It’s not an overstatement that Jeff Buckley was one of the most singularly talented musicians of his generation; blessed with a beautiful and athletic voice, a more than adequate guitar technique and an ability to write songs that escaped from predictable verse/chorus patterns while remaining accessible. Additionally, Buckley is also emotionally wide-reaching, able to jump between brash lustiness and eloquent emotional expression.
Buckley was only able to record one full album before his Memphis drowning in 1997. Although Grace has moments of immense power, it also houses some less-impressive material. It’s unfortunate that Buckley’s most remembered for his cover of Leonard Cohen’s ‘Hallelujah’, rather than his own great songs. His album of demos for his second album is also well worthwhile, but his estate has also released a long string of live albums and outtakes that I’ve never bothered with.
Jeff was the son of avant-garde folkie Tim Buckley, who led a similarly short life before succumbing to a heroin overdose; the elder Buckley actually died younger than his offspring, even though his recorded output is much more voluminous, as Jeff Buckley didn’t record Grace until he was already 27. The younger Buckley barely knew his father, and tried to avoid comparisons; instead, common reference points include Led Zeppelin and Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan.
1994, 7.5/10 Grace is a frustrating album, even more so in hindsight, as it’s the only album that Jeff Buckley completed before he drowned. Most of Buckley’s originals are great, and a whole album of this standard would be a contender for best album of the 1990s, but Grace is dragged down by the inclusion of three covers. Even if Buckley’s is the definitive version of the Leonard Cohen standard ‘Hallelujah’, it still drags at close to seven minutes, while the other covers are just plain dull – ‘Lilac Wine’ has a foppish, wispy quality that’s not very appealing, and Buckley’s ability to warble his way through Benjamin Britten’s ‘Corpus Christi’ is technically impressive but monotonous.
Grouped together in the middle of the album, along with the drawn out and melodramatic ‘Lover You Should Have Come Over’, there’s a definite lull in momentum, and when the blistering, nasty ‘Eternal Life’ kicks in, it’s a breath of fresh air. Award for the standout song, however, goes to the tour de force ‘Last Goodbye’ which ties together most of Buckley’s appealing aspects; powered by a memorable bass line, it’s a fluid song that’s accessible yet completely lacking any clear verse/chorus structure, is emotionally eloquent, and simultaneously rock hard and beautifully sensitive. Other notable songs include the title track, with some terrific guitar work with the fast arpeggios in the introduction and the trippy flange as the song climaxes, while the closing ‘Dream Brother’ is scarily prescient with its last line “Sleep in the sand/With the ocean washing over me.”
It’s unfortunate that Buckley never had the chance to make another album – he had the obvious potential to be one of the greats, and uneven as Grace is, maybe sublime moments like ‘Last Goodbye’ are alone enough to secure a legacy.
Sketches For My Sweetheart The Drunk
1998, 7.5/10 Buckley drowned in a Memphis river in May 1997 on the eve of beginning band rehearsals for his follow-up to Grace, and this posthumous sophomore album was pieced together from demos completed during the preceding few months. A two-disc set, the first disc comprises of official studio demos recorded with Television guitarist Tom Verlaine, and mixed by Grace producer Andy Wallace, while the second disc comes from more informal sessions, often just by Buckley on a four-track.
It’s better to think of Sketches as a single album with a bonus disc rather than a double album per se. Buckley’s mother, Mary Guibert, who pieced this set together, referring specifically to the lyrics, stresses that “these were works in progress, still in the process of metamorphosis”, but it’s an effective set nonetheless, and it’s not weighed down by boring covers like Grace was. The most arresting track here is ‘Everybody Here Wants You’, which explores an R&B flavoured territory that’s ideally suited to Buckley’s clear falsetto; it’s a shame that he never had the chance to explore this area further. Similarly beautiful are ‘Opened Once’, ‘Morning Theft’ and ‘You & I’, oozing emotion from their minimalist arrangements. ‘New Year’s Prayer’ is almost mantra-like in its repetitive groove, while ‘Vancouver’ successfully marries a delicate melody with a thrashy arrangement. ‘The Sky Is A Landfill’ is bristling and raw, while the cover ‘Yard Of Blonde Girls’ is similarly hard-edged.
The second disc can be tough to sit through; I’m not enough of a fanatic to care about the two alternate Verlaine mixes that open the disc, while the poor sound quality makes some of the other tracks difficult (the bass pulse that runs through his cover of Genesis’ ‘Back In N.Y.C.’ is particularly irritating), but some of these songs are definitely worth saving even in this crude form, like the lascivious ‘Your Flesh Is So Nice’ and the unadorned cover of ‘Satisfied Mind’.
Because Buckley’s discography is so small, if you’re a fan Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk is totally essential – the first disc may not be exactly the end result Buckley had in mind, but it’s still fascinating, while the messier bonus disc also has its moments.
Five Favourite Jeff Buckley Songs
Last Goodbye Everybody Here Wants You The Sky Is A Landfill Grace Eternal Life
Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
Review Pages
Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:
Britt Walford and Brian McMahan met in their pre-teens, and joined the punk band Squirrel Bait while still in their teens. Walford, a drummer, left Squirrel Bait after the band’s first recording sessions, but McMahan stayed on as second guitarist until their dissolution in 1987. Walford and McMahan joined forces […]
Fairport Convention are the focal point for British folk-rock of their generation. While they started their career as a sixties folk-rock band, like a London equivalent to Jefferson Airplane, they started wading through the archives of British folk songs and electrifying them. With an impressive pool of talent, Fairport Convention […]
Rock and roll’s perpetual underdog, Thomas Earl Petty was born in Gainsville, Florida, in 1950. His interest in rock and roll was sparked when he met Elvis Presley in 1961, and was cemented when he saw The Beatles on the Ed Sullivan Show. Petty dropped out of school at the […]
The band most likely to win a Scrabble tournament, The Decemberists hail from Portland, Oregon, and are notable for flaunting their extensive vocabulary in song. Despite their American heritage, they’re staunch Anglophiles; many of their early songs are set in Victorian England, while leader Colin Meloy is a fan of English […]
I don’t usually write reviews on request – you might want to try these blogs: https://80smetalman.wordpress.com/https://vinyldaftdad.wordpress.com/http://crazyonclassicrock.wordpress.com/ – specialises in rock reviews, particularly anything that is inspired by classic rock or anything retro: disco, ska, blues, jazz, R&B, soul, etc. Contact me here, or just leave a comment.
The 1975 formed as a high school band in Wilmslow, Cheshire, where a council worker organised frequent gigs for teenagers. Vocalist and guitarist Matty Healy, the son of prominent actors, was joined by guitarist Adam Hann, bassist Ross MacDonald, and drummer George Daniel. The quartet cycled through a vast number […]
Blog Posts
I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:
The Decemberists rode the wave of early 21st century Indie to success, attracting attention with their predilection for historic epics and olde English folk music. They hail from Portland, Oregon, but the band was named for the Decembrist Revolution in 19th century Imperial Russia. The band’s invented back story describes […]
Jimmy Webb enjoyed a sterling career as a songwriter in the 1960s – his website bills him as “America’s Songwriter”, and it’s not an unreasonable title given his rich catalogue of hits like ‘Wichita Lineman’ and ‘By The Time I Get To Phoenix’. After writing for Glen Campbell, Richard Harris, […]
Nic Jones emerged in the fertile folk scene of the late 1960s. While contemporaries like Richard Thompson, Sandy Denny, and John Martyn ventured into pop and rock music, Jones remained stubbornly traditional. His first two albums, 1970’s Ballads & Songs and 1971’s Nic Jones, were austere, Jones playing solo in […]
In tandem with Robert Forster, Grant McLennan was a vocalist, songwriter, and guitarist for literate Australian jangle-pop band The Go-Betweens. While The Go-Betweens were on hiatus during the 1990s, Grant McLennan embarked on a solo career, releasing four solo albums, two albums with The Church’s Steve Kilbey, and one album […]
David Crosby, Stephen Stills, and Graham Nash were all members of famous 1960s bands before linking up as a trio. Crosby was a member of The Byrds, fired when his countercultural songs like ‘Triad’ were rejected by the group. Nash was frustrated in The Hollies, who chose to record an […]
The members of The Cars were all experienced musicians when they formed. Drummer David Robinson had already played with another famous Boston act, Jonathan Richman’s Modern Lovers. The band’s two vocalists – bassist Ben Orr and songwriter Ric Ocasek – had played together in Milkwood, a folk rock band. They […]
