A gentle-sounding English folk-artist, Nick Drake hardly made a ripple during his short lifetime. He was too shy to play live and barely sold a record. Posthumously, his small catalogue has earned plenty of attention; his delicate and measured approach produced some of the most timeless music of his generation. A talented guitarist with a gentle voice that’s perfect for his material, it’s difficult to dislike Drake’s sensitive approach. While he can become monotonous if you’re not in the mood for his elegant ramblings, it takes a cynical mind to completely dismiss his unassuming talent.
All three of his albums are different in character; debut Five Leaves Left is autumnal folk with strings, Bryter Layter has more dynamic arrangements with Drake using a rhythm section, while Pink Moon is rawer with Drake alone with an acoustic guitar. Throughout his short career, Drake was remarkably consistent; I count one substandard song on his three studio albums, the generic ‘Know’ from Pink Moon. There are also some albums of out-takes, but they’re not as essential as his studio recordings.
While Drake’s become a cult figure, he enjoyed very little success in his lifetime – he had difficulties playing live, partly because he was a self-taught guitarist who employed a lot of different tunings and had to re-tune between songs. But he’s since been recognised as a unique talent, and a lot of his music has a timeless quality – his hushed delivery feels apiece to 21st-century Indie records.
1969, 9/10 Five Leaves Left is my least favourite of Drake’s three studio albums, but it’s still a gorgeous and mystical near-masterpiece. Drake and his acoustic guitar are the heart of the record, but he does enjoy various accompaniments, with strings and with members of Pentangle and Fairport Convention. Drake accompanies himself on piano on ‘Saturday Sun’, while ‘Way To Blue’ drops Drake’s guitar altogether and just leaves the strings.
Favourites include the moody ‘Riverman’ and the subtle jazzy groove of ‘Man In A Shed’. Drake’s lyrics are beautifully innocent and effortless in a way that an intellectual like Paul Simon could never hope to achieve: “Betty said she prayed today/For the sky to blow away/Or maybe stay/She wasn’t sure” reads a couplet in ‘River Man’. But musically Five Leaves Left is actually a difficult album to decode – it’s much more complex and nuanced than you’d expect from a folk-based artist, with alternate guitar tunings and complex strings – after plenty of listens, there’s always something new to discover.
The album’s title was grimly prophetic; five leaves (years, if we’re going to be literal) later Drake accidentally overdosed on sleeping pills, only leaving two further albums for an almost flawless recorded legacy.
Bryter Layter
1971, 9.5/10 I’ve always wondered what it would have sounded like if Nick Drake had decided to plug in an electric guitar and rock; unfortunately, we don’t find out on Bryter Layter, or anywhere else in his catalogue. Like Five Leaves Left, Drake is again joined by Fairport Convention musicians and by strings, while John Cale is an important new contributor, adding beauty to gorgeous ballads ‘Fly’ and ‘Northern Sky’.
‘Northern Sky’ is a serious contender for the most beautiful song in the entire genre of popular music; Cale contributes lovely accompaniment on celeste, piano and organ, adding a lovely middle section that links the song’s two halves, while Drake breathes the elegantly enigmatic lyrics; “Been a long time that I’m waiting/Been a long time that I’m blown/I’ve been a long time that I’ve wandered/Through the people that I’ve known.” ‘Fly’ is almost as superb, bringing out the yearning in Drake’s voice. ‘At The Chime Of A City Clock’ and ‘One Of These Things First’ bring a jazzier touch, while the two separate parts of ‘Hazey Jane’ are alternately bright and soothing.
If there’s a quibble, the jazzy ‘Poor Boy’ drags a little at six and a half minutes, but Bryter Layter is still an album of almost unrivalled beauty.
Pink Moon
1972, 9/10 After the failure of his first two gorgeous and ornately arranged albums, Nick Drake went the opposite route with his third. Recorded by Drake, facing the wall in a deserted studio late at night, Pink Moonshowcases him at his rawest. Without all the strings in the arrangements, it’s a pleasure to be able to hear Drake’s guitar at the forefront; the only overdub is some piano on the title track. While Drake never raises his voice, there’s an unsettling intensity in the insistent strum of ‘Things Behind The Sun’ and the fragile beauty of the title track.
It’s the first half of Pink Moon that’s really captivating; the title track, which boosted Drake’s profile immeasurably after being featured in a car commercial, has a beautifully delicate melody that’s complemented by the simple piano line. ‘Road’ and ‘Place To Be’ are similarly pretty, while ‘Which Will’ is gently insistent. The second half doesn’t quite reach the same heights; the generic lyrics of ‘Know’ damage Drake’s mystique a little.
Sadly, Drake’s recording career ended at Pink Moon, after he overdosed on sleeping pills two years later, unappreciated at the time but now a revered figure.
Made To Love Magic
2004, 7/10 Nick Drake’s leftover songs have been covered in a couple of outtakes collections – Time Of No Reply was released in 1987 and covered most of the same material as Made To Love Magic. This makes Magic a confusing release – it was originally planned as a remastered version of Time of No Reply but ended up with a different track listing. It omits two tracks from Time Of No Reply – ‘Been Smoking Too Long’ and ‘Strange Meeting II’, while there’s one significant new song, ‘Tow The Line’. The latter wasn’t featured on Time of No Reply and is the last song Drake recorded.
Made To Love Magic isn’t presented chronologically like Time of No Reply – while Drake’s three studio albums were very well sequenced, and provided immersive listening experiences, this is like a random grab bag of Drake leftovers. Most of the songs either pre-date Five Leaves Left, or were recorded in his last recording sessions in 1974. The title track is sped up slightly from its Time Of No Reply version, and features a newly recorded Robert Kirby string part. It’s one of the most memorable songs here, but it also portrays a fey, hippie image of Drake that’s less grounded than his other work.
Drake’s recorded legacy is small enough that you’ll want to hear his outtakes if you’re a fan. In the digital music era, it’s tempting to want to grab all the new tracks from this album and Time Of No Reply, put them in chronological order, and make a more logical Nick Drake outtakes album.
Ten Best Nick Drake Songs
Northern Sky Things Behind The Sun Fly River Man Pink Moon Road One Of These Things First At The Chime Of A City Clock Hazey Jane II Place To Be
CB came real late to Nick. I have a compilation ‘Way To Blue’ which I enjoy when I play it. Watched a real good doc on him a while back. Gave a good feel for him and his music. Sad.
Looks like Way to Blue covers most of the major songs (although Poor Boy is probably my least favourite from his studio albums). It seems like a shame to lose the character of the individual albums though.
I played music with an older guy who was a big music buff (opened for The Church, met Lowell George, owned Richard Thompson’s Henry the Human Fly) and he’d missed Nick Drake the first time round. He seems like a major figure now, but was super obscure at the time.
Did you notice that you can comment on artist pages now? You’re the first one.
You’re in pretty good company if you play with musicians of that caliber. I know what you mean on missing something from the individual albums. I had heard of Drake but never got around to him. There was so many of those guys that flew under the radar. I managed to catch a lot of them. I was listening to my old Syd Barrett records a while ago. When I bought them it was Syd who? Internet has changed all that.
I seen your new format. Can I still make my way through alphabetically? First one. Ribbon, button maybe?
The Reviews page is still there – I just put a link to it from the front page, and you can also find it from the menus.
Yes i found it thanks. I’m on a roll with your stuff
Fantastic review! I loved this album first time I heard it. Recently though, I’ve grown stale to it.
I’ve generally warmed to Drake as I’ve got older – he’s pretty unique in his gentle yet sophisticated approach, kind of like folk jazz. It would have been interesting to see what he would have done next if he’d made more albums.
I definitely agree. Drake was an amazing singer, no question about that. Quite frankly, he just isn’t my cup of tea. I’ve given all three of his studio albums a try and I just can’t get behind it all (if you know what I mean). Nevertheless, really enjoying your reviews! Grade-A stuff!
Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
Review Pages
Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:
Named after a Talking Heads song, Radiohead are the most critically acclaimed band to emerge in the 1990s. They convened informally in 1986 as teenagers while attending Abingdon School in Oxford, and were originally known as On A Friday. Front-man Thom Yorke infuses his gorgeous voice with his neuroses, while the […]
Recently, a reader suggested that I list my favourite albums by year. So here you are – I’ve mostly only listed albums I’ve already reviewed on this site. I don’t know some years very well – I’m dubious about including veteran artists in a couple of 1990s slots, and I […]
Introduction Grant McLennan was taught to play and drafted into The Go-Betweens by Robert Forster. Because of this, he’d never played with another band when they split in 1990. After releasing an album with The Church’s Steve Kilbey as Jack Frost, McLennan launched into a solo career, working with New […]
Miami synth-pop duo Magdalena Bay consists of songwriter/vocalist Mica Tenenbaum and musician/producer Matthew Lewin. The pair met as high school students, first playing together at Live! Modern School of Music. They formed a progressive rock band named Tabula Rasa, before going to college in separate states and breaking off their […]
1970s singer-songwriter Judee Sill was the first artist signed to David Geffen’s Asylum record label. But she had a troubled life; after her father died, her relationship with her stepfather was difficult, and she slipped into a life of crime. After she was arrested for armed robbery, she was sent […]
Siblings Eva and Sam Hendricks grew up in Westport, Connecticut. Eva Hendricks dabbled in musical theatre and sang jingles for commercials. In 2011 Eva Hendricks, vocalist and guitarist, recorded an EP with guitarist Spencer Fox. The duo were joined by Eva’s brother Sam on drums, and eventually bass player Dan […]
Blog Posts
I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:
The Jam were huge in the UK during the punk era, scoring four top ten albums and four number-one singles. Emerging from Woking, on the outskirts of London, the three-piece band were fast and aggressive enough to initially be considered as punk. Subsequent albums showed a heavy influence from mid-1960s […]
Before she released her record-breaking solo album Tapestry in 1971, Carole King had already enjoyed a prolific musical career. She’d inspired Neil Sedaka’s ‘Oh! Carol’ and written a hit song for her daughters’ babysitter (Little Eva’s ‘Loco-motion’). The 1960s hits that she wrote with her husband Gerry Goffin helped make […]
Swindon band XTC formed in the early 1970s, initially playing glam rock. The original band featured singer/guitarist Andy Partridge, singer/bassist Colin Moulding, and drummer Terry Chambers. The band’s early work was nervy new wave – they transitioned towards more mainstream pop/rock after keyboardist Barry Andrews was replaced by multi-instrumentalist Dave […]
Jeff Buckley is best known for his sensitive reading of Leonard Cohen’s ‘Hallelujah’. It’s well done, but taken alone it undersells Buckley’s immense talents. Far more than a crooner, he was also a talented guitarist and a sophisticated songwriter – other artists were capable of a lovely cover of ‘Hallelujah’, […]
Stewart Copeland, Sting, and Andy Summers were all veteran musicians when they formed The Police in London in 1977. Copeland had drummed for progressive rock band Curved Air, Sting had played in the jazz fusion band Last Exit, while Summers’ career as a guitarist dated back to the 1960s when […]
Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel met in 1953 when they appeared in their school’s production of Alice in Wonderland – Simon played the White Rabbit and Garfunkel the Cheshire Cat. Learning to harmonise together, they released their first single, ‘Hey Schoolgirl’ in 1957 as Tom & Jerry. Initially inspired by […]
CB came real late to Nick. I have a compilation ‘Way To Blue’ which I enjoy when I play it. Watched a real good doc on him a while back. Gave a good feel for him and his music. Sad.
Looks like Way to Blue covers most of the major songs (although Poor Boy is probably my least favourite from his studio albums). It seems like a shame to lose the character of the individual albums though.
I played music with an older guy who was a big music buff (opened for The Church, met Lowell George, owned Richard Thompson’s Henry the Human Fly) and he’d missed Nick Drake the first time round. He seems like a major figure now, but was super obscure at the time.
Did you notice that you can comment on artist pages now? You’re the first one.
You’re in pretty good company if you play with musicians of that caliber. I know what you mean on missing something from the individual albums. I had heard of Drake but never got around to him. There was so many of those guys that flew under the radar. I managed to catch a lot of them. I was listening to my old Syd Barrett records a while ago. When I bought them it was Syd who? Internet has changed all that.
I seen your new format. Can I still make my way through alphabetically? First one. Ribbon, button maybe?
The Reviews page is still there – I just put a link to it from the front page, and you can also find it from the menus.
Yes i found it thanks. I’m on a roll with your stuff
Fantastic review! I loved this album first time I heard it. Recently though, I’ve grown stale to it.
I’ve generally warmed to Drake as I’ve got older – he’s pretty unique in his gentle yet sophisticated approach, kind of like folk jazz. It would have been interesting to see what he would have done next if he’d made more albums.
I definitely agree. Drake was an amazing singer, no question about that. Quite frankly, he just isn’t my cup of tea. I’ve given all three of his studio albums a try and I just can’t get behind it all (if you know what I mean). Nevertheless, really enjoying your reviews! Grade-A stuff!