Steely Dan Album Reviews

Steely Dan were the quiet achievers of the 1970s, recording an excellent series of meticulously written and arranged albums with jazzy chord changes and dark, sarcastic lyrics. The group was formed around Donald Fagen on lead vocals and guitar and Walter Becker on bass and guitar. The pair met when they were students at Bard College, New York, in 1967. They formed a songwriting team and comedian Chevy Chase was a drummer in one of their early bands.

Fagen and Becker were signed as staff writers for ABC Records. Other artists found their songs too complex to record, so producer Gary Katz suggested that they form their own band. The pair recruited guitarists Denny Dias and Jeff “Skunk” Baxter, drummer Jim Hodder, and vocalist David Palmer, and named the newly formed band after a dildo in William S Burroughs’ novel Naked Lunch. After the unsuccessful single ‘Dallas’/‘Sail the Waterway’, which Fagen and Becker have since disowned, they found success with their debut album Can’t Buy A Thrill. Palmer left the band during recording sessions for follow-up Countdown to Ecstasy, leaving Fagen as the sole lead vocalist; Fagen’s sardonic delivery is more appropriate for the group’s dark undercurrents.

Ever perfectionists, Fagen and Becker brought in more and more outside musicians to augment their sound, adding future Toto drummer Jeff Porcaro, keyboardist and backing vocalist Michael McDonald, and Royce Jones. The group stopped touring after 1974’s Pretzel Logic, and the band essentially became a studio operation based around Fagen and Becker, augmented by session musicians. Baxter and McDonald went on to join The Doobie Brothers.

The group’s albums became increasingly perfect and increasingly insular, and 1977’s Aja stands as the pinnacle of their quest for a pristine sound. After a previously uneventful career, 1980’s Gaucho was beset by a host of difficulties – Becker’s girlfriend died of a drug overdose in his apartment, an assistant engineer accidentally deleted most of a completed track, Becker broke a leg in a traffic accident, and the group were sued over the similarity of the title track to a Keith Jarrett piece.

Steely Dan disbanded in 1981, but Fagen and Becker began working together again a few years later. They resumed touring and produced two more albums – Two Against Nature is famous for beating Eminem for the 2001’s Album of the Year Grammy, and it feels more like a consolation award than anything, compensation for not receiving any Grammys except for engineering in their 1970s prime. Fagen continues to tour as Steely Dan, despite Becker’s death in 2017.

Steely Dan Album Reviews

Can’t Buy A Thrill | Countdown to Ecstasy | Pretzel Logic | Katy Lied | The Royal Scam | Aja | Gaucho | Two Against Nature | Everything Must Go

Donald Fagen: The Nightfly

Linda Hoover: I Mean to Shine

Best Album: Aja
Overlooked Gem: The Royal Scam

Can’t Buy A Thrill


1972, 8/10
Although Becker and Fagen had previous experience in the studio – the duo had recorded the unsuccessful soundtrack to You’ve Got to Walk It Like You Talk It or You’ll Lose That Beat and Steely Dan had already released an unsuccessful single – Can’t Buy A Thrill is a remarkably assured debut. While their work would become more insular, jazzier, and more idiosyncratic they already have a lot of their trademarks in place – pristine production and musicianship, with dark lyrics. The most noticeable difference from the group’s later work is the presence of guest vocalists – while Fagen takes a lot of the leads, drummer Jim Hodder (‘Midnite Cruiser’) and vocalist David Palmer (‘Dirty Work’, ‘Brooklyn (Owns The Charmer Under Me)’) both also contributed lead vocals. While they’re both capable singles, with sweet voices, their presence is jarring – Fagen’s nasal, distinctive voice is best-suited to the band’s dark-streaked material.

The two most interesting songs are the two best known. The cryptic opener ‘Do It Again’ features a slinky groove from Fagen’s electric piano and an electric sitar solo from Dias in the extended instrumental section. ‘Reelin’ In The Years’ begins a tradition of terrific Steely Dan guitar solos, courtesy of session guitarist Elliott Randall. Elsewhere, the material’s less distinctive, but still excellent – ‘Kings’ and ‘Change of the Guards’ are both choice deep cuts, and ‘Dirty Work’ and ‘Brooklyn’ are nice tunes, despite Palmer’s distractingly smooth vocals.

Can’t Buy A Thrill is an excellent debut from Steely Dan, but they’d only get more interesting.

Countdown to Ecstasy


1973, 8.5/10
Steely Dan’s second album is their last as essentially a self-contained band – the five official band members play most of the instruments and are only augmented by the occasional guest. But Countdown to Ecstasy already sounds a lot more like a Steely Dan album – Fagen takes all the lead vocals, and the smooth west coast vibe from songs like ‘Midnite Cruiser’ on Can’t Buy A Thrill is gone, replaced by darker material. Music critic Paul Lester wrote that “Becker and Fagen offered cruel critiques of the self-obsessed ‘Me’ decade”, and this is borne out in songs like ‘Razor Boy’, where Fagen asks “Will you still have a song to sing when the razor boy comes and takes your fancy things away?” Even the album’s tenderest song, ‘Pearl of the Quarter’, is essentially a love song to a prostitute.

Countdown to Ecstasy didn’t produce any hit singles, but it’s more consistent and coherent than their debut, and it stands as one of Steely Dan’s stronger albums. Opener ‘Bodhisattva’ is a fun, bluesy vamp, featuring soloing from Baxter and Dias, while ‘Show Biz Kids’, later sampled by Super Furry Animals, features Rick Derringer on guitar. ‘My Old School’ tells the story of a drug bust at Bard College, which Fagen and Becker both attended.

Countdown to Ecstasy sounds much more characteristic of Steely Dan than their debut, with more bite.

Pretzel Logic


1974, 9/10
Pretzel Logic finds Steely Dan moving away from being a self-contained band. Jim Hodder is relegated to backing vocals, and the drum duties are performed by Jim Gordon and Jeff Porcaro. Fagen and Becker also use studio musicians to augment their own core roles; David Paich and Michael Omartian contribute keyboard parts, and Wilton Felder and Chuck Rainey contribute bass. Becker stated that “Once I met Chuck Rainey I felt there really was no need for me to be bringing my bass guitar to the studio anymore”, and Pretzel Logic is the first album where Becker plays the guitar. The group’s jazz influence is more apparent than ever before, as they cover Duke Ellington and name one of their originals ‘Parker’s Band’. Pretzel Logic was also more commercially visible than Countdown to Ecstasy, featuring the hit opener ‘Rikki, Don’t Lose That Number’.

‘Rikki, Don’t Lose That Number’ has never been one of my favourite Steely Dan songs – I’ve always found the chorus hook irritating, although Baxter’s guitar solo is one of his most memorable contributions to the group. But there are plenty of lesser-known treasures that blur the lines between jazz and pop – ‘Night By Night’ and the surprisingly tender ‘Any Major Dude Will Tell You’ are two of my favourite Steely Dan pieces. There’s also the bluesy title track, with one of Fagen’s strongest vocals, and the pretty ‘Barrytown’. Pretzel Logic is probably my favourite moment in Steely Dan’s evolution from a rock band to smooth jazzy studio mavens, but it’s marred by a couple of weak points – the fragmentary ‘Through With Buzz’ and the country throwaway ‘With A Gun’.

Pretzel Logic has its flaws, but it was Steely Dan’s strongest album to date, diving deeper into jazz and into studio perfectionism.

Katy Lied


1975, 8/10
Becker and Fagen ditched any pretence of being a band on Katy Lied, augmenting themselves with a host of studio players. 20-year-old Jeff Porcaro is on drums, while Michael McDonald’s distinctive voice is used for the first time on backing vocals on songs like ‘Any World (That I’m Welcome To)’. The album was troubled by sound issues – Becker and Fagen refuse to listen to it in full because of issues with the noise reduction system, although a last-minute effort from Dias and Becker largely negated the dullness in sound. Despite the extra musical firepower, Katy Lied is my least favourite set of songs on a 1970s Steely Dan album.

There are some excellent pieces though – ‘Doctor Wu’ was later covered by The Minutemen, Phil Woods guests on saxophone, and it’s a great showpiece of the band’s cryptic professionalism. ‘Black Friday’ is the opener and first single, and it’s effective, with Becker supplying the searing lead guitar work. The slinky groove of ‘Chain Lightning’ is appealing and McDonald’s backing vocals ignite ‘Any World (That I’m Welcome To)’. But there are too many mid-tempo bores like ‘Everyone’s Gone to the Movies’ and ‘Bad Sneakers’ (which probably suffers in retrospect from a later 1970s hit referencing piña coladas in its chorus).

Katy Lied is a very good record, but it fails to stand out in Steely Dan’s exemplary 1970s catalogue.

The Royal Scam


1975, 9/10
The Royal Scam is arguably the closest Steely Dan came to repeating themselves in the 1970s – it’s a continuation of the dark, sophisticated jazz-rock of Katy Lied. But rather than a stale retread, it’s an improvement on its predecessor. The songwriting is sharper, and even though the playing was exemplary on Katy Lied, the studio musicians featured here elevate the material even further. Jazz guitarist Larry Carlton guested on Katy Lied but he’s all over The Royal Scam, and his dazzling solo on ‘Kid Charlemagne’ is perhaps his most iconic moment. Drummer Bernard Purdie appears for the first time on a Steely Dan record and his precise and funky work is a terrific fit for the band.

Steely Dan’s work is always filled with cynicism, but it’s particularly pronounced on The Royal Scam. Almost all of these tales are dark, the abusive husband and cheating wife of ‘Everything You Did’ perhaps the most extreme example. ‘Everything You Did’ features the line “turn up the Eagles, the neighbours are listening, which in turn inspired Henley and Frey to include the reference of “steely knives” on Hotel California. Elsewhere, ‘Kid Charlemagne’ is my favourite moment from the Steely Dan catalogue, a portrait of LSD chemist Owsley Stanley with funky clavinet and the line “Is there gas in the car? Yes there’s gas in the car.” ‘The Fez’ is another great Purdie groove, ‘Haitian Divorce’ uses talk box guitar, and low-key songs like ‘Sign In Stranger’ and the title track are pretty and accomplished.

The Royal Scam is another great Steely Dan album, one of the better records in their 1970s catalogue.



1977, 9.5/10
Beloved by audiophiles, Steely Dan’s sixth album was a further progression towards a pristine studio sound. While the two previous Steely Dan albums were dominated by a smooth jazz sound, they featured songs like ‘Black Friday’ and ‘Everything You Did’ that were driven by raw, bluesy guitars, while the group’s lyrics constantly poked at the dark underbelly of society. But Aja is a surprisingly warm and compassionate set of songs, out of character compared to Becker and Fagen’s other work, even though they throw in the occasional subversive lyric like “She prays like a Roman/With her eyes on fire.” Regular contributors like Larry Carlton, Chuck Rainey and Bernard Purdie are back, and notable additions to the group’s roster of session players include Weather Report’s Wayne Shorter and drummer Jim Keltner.

The most accessible songs are the succinct upbeat songs named after women – ‘Peg’ was later sampled by De La Soul, and has a prominent Michael McDonald backing vocal, while ‘Josie’ is bouncy and fun. Elsewhere, the material’s deeper – the title track is close to pure jazz with its Shorter solos and relaxed feel. The crown jewel is ‘Deacon Blues’, an autobiographical tale of Fagen and Becker’s musical aspirations as suburban teenagers, the most heartfelt piece the group ever released. Purdie’s patented shuffle drives ‘Home At Last’, while the kiss-off of the opening ‘Black Cow’ is the album’s most negative piece.

It’s smooth and calm, but Aja is far too sophisticated and intelligent to be written off as elevator music, and its perfect veneer is the peak that Steely Dan had been working towards.



1980, 7.5/10
Gaucho was recorded in New York, changing the pool of session musicians that Steely Dan worked with; previous albums were recorded in Los Angeles. The sessions were beset with difficulty – Becker’s girlfriend died of a drug overdose in his apartment and he broke his leg in a traffic accident, while an engineer accidentally deleted a song named ‘The Second Arrangement’. Gaucho is very similar to Aja in shape – seven tracks, with a smooth, jazzy veneer. Perhaps the biggest fault of Gaucho is that it lacks the upbeat tracks that Aja had – songs like ‘Peg’ and ‘Josie’ helped to provide balance, but Gaucho is all languid. Gaucho is generally regarded as Steely Dan’s weakest album in their initial run, although it’s undergone positive reappraisal.

Despite its reputation, as one of the band’s more insular albums, the singles ‘Hey Nineteen’ and ‘Babylon Sisters’ both received airplay – ‘Hey Nineteen’ is typical of the jaded atmosphere of the album as a whole, with the line “She don’t remember the queen of soul”. My favourite song here is the title track – jazz pianist Keith Jarrett sued for the similarity to his piece “Long As You Know You’re Living Yours”, and was given a co-writer credit, but the result’s impressive, a song that unwinds over a complex jazz progression. ‘My Rival’ is perhaps the least accomplished song here, but everything else is strong – the album suffers from its homogeneous sound but it’s full of well-crafted tunes.

Gaucho is a step down from most of Steely Dan’s work in the 1970s, but there’s still a lot of beautiful music here.

Two Against Nature

2000, 7/10
Fagen and Becker started working together again in the mid-1980s – Fagen produced Becker’s 1993 record Kamakiriad, and the pair toured in the 1990s. A full reunion album emerged in 2000. Infamously it won the Album of the Year Grammy, beating out Radiohead, Beck, and Eminem. While the Grammy win feels like a consolation for their stellar work in the 1970s barely receiving any recognition from the Recording Academy, it’s a solid enough return to the studio, a natural follow-up to Gaucho. As usual, there’s an array of backing musicians – familiar names from the 1970s like Dean Parks and Hugh McCracken, and younger musicians who hadn’t work with the Dan previously, like Keith Carlock and Vinnie Colaiuta.

Impressively, there are a handful of songs here that stand up to the band’s 1970s best – in particular, ‘Jack of Speed’, which is built around a great Wurlitzer riff from Fagen. ‘Cousin Dupree’ is engagingly creepy, while ‘Gaslighting Abbie’ is a very good opener. Fagen’s voice is thinner and weaker than it was in the 1970s, and the group sound best when the material revolves around a groove.

Two Against Nature is weaker than anything Steely Dan released in the 1970s, but it’s still a worthy addition to their catalogue.

Everything Must Go

2003, 7/10
Steely Dan’s final album, Everything Must Go is another tasteful and worthy late period from Becker and Fagen. There’s a smaller cast of musicians than usual – Becker and Keith Carlock are the rhythm section on every track, while guitarists Jon Herington and Hugh McCracken also play on every song. ‘Slang of Ages’ features Becker’s only lead vocal on a Steely Dan studio album – it’s interesting to hear how much of Steely Dan’s sound derives from Fagen’s pinched vocals, as they sound like a completely different band with Becker at the mike.

‘Things That I Miss the Most’ is a straightforward verse/chorus construction and it works – the way that Fagen spits out the things that he misses the most (“The talk/The sex/Somebody to trust”) is delicious. A terrific Becker bassline drives ‘Godwhacker’, Fagen’s sacrilegious response to losing his mother to Alzheimer’s. There’s plenty of tasteful jazz-rock that you suspect Fagen and Becker could have churned out in their sleep, like the title track and ‘Blues Beach’.

Everything Must Go is the least enthralling record in Steely Dan’s catalogue, but it’s more respectable and tasteful than most band’s late-career efforts.

Donald Fagen

The Nightfly


1982, 8.5/10
After more than a decade in creative partnership, Fagen and Becker split after the difficult sessions for Gaucho. Becker moved to Hawaii and took up avocado farming, in an attempt to clean up his drug habit, while Fagen recorded his solo debut. In many ways, The Nightfly is a continuation of the smooth jazzy sound of Aja and Gaucho, and it utilises familiar musicians like Jeff Porcaro, Larry Carlton, and Michael Omartian. But while it’s stylistically very similar to Steely Dan, its lyrical outlook is very different – it’s evident that Becker supplied much of Steely Dan’s acerbic outlook, and instead The Nightfly is wistful and nostalgic. It’s based on Fagen’s suburban New Jersey childhood, in prosperous and confident 1950s America, listening to late-night jazz radio.

The Nightfly is such a smooth and consistent album that it’s difficult to pick out highlights. My favourite is the title track with its crisp rhythms, and electric piano stabs. The most notable material is the sentimental, 1950s-tinged songs like ‘Ruby Baby’ and ‘Maxine’, the biggest departure from Steely Dan’s sound.

Very much a continuation of the excellence of Steely Dan’s first phase, The Nightfly is a very strong epilogue to their early career.

Ten Best Steely Dan Songs

Kid Charlemagne
Night By Night
Any Major Dude Will Tell You
Black Friday
Deacon Blues
The Fez
Doctor Wu
Showbiz Kids

Back to 1970s Album Reviews….



1970/2022, 7.5/10
New Jersey’s Linda Hoover was discovered by producer Gary Katz. In 1970 he introduced her to some other young musicians he was working with, Walter Becker and Donald Fagen. The pair wrote five songs for Hoover’s debut and also played on the sessions. Recorded a couple of years before Steely Dan debuted, I Mean to Shine is a fascinating look into Steely Dan’s early history. The band have more country influence than they would on their later work, while they met future Steely Dan guitarist Jeff “Skunk” Baxter during these sessions. Hoover is an uncomfortable match for Becker and Fagen’s subversive songs – she sings well and has a hint of Grace Slick’s stridency in her vocals but is too wholesome for the arrangement to have worked long-term.

Becker and Fagen’s songs are certainly subversive – the title track is about a woman ditching her lover as she aims for the stars, while the chorus of ‘Jones’ reads “But a monkey on a silver string / ain’t really all that bad/Just waiting ’til my Jones comes down on me”. In comparison, Hoover’s own material is pure and innocent – she wrote ‘Mama Tears’ about missing her mother. The covers from Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young and The Band are enjoyable. ‘4+20’, is expanded from a Stephen Stills solo arrangement on the original, Richard Manuel’s ‘In A Station’.

I Mean To Shine was shelved for more than fifty years – the record company had a publishing deal and wasn’t interested in releasing an album with only three Hoover originals. But now available as of Record Store Day 2022, it’s an insight into the formative era of Steely Dan.


  1. I have listened to this band a lot over the years. They make really good music. So much good stuff for CB’s ears. I see you have another take on SD. I’ll spare you more of my input and just say that SD hold a special place in my music pile.

      • Last thing I heard before I shut out the light last night was ‘Black Cow’. I like your quote. The amount I commented on your post seems inadequate for all the listening I put into their music. More of them coming up on CB’s takes. Good job by the way.

  2. Top 10

    Deacon Blues
    Do It Again
    Dirty Work
    Time Out of Mind
    Rikki Don’t Lose That Number
    Reeling in the Years
    Black Friday

  3. Top 10

    Don’t Take Me Alive
    Pretzel Logic
    The Boston Rag
    Deacon Blues
    Haitian Divorce
    Black Cow
    Kid Charlemagne
    Green Earrings
    Charlie Freak
    Show Biz Kids

  4. What’s interesting is that, as someone who listened to all the Steely Dan records in real time, back in the 70s, when The Royal Scam came out it seemed like their weakest record. In retrospect I can’t see why. It didn’t seem as inspired somehow. But now, when I listen, I hear nothing lacking. And Kid Charlemagne is their greatest song. Don’t even think of arguing with me.

    • I just like the later stuff better – it’s more unique and sophisticated, and I don’t like Palmer on vocals as much. I do wonder if I would have scored it higher if they’d broken up early.

Leave a Reply

  • Nick Drake Bryter Layter

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

  • Faith No More Angel Dust
  • R.E.M. New Adventures in Hi Fi
  • Straitjacket Fits Melt