]
New Order Album Reviews

Joy Division‘s lead vocalist Ian Curtis took his own life on the eve of the band’s first US tour. The band rebranded as New Order – taking their name from a newspaper article titled The People’s New Order of Kampuchea. They added Gillian Gilbert, the girlfriend of drummer Stephen Morris, […]
Utopia Parkway Fountains of Wayne
Fountains of Wayne Album Reviews

Adam Schlesinger and Chris Collingwood met at Williams College in Massachusetts. They formed Fountains of Wayne, christening themselves after a garden furniture and statuary store in Wayne, New Jersey. Although the pair recorded their debut largely independently, they were joined on tour and on subsequent albums by guitarist Jody Porter […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

Red House Painters Ocean Beach
Red House Painters Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

The Red House Painters took their name from a Tennessee painting crew named The International League Of Revolutionary House Painters. Leader Mark Kozelek came from Ohio, but formed the band in San Francisco. Kozelek was joined by drummer Anthony Koutsos, bassist Jerry Vessel, and guitarist Gorden Mack – Mack left […]
Dire Straits Money for Nothing
Dire Straits Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

One glance at Mark Knopfler’s bandana will tell you that Dire Straits have never been a fashionable band. Emerging in 1978, at the height of punk, their literate bar-band rock appealed to conservative listeners not enamoured by the upstart sounds of The Sex Pistols and The Clash. Despite their lack […]
10 Best Nic Jones Songs

Nic Jones emerged in the fertile folk scene of the late 1960s. While contemporaries like Richard Thompson, Sandy Denny, and John Martyn ventured into pop and rock music, Jones remained stubbornly traditional. His first two albums, 1970’s Ballads & Songs and 1971’s Nic Jones, were austere, Jones playing solo in […]
Retrospective the best of Buffalo Springfield
10 Best Buffalo Springfield Songs

Californian folk-rock band Buffalo Springfield were short-lived but signicant. They recorded one of the defining protest songs of the 1960s, ‘For What It’s Worth’, and launched the careers of Neil Young, Stephen Stills, Richie Furay of Poco, and Jim Messina of Loggins and Messina. Buffalo Springfield’s lineup was fluid – the temperamental Young […]
ABBA: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

In November 2021, ABBA released their ninth studio album Voyage. It was the Swedish quartet’s first studio album in almost 40 years – an unprecedented gap in output for a superstar group. It’s not the longest gap between releases – niche groups like The Sonics, Fanny, Strawberry Alarm Clock, and […]
Taylor Swift’s Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Taylor Swift is a megastar, and her profile as a celebrity can overshadow her musical abilities. Opinions on Swift are wildly diverse. In some quarters, she’s dismissed as disposable music for teenage girls. In others, she’s highly respected as a songwriter and recording artist. Swift is an adept songwriter, particularly […]
%d bloggers like this: