Wind It Up by Gwen Stefani

3

Wind It Up by Gwen Stefani

Topped the NZ chart: for 2 weeks from 25 December 2006.

Gwen Stefani was already an established star before she went solo. She sang for California ska-punk band No Doubt, fronting hits like ‘Don’t Speak’ and ‘Just a Girl’. Her solo career started strongly with 2004’s ‘Hollaback Girl’.

‘Wind It Up’ was the lead single for her second album, The Sweet Escape. It’s credited to Stefani, Pharrell Williams, Richard Rodgers, and Oscar Hammerstein II. The latter two are included due to the interpolation of ‘The Lonely Goatherd’ from The Sound of Music.

‘Wind It Up’ is a bizarre mishmash – like Stefani and Williams throwing a whole lot of ideas at the wall. There’s yodelling, a minimalist beat from the Neptunes, incoherent lyrics about the objectification of women, a disregard for vocal melody, and shouts of “wind it up”. The beat holds the disparate elements together better than you might expect, but it’s still incoherent and irritating. It’s similar in feel to ‘Hollaback Girl’, but doesn’t work nearly as well.

Stefani’s career has been a lot quieter since 2006 – not unusual for a pop/rock artist after their first decade. She released a new solo record, Bouquet, a couple of weeks ago (15 November 2024). It’s only her second non-Christmas solo album since The Sweet Escape.

Read more

6 Comments

  1. I liked some of her music with No Doubt…but this no…the yodelling is probably my favorite part. For me…No Doubt sounded good in spots…but she turned into a regular pop singer after them. She does have a great voice…that I will give to her.

    • Feel like she gets a bit of a free pass because of the No Doubt stuff. I like Hollaback Girl well enough though, so there’s probably some other good stuff.

Leave a Reply

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

More review pages

Syd Barrett Album Reviews

Syd Barrett was the creative force behind the original Pink...

Don Henley Album Reviews

Don Henley emerged as the primary lead singer of the...

Split Enz Album Reviews

Formed by a group of Auckland students in 1972, Split...
Split Enz Mental Notes

Pavement Album Reviews

Pavement’s debut album Slanted and Enchanted was recorded in 1991...
Pavement Slanted and Enchanted

The Raincoats Album Reviews

The punk and new wave movements lowered the barriers to...

Big Thief Album Reviews

Indie folk and Americana band Big Thief are based in...

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

More blog posts

Five Best Songs by The Front Lawn

The Flight of the Conchords weren’t New Zealand’s first musical/theatrical...

Sugar Mountain by Neil Young: Great B-Sides

Neil Young first rose to prominence in 1960s folk-rock group...
Neil Young Decade

10 Best Paul Kelly Songs: Part 1, 1985-1992

Singer-songwriter Paul Kelly is barely known outside of Australia, but...

Man Without Ties by Paul Westerberg

The Replacements are one of my favourite bands of all...
14 Songs Paul Westerberg

10 Best Pop-Era Genesis Songs

Genesis formed in the 1960s, when Peter Gabriel, Tony Banks...

Babies, If I Didn’t Have You by Kate & Anna McGarrigle: Great B-Sides

It’s challenging to write about Canadian sisters Kate & Anna...

Subscribe

Subscribe to receive new posts from Aphoristic Album Reviews.