Bill Withers Album Reviews

It’s difficult to discuss this enduring 1970s acoustic soul singer without referencing one of my favourite jokes, so let’s get it out of the way first, shall we?

How do you turn a duck into a soul singer?
Put it in the microwave until its bill withers.

Bill Withers was born in the small mining town of Slab Fork in Wes Virginia. He was a relatively latecomer to the music industry – he spent his twenties in the navy and manufacturing aeroplane toilets. His debut Just As I Am was released in 1971, at the age of 32, and contained the iconic ‘Ain’t No Sunshine’. 1972’s more confident Still Bill followed in 1972, and contained another standard in ‘Lean On Me’.

Withers continued having hits like ‘Lovely Day’ and ‘Just The Two Of Us’, before bowing out of the music industry with 1985’s Watching You Watching Me. Withers’ music is eminently likeable – he exudes wisdom and humility that’s rare in popular music. His early records transcend genres intuitively – he’s bridging the gap between acoustic singer-songwriter and soul. While his catalogue isn’t as deep and rich as some of his contemporaries, his early albums are excellent and among the best of their era.

Bill Withers Album Reviews

Favourite Album: Just As I Am

Just As I Am | Still Bill | Live At Carnegie Hall | +’Justments | Making Music | Naked & Warm | Menagerie | ‘Bout Time | Watching You Watching Me

Just As I Am

Bill Withers Just As I Am

1971, 9/10
Bill Withers was 32 years old when he recorded his debut album – it was recorded in a few spread-out sessions, as his cash strapped record label could afford studio time. He’s accompanied by Booker T. and the MGs, while Stephen Stills contributes some lead guitar. Particularly on Just As I Am, Withers’ acoustic soul bridges the gap between singer-songwriter introspection and soulful vocals and grooves to create an album with universal appeal. Withers’ maturity gives him gravitas, wisdom and grace that’s not common in popular music. Songs like ‘Grandma’s Hand’ with their focus on tradition and heritage are profound and heartfelt.

The key song is ‘Ain’t No Sunshine’; it’s such a standard that it’s easy to forget how idiosyncratic it is – the bridge is Withers simply repeating the phrase “I know” ad infinitum. ‘Grandma’s Hand’ is the other standout, with Withers telling the story of his grandmother’s influence on his life. There are also notable covers – Fred Neil’s ‘Everybody’s Talking’ and The Beatles’ ‘Let It Be’, while there’s a pep talk to himself in ‘Do It Good’, social commentary in ‘Harlem’, and resigned tales of broken love in ‘I’m Her Daddy’ and ‘Hope She’ll Be Happier’.

Just As I Am is a very strong, and somewhat overlooked, debut – there’s far more to Withers than a few hit singles, and there’s a full album of worthwhile material here.

Still Bill

Bill Withers Still Bill

1972, 8.5/10
For his sophomore album, Withers collaborated with members of Charles Wright’s Watts 103rd Street Rhythm Band. Still Bill is more confident-sounding, which means that it loses some of the intimacy of the debut. There’s less of the acoustic soul of Just As I Am and more funk grooves; it’s another very strong, and very underrated album, it’s just not quite as unique as the debut.

The enduring song from Still Bill is ‘Lean On Me’ – it’s subsequently translated into dance and hip hop versions, but Withers’ version is endearing, written about the loss of community he felt after leaving his hometown of Slab Fork, West Virginia. The groove-based songs that follow ‘Lean On Me’ are also strong – ‘Use Me’ is a nuanced tale of a bad relationship, while ‘Kissin’ My Love’ rides a laid-back shuffle – while there are still delicate, heartfelt songs like ‘Let Me In Your Life’. ‘Who Is He (And What Is To You)?’ is surprisingly paranoid from the usually genial Withers.

Still Bill isn’t quite as distinctive as Withers’ debut, but it’s a fine followup – both albums have been lost a little in the shuffle of great albums from the early 1970s, but are well worth discovering.

Live At Carnegie Hall

Bill Withers Live at Carnegie Hall

1973, 9/10
Live At Carnegie Hall is a celebrated double live album, and for good reason. It’s a strong document of Withers’ early solo career, showcasing his unique mixture of confidence and humility. It covers enough of Withers’ early highlights that it’s a good one shopping solution for him – although I’d recommend it as a complement to his studio albums, as five of the fifteen songs are Bill Withers’ compositions that aren’t on any of his studio albums.

Some of these songs are transformed in a live setting – for example ‘Better Off Dead’ is much punchier in this live rendition, while ‘Harlem/Cold Baloney’ is transformed into a fourteen-minute soul epic. And it captures the essence of Withers, and some of his stage chat is as memorable as his songs – in ‘Grandma’s Hands’ he recalls how lively his grandmother’s church was: “At the funeral, they used to have to tie the caskets down!”

Live At Carnegie Hall is as valuable as Bill Withers’ studio albums, and it’s one of the few live albums that’s essential, not just to Bill Withers’ fans but as a document of 1970s soul.



1974, 6.5/10
I’ve always been curious as to why the first two Withers albums, along with Live At Carnegie Hall, receive all of the attention, so I went an album deeper into his discography with 1974’s +’Justments. It’s not dissimilar from what I was expecting – +’Justments is enjoyable, but without the amazing songs that peppered earlier records. Withers is coasting on a great band, relaxed grooves and his low key, charming presence. Withers produces along with Melvin Dunlap and James Gadson, who are also the record’s rhythm section.

Particularly redundant is ‘Make A Smile For Me’, effectively a facsimile of ‘Let Me In Your Life’ from Still Bill. The most fascinating song on +’Justments is ‘Railroad Man’, which stretches out over six minutes and expresses angry nostalgia about Withers’ childhood in West Virginia. José Feliciano guests on congas on ‘Railroad Man’ and also contributes guitar on ‘Green Grass’. Actress Denise Nicholas, whom Withers was briefly married to in the early 1970s, is credited as the writer of ‘Can We Pretend’.

+’Justments is a nice record, but it’s disappointingly light on songwriting after Withers’ earlier gems.

Five Favourite Bill Withers’ Songs

Ain’t No Sunshine
Grandma’s Hands
Lean On Me
Use Me
Who Is He (And What Is He to You)

Back to 1970s Album Reviews….


  1. I enjoyed his debut album quite a bit. I thought it was going to be as good as Al Green’s Call Me. Not quite, not quite. Didn’t really like his second album and haven’t really given his live album its fair share (because I’ve been listening to At Folsom Prison and TVZ’s incredible live album from the 70s). Again, yet another fantastic overview of a soul giant.

    • Withers and Green are sort of different types of artists I think – Withers is stripped back and often acoustic and often going for authenticity, while Green is smooth and gorgeous. Both awesome, but feels a little bit apples and oranges.

    • Yup, I bought a CD twofer of Just As I Am/Still Bill years ago, and that was a bonus track.

      Those first two albums and the live one are all very good – I should probably give his later work a chance sometime too, since there’s not that much of it.

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Talking Heads Remain in Light
Talking Heads Album Reviews

The Talking Heads started out playing in legendary New York club CBGB, effectively the focal point for American New Wave; The Ramones, Television, Patti Smith Group, and Blondie also launched their careers there. While these groups all came from the same place and time, they’re a diverse bunch, and Talking Heads have […]
Pink Floyd Album Reviews

Pink Floyd are one of classic rock’s most renowned bands. Several generations have appreciated the studio wizardry of 1973’s The Dark Side of the Moon and the themes of alienation and self-examination of 1979’s The Wall. But the group’s catalogue is much deeper than their 1970s big sellers like Wish […]
The Beach Boys Pet Sounds
The Beach Boys Album Reviews

As a casual music listener it’s easy to hear The Beach Boys’ sun-drenched hits, and conclude that the group were all beaches, girls and cars, and no substance. But the group was led by Brian Wilson, one of the most talented musicians of his era, with an ear for sophisticated […]
Kimbra Album Reviews

Kimbra Johnson was earmarked for stardom early. There are videos online of her singing as a pre-teen, while she placed second in New Zealand’s national secondary school rock quest at the age of 14. But after a generic debut single ‘Deep For You’, she took time out and became more […]
Suzanne Vega Album Reviews

Suzanne Vega was born in Santa Monica, California. At the age of two, she moved to New York City when her mother married Puerto Rican writer Edgardo Vega Yunqué. She wrote poetry and songs in her youth and cites Lou Reed, Bob Dylan, and Leonard Cohen as key influences. At […]

I don’t usually write reviews on request – you might want to try these blogs: – specialises in rock reviews, particularly anything that is inspired by classic rock or anything retro: disco, ska, blues, jazz, R&B, soul, etc. Contact me here, or just leave a comment.

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

Van Morrison Veedon Fleece
Van Morrison: Five Best Albums

The best albums from Van Morrison's catalogue.
10 Best Moody Blues Songs

Birmingham band The Moody Blues have one of the most misleading names in popular music. It fit to start with – their early repertoire was based on American blues, and their cover of Bessie Banks’ ‘Go Now’ topped the UK charts in early 1965. They played on the Ed Sullivan […]
10 Best Songs by The Mutton Birds

Don McGlashan had already made an impact on the New Zealand music scene before he formed The Mutton Birds. He was the drummer for the punk-influenced band Blam Blam Blam, remembered for fabulously titled songs ‘There Is No Depression in New Zealand’ and ‘Don’t Fight It Marsha, It’s Bigger Than […]
Steely Dan Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Steely Dan were major album artists of the 1970s, releasing a string of quality records that blurred the lines between rock and jazz. They started the decade as a self-contained rock band and ended as the duo of Donald Fagen and Walter Becker, supported by a revolving cast of session […]
The Hold Steady Stay Positive
The Hold Steady: Albums Ranked from Best to Worst

For me, The Hold Steady were the last gasp of a prolonged musical adolescence that reached into my mid-twenties. My first Hold Steady album hit me hard. I played it repeatedly, enjoying its intoxicating modernisation of classic rock, topped by Craig Finn’s literate lyrics. The Hold Steady sound like a […]
Van Morrison in the 1980s: Five Best Albums

I’ve already posted about my favourite five Van Morrison albums, but all five were released in the 1960s and 1970s. While he didn’t reach the level of his earlier peaks, Van Morrison continued to release fine albums in the 1980s. While other rock veterans like Neil Young, Eric Clapton, and […]
%d bloggers like this: