Skip to content

1960s Album Reviews

Zombies Odessey and Oracle Review

The following 1960s artists have their own dedicated page:

The Band
The Beach Boys
The Beatles
The Byrds
Creedence Clearwater Revival
Fairport Convention
The Moody Blues
The Rolling Stones
Simon and Garfunkel
The Velvet Underground

Read on for album reviews of artists who don’t quite qualify for their own page.


Retrospective – Buffalo Springfield

Retrospective the best of Buffalo Springfield1969, 8/10
According to legend, Stephen Stills chased down the black hearse driven by Canadians Neil Young and Bruce Palmer, forming the basis for 1960’s L.A. folk-rock group Buffalo Springfield. While Buffalo Springfield lasted less than two years and three albums and only enjoyed one hit single (Stills’ ‘For What It’s Worth’, aka “Stop, hey, what’s that sound?”, which has been retrospectively adopted as a counter-cultural anthem by TV documentaries and feel-good movie makers), if nothing else they are notable as a training ground.

Neil Young went on to a long and varied solo career, Stills formed Crosby, Stills and Nash while third singer-guitarist Richie Furay formed country-rock group Poco. So while Buffalo Springfield were a seminal group in their own right, Retrospective is doubly interesting as a fascinating insight into the development of Young and Stills.

Young’s restless creativity kicks in right from day one of the Springfield; he’s already self-mythologising in ‘Broken Arrow’ while his six songs on Retrospective presage the amount of musical ground he would cover in his solo career. Young was less than confident about his vocal abilities so Furay takes on the lead vocals on the charming ‘Nowadays Clancy Can’t Even Sing’.

On the other hand, Stills’ material on Retrospective has a degree of charm, but it hardly points the way to his early CSN peaks like ‘Suite: Judy Blue Eyes’ and ‘Carry On’; ‘Go and Say Goodbye’ sounds like apt material for a uncool folk outfit like The Seekers or The Kingston Trio. The time in between the demise of Buffalo Springfield and Crosby, Stills and Nash was well spent in day long jamming sessions with Jimi Hendrix. While Stills arguably turned out as a superior guitarist to the more heralded Young, his skills haven’t come to fruition here

Young’s guitar lines in ‘For What It’s Worth’ are minimalist perfection; the solo he produces in the fade-out is modest but it fits the song perfectly. Along with ‘For What It’s Worth’, Young’s epics are the most noteworthy pieces on Retrospective; the multi-part ‘Broken Arrow’ wears its obvious Sgt. Peppers influences on its sleeve, while ‘Expecting to Fly’ is a beautiful string laden ballad. Stills’ ‘Rock and Roll Woman’, supposedly about Jefferson Airplane’s Grace Slick, combines David Crosby and Stills voices on record for the first time with excellent results. Furay’s sole contribution ‘Kind Woman’ is merely pleasant.

With only two years of material, some of the material isn’t quite compilation worthy. While it may be more sensible to buy Buffalo Springfield’s individual albums, Retrospective is an excellent budget priced selection of a slightly overlooked sixties group.


At Folsom Prison – Johnny Cash

Johnny Cash Folsom Prison1968, 6/10
Johnny Cash always had a bullet proof reputation, both a respected elder statesman of country music and an anti-authoritarian hero. His baritone is authoritative, imbuing his music with gravitas, and it’s perfect for these dark tales of crime and punishment that he’s singing to an appreciative prison audience. Cash performs with backing band The Tennessee Three, and it was recorded at a time when he’d cleaned up his personal life.

Cash has the captive audience lapping up these songs, and it’s a compelling performance – songs like the execution countdown of ’25 Minutes To Go’ are riveting. But with Cash’s limited vocal style and these simple country songs, At Folsom Prison is an event more than a record that stands up to repeated listening. There are highlights like Cash’s sensitive vocal performance on ‘Long Black Veil’ and June Carter’s harmony vocals on the lively ‘Jackson’.

At Folsom Prison is a terrific document of a masterful live performer, and it’s something that every music fan should hear. But it’s not an album that I need to have in my collection.



Diamond’s And Gold – Neil Diamond

Diamonds and Gold Neil Diamond1973, 7/10
Diamond’s And Gold captures Neil Diamond’s early period before the sparkly shirts began to take a toll on his career. It collects the highlights from his first two albums, as well as the non album single ‘Kentucky Woman’. Although he later fabricated a story, in order to make himself “more interesting”, that he ran away from home at the age of 13 to join a band, Diamond started his career as a professional songwriter in the Brill Building after dropping out of med school.

His songs on Diamond’s And Gold bear definite traces of the sixties pop production line; less densely produced than the Spector model, with a constant acoustic guitar to remind us of Diamond’s status as songwriter and musician, but with the same overlaid elements of horn sections, female backing singers, organs, and strings. It’s dippy sixties pop, with simple romantic themes and a hint of melancholy; it’s a guilty pleasure, but to a lesser extent than ‘Song Sung Blue’ or ‘You Don’t Bring Me Flowers’.

Diamond certainly had a knack of crafting catchy pop songs, and it’s most apparent in his earliest work. Along with his own staples, ‘Cherry Cherry’, ‘Kentucky Woman’ and ‘Solitary Man’, Diamond’s And Gold also features ‘I’m A Believer’, ‘Red Red Wine’, and ‘Girl You’ll Be A Woman Soon’, popularised by The Monkees, UB40, and Pulp Fiction respectively. On the second tier, we have the ultra-catchy ‘Oh, No, No (I Got The Feeling)’,  ‘Thank The Lord For The Night Time’ and the awkward ‘Shilo’.

Elsewhere the standard drops off; Diamond’s cover of ‘Monday Monday’ doesn’t measure up to The Mamas And The Papas’ original, while a few of the other songs are disposable. For a professional songwriter, Diamond didn’t know too many chords, but most of these songs are harmless enough. Neil Diamond went on to write some more great songs, such as ‘Brother Love’s Travelling Salvation Show’ and ‘Holly Holy’, but he was never this humble and approachable again.



Alice’s Restaurant

Arlo Guthrie Alice's Restaurant1967, 6.5/10
Arlo Guthrie came to folk music with an incredible pedigree, the son of folk legend Woody Guthrie who met and jammed with other famous musicians such as Pete Seeger and Leadbelly as they visited his home. He rose to prominence at the 1967 Newport Folk Festival at the age of 20 where the lengthy talking song ‘Alice’s Restaurant’ was first performed at a topical songs workshop.

While the song continues the acoustic simplicity of early 1960s protest folk, it’s also laced with a humour that makes its subversive litany on littering and the draft go down surprisingly easily. In fact, the song is much more notable for Guthrie’s comic timing and laconic delivery than it is for its musical content – the almost incessant guitar riff only adds to the humour – he’s as much a stand-up comedian as a musician over the eighteen minutes as he details his adventures trying to dispose of a half-tonne of garbage, in court and with the army psychiatrist, and the catchy chorus is only introduced towards the end of the song. The song’s following was strong enough to spawn a full length feature movie in 1970, starring Guthrie.

The second side of Alice’s Restaurant isn’t as memorable; with pleasant but generic folk like ‘Chilling of the Evening’ and ‘I’m Going Home’ and assorted silliness like ‘The Motorcycle Song’ (“I don’t want a pickle/I just want to ride my motor-sickle”) and ‘Ring-Around-A-Rosy Rag’, which uses a riff that’s too close to the infinite loop of the title track.

Alice’s Restaurant is an album that has been treated precisely right by posterity – it never makes top album of all time lists, and it doesn’t deserve too, but it’s still easily available and the title track enjoys a cult following and still holds up as a transcendent piece of work that’s as interesting as a piece of social history as it is as a song.



Dusty in Memphis – Dusty Springfield

Dusty in Memphis Dusty Springfield1969, 9.5/10
Dusty Springfield began her career in a folk-pop trio The Springfields with her brother Tom. When The Springfields broke up, she went on to solo success in the early 1960s with ‘I Only Wanna Be With You’ and ‘I Don’t Know What To Do With Myself’, showcasing her sensual voice. But by the late 1960s her star was fading, and she signed with Atlantic Records in an effort to reignite her career. Recording in Memphis, the production team of Jerry Wexler, Tom Dowd, and Arif Mardin gave her more direct, stripped down sound than she was accustomed to.

The standard from Dusty in Memphis is ‘Son of a Preacher Man’ – it was originally written for Aretha Franklin, who passed it over but recorded it after Springfield’s version became successful. Randy Newman contributes ‘Just One Smile’, previously a hit for Gene Pitney, and ‘I Don’t Want To Hear About It Anymore’, the ethereal ‘The Land of Make Believe’ is from Burt Bacharach, while the Carole King and Gerry Goffin team contributes four of the songs. Dusty in Memphisboasts a fabulous beginning trio, where each song lifts the ante from its predecessor – the mid-tempo, memorable ‘Just A Little Lovin” leads into the cool drama of ‘So Much Loving’, before delivering the tour de force of ‘Son of a Preacher Man’.

The ubiquitous ‘Son of a Preacher Man’ is only the tip of the iceberg; Dusty in Memphis boasts an entire album of splendid music that strikes a beautiful balance between the emotion of soul and the sophistication of professionally written pop.



Odessey and Oracle

Zombies Odessey and Oracle Review

1968, 10/10
Originally known for their British invasion hits ‘She’s Not There’ and ‘Tell Her No’, the Zombies also recorded as what’s now recognised as one of the finest albums of the sixties while in their death throes. With a warm, layered pop sound that’s derived from mid-sixties Beach Boys and Beatles records, in 1968 this album was probably a couple of years too late for mainstream acceptance. But with two strong song-writers, a sweet voiced singer backed by luscious harmonies, and a high level of musicianship corralled into succinct pop songs, Odessey and Oracleis a landmark and absolutely essential for any sixties pop fan. The songs, written by keyboard player Rod Argent and bassist Chris White, are generally sweet in tone, yet there’s still tension like the bittersweet welcome home to a lover released from prison in ‘Care of Cell 44’ and the romantic resignation of ‘Maybe After He’s Gone’. While White’s bass is prominent and guitarist Paul Atkinson also contributes some memorable lines, it’s the acoustic piano and mellotron of Argent that are the main musical feature, while the harmonised vocals of Rod Blunstone, White and Argent are also beautiful and ornate.

Of the twelve songs, it’s the two longer and more experimental tracks that are most difficult. The main stumbling block is Chris White’s ‘Butcher’s Tale’; its dour delivery and obvious thematic agenda are almost enough to throw an otherwise perfect album off course, even if it’s hardly lacking in musical ideas in itself. The other song that doesn’t quite fit is ‘Changes’, also by White; it’s full of beautiful harmonies and mellotrons, but it’s also overlong and repetitive. Once adjusted to these two difficult tracks, the rest of the album provides a practically flawless display of pop music, melodic, beautifully arranged and gloriously sung. Blunstone’s warm vocals enliven the quietly devastating psychedelic vision of ‘Hung Up On A Dream’ and the loneliness of ‘A Rose For Emily’, while ‘This Will Be Our Year’ and ‘Friends of Mine’ bubble with unstoppable exuberance.

Despite their short tenure, The Zombies were among the finest groups of the 1960s, and Odessey and Oracle is their key statement.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: