Before he became Patti Smith’s lead guitarist, Lenny Kaye compiled the 2 album set, Nuggets: Original Artyfacts from the First Psychedelic Era. Released in 1972, the two-LP set covered American garage rock and psychedelia from the years 1965-1968 and was a major influence on punk rock. Rhino Records reissued an expanded version of the set in 1998, with 118 tracks in total. I’m profiling and rating each of these 118 tracks, working backwards.
Track 40/118: Time Won’t Let Me by The Outsiders
Release Year: 1966
From: Cleveland, Ohio
Aphoristic Rating: 9/10
TIME WON’T LET ME – The Outsiders [2:46]
(Thomas King/Chet Kelley)
Personnel/SONNY GERACI: vocals * TOM KING: guitar, sax * MERTON MADSEN: bass [+ AL AUSTIN: lead guitar * RONNIE HARKAI: drums * EVAN VanGUARD: trumpet * MIKE GERACI: sax]
Produced by TOM KING
Recorded in Cleveland, OH
Capitol single #5573 (1/66); Pop #5
The Outsiders originated from an earlier band, the Starfires. The Starfires were formed by teenage guitarist Tom King in the late 1950s. They were a successful R&B combo regionally, playing up to shows a week. The band’s style evolved in the 1960s – King relinquished his position as lead singer after a tonsillectomy, and the band changed their style to reflect Beatlemania.
‘Time Won’t Let Me’ is a sophisticated amalgam of the band’s R&B roots and the Beatles influence. There’s a horn section and organ adding colour and energy, but even without them, there’s a very impressive British Invasion-inspired guitar song. There’s also a touch of blue-eyed soul in the voice of lead singer Sonny Geraci, and a fluid guitar solo from Al Austin.
While many of the songs on Nuggets languished in obscurity, ‘Time Won’t Let Me’ made the top five on Billboard. The band, however, weren’t able to capitalise on their hit. They enjoyed a minor hits with follow-up singles – ‘Girl in Love’ and a cover of The Isley Brothers’ ‘Respectable’ – but faded into semi-obscurity.
The members of The Outsiders who achieved the most in the music business didn’t play on ‘Time Won’t Let Me’. Drummer Jimmy Fox left Starfire to go to college, before reconnecting with The Outsiders after ‘Time Won’t Let Me’. He later left to form his own band, The James Gang with Joe Walsh. Meanwhile, James William Guercio toured with a later lineup of The Outsiders – he went on to manage Chicago, whose early work offered a similar blend of R&B and British Invasion sounds.
Read More
17 Comments
Leave a Reply
Review Pages
Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:
Blog Posts
I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:
A great song for sure!
I’d never actually heard it before – doesn’t make the oldies station here.
Nice that you’re hearing it with new ears. It got a lot of radio play here back in the day.
TOP FIVE
I did toy with a ten.
Thebass player has a hell of a quiff. Excellent song and always a favorite of mine when I listened to it on our oldies channel here back when I was a teen. One of the best songs on Nuggets to me.
Cleveland has given us some good bands…James Gang, Raspberries, and I think Nine Inch Nails…. that makes sense with The James Gang.
I’d never heard it before Nuggets, as I just to Christian, it’s almost too good for pop radio.
This song is how all pop radio was in 1966. That’s what made the 60s so great!! In fact, 65 and 66 were the greatest years for singles ever!!!
I agree… it stands out…it’s polished and a little edgy at the same time.
See? The only other years that come close are 64 and 65. Or anything between 64 and 69 really.
https://rateyourmusic.com/list/bobbyb5/greatest-singles-1966/
That is a good list. I’d probably have Eight Miles High nearer the top. That comma in ‘Paint It, Black’ drives me crazy.
I read that the comma was just a printing error by somebody. Just a typo. But they didn’t notice it until it was too late so they just left it like that.
I didn’t know that the one guy had anything to do with The James Gang, whom I love. Or that they had anything to do with that Guercio guy who was in Chicago, whom I also love. But I knew he had something to do with The Buckinghams, who now that I think about it are kind of similar to The Outsiders with their horn arrangements and stuff.
Two Walsh-related posts in a week. I don’t really know the Buckinghams.
Awesome-sounding tune. I love the groove and the organ. And the horns are cool as well!
I’d never heard it before Nuggets, it’d almost too good and too sophisticated to be a hit.
This is one I’m familiar with and like a lot. Just an FYI I had to come to your blog again to make a comment instead through the feed/reader.