Before he became Patti Smith’s lead guitarist, Lenny Kaye compiled the 2 album set, Nuggets: Original Artyfacts from the First Psychedelic Era. Released in 1972, the two-LP set covered American garage rock and psychedelia from the years from 1965-1968 and was a major influence on punk rock. Rhino Records reissued an expanded version of the set in 1998, with 118 tracks in total. I’m profiling and rating each of these 118 tracks, working backwards.
Track 96: One Track Mind by The Knickerbockers
Release Date: 1966
From: Bergenfield, New Jersey
Aphoristical Rating: 7/10
ONE TRACK MIND – The Knickerbockers [2:18]
(Linda Colley/Keith Colley)
Personnel/BUDDY RANDELL: vocals, sax * BEAU CHARLES: guitar, vocals * JOHN CHARLES: bass, vocals * JIMMY WALKER: drums, vocals
Produced by JERRY FULLER
Recorded in Hollywood, CA
Challenge single #59326 (2/66); Pop #46
The Beatles were formative for many bands on Nuggets, but it’s more explicit for The Knickerbockers than most. Beau and John Charles were brothers, originally with the last name Cecchino, who formed a band in 1962. Buddy Randell joined in 1964 – he’d previously played with the Royal Teens, famous for 1958’s ‘Short Shorts’. Randell’s uncanny vocal similarity to John Lennon meant that 1965’s ‘Lies’ was often used to fool people into believing it was a long-lost Beatles track.
‘One Track Mind’ is another Beatles soundalike track. It didn’t match the success of ‘Lies’, only charting at #46 rather than #20. It’s not quite as sharp as its predecessor, but it’s another worthy slice of Beatles imitation.
The Knickerbockers’ career faded as their chart placements fell, perhaps not interested in adapting to psychedelia. They made two albums in the 1960s but they barely boast any originals, padded out with covers from The Zombies and The Kinks. The Charles brothers later started a country-rock band named Lodi (wonder where they got that name from?), but split in 1972 after one album.
Read More
Related Posts
25 Comments
Leave a Reply
Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:
I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:
Subscribe
Subscribe to receive new posts from Aphoristic Album Reviews.
This one isn’t near as good as Lies, which really could be The Beatles almost. I think it’s the closest Beatles sound-alike record other than the Dave Clark Five’s Because and Glad All Over. Those two songs almost surpass The Beatles earliest stuff.. Especially as far as the sound goes. I need to try to make a list of the best Beatles sound-alike records. I know there’s a bunch but it’s hard to think of them. The Beau Brummels’ Laugh Laugh is probably the best one I can think of. But there’s a shitload more of good ones.
Do you like Todd Rundgren’s Beatles imitation record Deface The Music? Early Hollies are close sometimes.
With your “Beatles-like” characterization, you got my attention right away. It’s a pretty good tune that definitely sound Beatle-esque, especially the vocals.
‘Lies’ (which a couple of years away the rate I’m going) is even better.
I heard Deface the Music once or twice but I don’t remember it that well. But when he did Strawberry Fields Forever and Rain on a different album it sounded like the Beatles. It was like note for note copies of the originals. And he even tried to imitate the singing. But the best one on the album was the Beach Boys one.
I haven’t listened to those remakes but I guess I should sometime. The originals on that record are pretty good.
I’ve listened to that tune in the meantime and like it as well.
I love the guitar hooks in the background…they are relentless. It does have that Beatle sound and the lead vocals are great.
I do agree with Kingclover….The Beau Brummels were close also.
I only know Triangle from The Beau Brummels, which is more like early country-rock.
Laugh Laugh is pretty close
I hear a bit of ’80s power pop in this, The Pinkees’ ‘Danger Games’ especially. (Btw mate, I can’t see the ‘like’ button on your new site, not sure if others are having the same problem. I’m using Chrome, if that helps…)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiMRvzIt6sE
I guess it’s a pretty short jump from 1965 Beatles to power-pop. I just listened to that Pinkees track now – I’d never heard of them before, but reminds me of The Records (which I guess is a very obvious comparison).
The like button is the one issue I know of that I need to fix – I think the caching plugin is messing with it.
You finally showed up in my feed again.
Yup, the people from Wordpress fixed it – should have asked them earlier.
They do sound very Beatles, not bad though. On another note, your site isn’t allowing me to like your posts.
That voice sounds very similar to Lennon. The like button is the last thing I need to fix I think – just the caching plugin messing with it.
I guess if you’re going to sound _______-esque, The Beatles would be pretty good source material!
With this Nuggets series, I guess the scene was still pretty small. There’s the occasional oddball band, but most things are pretty easy to connect to an influential mid-1960s band like The Beatles, Stones, Kinks, Byrds, or Animals.
The most notable Beatles-like element that immediately stands out to my ears are Randell’s as you state ‘uncanny vocal similarities to John Lennon’.
Yup, Lennon had a pretty distinctive voice so it’s interesting that they could reproduce that.
Man, I love this boxed set. And this is a pretty good song!
You’ve got a one track mind about Nuggets?
Haha pretty much. I have a blind bias though, I just love that stuff. Smarter folks than me (like yourself) are more discerning. 🙂
There hasn’t been anything I’ve disliked so far – various shades of good to great.
Exactly!