Skip to content

Simon and Garfunkel – Worst to Best

Simon and Garfunkel Bridge Over Troubled Water

Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel started their recording career as Tom and Jerry, making teen-oriented Everly Brothers style pop. But by 1963, they’d re-branded as Simon and Garfunkel, and re-launched their career as an earnest trad-folk duo. Their debut album, 1964’s Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M., was unsuccessful, and Simon relocated to London. But a Simon penned track ‘The Sound of Silence’ slowly gained a following, and producer Tom Wilson overdubbed guitar, bass, and drums on it. Despite not knowing about the re-release, Simon and Garfunkel had a number one hit in early 1966, and hastily reconvened, rush releasing a second album to capitalise on their sudden popularity.

Their golden era of albums started with 1966’s Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme. With more studio time, the duo’s sound is more detailed and ornate, and they continued through their last two albums; 1968’s Bookends and 1970’s Bridge Over Troubled Water. The duo fractured in 1970 over tensions fuelled by Garfunkel filming Catch-22 in Mexico while Simon was recording Bridge.

The pair have reformed for live performances and recorded two songs in the 1970s – ‘My Little Town’ appeared on both of the duo’s 1975 solo albums, while the second release of Garfunkel’s 1977 album Watermark featured a cover version of ‘(What a) Wonderful World’, with James Taylor singing alongside the duo. But their attempt at a full blown reunion album failed – Simon released the sessions as a solo album, 1983’s Hearts and Bones.

So Simon and Garfunkel’s legacy is essentially five studio albums, released between 1964 and 1970. This is how I rank them:

#5 – Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M. (1964)

Wednesday Morning 3.a.m. Simon and GarfunkelDespite a handful of strong Paul Simon songs, Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M. is the odd one out in the duo’s discography. The upbeat folk covers like ‘You Can Tell The World’ and ‘Go Tell It On The Mountain’ and the incongruously joyful reading of Dylan’s ‘The Times They Are A’Changin” are at odds with the group’s usual introspection. Simon’s originals like the title track and the original, acoustic ‘The Sound of Silence’ are the album’s highlights.

#4 – Sounds of Silence (1966)

Simon and Garfunkel - Sounds of SilenceThe duo’s second album was quickly pieced together to capitalise on the popularity of ‘The Sound of Silence’. There’s strong material like ‘I Am A Rock’ and ‘Kathy’s Song, but also obvious filler like the guitar instrumental ‘Anji’ and rote lyrics from Simon on ‘A Most Peculiar Man’ and ‘Richard Corey’.

#3 – Parsley, Sage, Rosemary, and Thyme (1966)

Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme - Simon and GarfunkelA huge step up from the duo’s first two albums, a less hurried schedule allowed the group to stretch out in the studio. There’s brilliance like the beautifully harmonised folk song ‘Scarborough Fair’, and the jazzy groove of ’59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin’ Groovy)’ uses Dave Brubeck’s rhythm section. Simon’s lyrics occasionally overreach, on songs like ‘The Dangling Conversation’.

#2 – Bridge Over Troubled Water (1970)

Simon and Garfunkel Bridge Over Troubled WaterThe duo’s final album is half brilliant pop epics like ‘The Only Living Boy In New York’ and ‘El Condor Pasa’, and half charming throwaways like ‘Baby Driver’ and the cover of ‘Bye Bye Love’. Some of the throwaways work brilliantly too – ‘Cecilia’ is one of the group’s most popular songs – but it’s hard for the lesser songs not to be overshadowed by tracks like ‘The Boxer’ and the epic gospel of the title track. In interesting trivia, there were at least two movies released in 2017 using song titles from this record; ‘Baby Driver’ and ‘The Only Living Boy In New York’.

#1 – Bookends (1968)

Simon and Garfunkel BookendsSimon and Garfunkel’s most consistent work is a concept album about ageing; at least on the first side, the second side is leftovers from their soundtrack for The Graduate. ‘Mrs Robinson’ and ‘America’ are the most well known songs, but there are plenty of great album tracks like ‘Punky’s Dilemma’ and ‘Overs’.

Do you have a favourite album from the duo?

10 thoughts on “Simon and Garfunkel – Worst to Best Leave a comment

  1. Unaccustomed as I am to agreeing with the vast majority, I have to say Bridge Over Troubled Water is the best S&G album. Leaving aside the portentous, anthemic (or perhaps overblown and tedious are the words I’m searching for) title track, it’s the one where Simon finally gets his identity sorted out after the false starts of the previous three albums.
    The Only Living Boy In New York is a beautiful combination of wistfulness and power that is worth the price of 12 inches of vinyl on its own.
    The Boxer is a trademark Simon tale that hints at his future solo work and Cecilia, while rather jagged compared to its stablemates, is kind of joyful.
    But So Long Frank Lloyd Wright is, for me, the masterpiece. I believe it came about when Garfunkel, having established that his friend believed he could write about anything in the world, dared him to celebrate the seminal architect, and Simon rose to the challenge. For me it’s one of those late night, one-more-before-bed songs when you’re reveling in the brilliance of the music you’re lucky enough to know.
    The role of Art Garfunkel in this act always slightly disturbed me. Lovely pure voice, certainly, but if I was Paul Simon I wouldn’t have given someone else my beautiful songs to sing. I would want my own voice to be the one that took “America” to the people. Maybe he was just too nice to ditch his old friend, or lacked the confidence to do it all himself on those early albums. But Dylan was doing it, Joni Mitchell was doing it and Simon managed it later.
    Anyway, that’s beside the point. The pre-Bridge albums all contain some great stuff, but this is the full banquet,

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Big S&G fan. I could live with your order or I could flip one and two. Great, great stuff and I’m certainly a fan of Simon’s solo work. We saw him live a few years back and he seems to free himself up to have a little more fun when he’s solo. One of the greatest songwriters of all time IMHO.

    Liked by 1 person

    • They were my first favourite band – I found my mum’s cassette of Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme, and played it lots. Heard it so much that I don’t even need a copy now – it’s kind of burned into my brain.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Sound Sniffer

Sniffing out the best new music


seeker of wisdom


or, Thoughts in Woods on Snowy Evening

Art by Rob Goldstein

There is no common truth

Up the Down Turn

Musings, Depression and Life Management

Alex Swift Blogging

opinions and analysis on media and entertainment, new and old

Diary of a Bassist

Musical musings of a bassist/power metal enthusiast

%d bloggers like this: