For some reason I never found Aretha Franklin’s original studio albums in second-hand bins, and for years the only album I owned from her was a double disc retrospective. The second disc dabbles in her 1980s work, with star power duets with Elton John and Annie Lennox that sound dated next to her timeless hits from the 1960s and 1970s, and the compilation inevitably returns to the mother-lode of her early work.
But tucked away on the second disc is an improbably strong late period highlight. Written by Lauryn Hill, at the peak of her powers in 1998, ‘A Rose is Still a Rose’ sees Franklin taking the role of the older, wiser woman giving advice to one younger and inexperienced. Maybe its production ties it to its era, but ‘A Rose is Still a Rose’ is hooky and memorable in a way that Franklin hadn’t been since the early 1970s.
There was a rose I knew, I met her once or twice before
She was a pretty sweet thing, not the least bit insecure
Then you came with your slick game and played with her youth
Ashamed of the way you lied, played with the truth, hey, hey
Mmm, she never knew what hit her
Steal her honey, then forget her
A rose
She wears a flower
Tryin’ to forget about you
Cause a rose is still a rose
Baby, girl, you’re still a flower
He can’t lead you and then take you
Make you and then break you
Darlin’, you hold the power
Now believe me when I tell you that I’ve been hurt myself
When he tells you that he loves you and sees nobody else
And now you’re so tough tryin’ to wear tight clothes and things
Tossin’ and flossin’, tryin’ to fill the void heartbreak brings
Oh, oh, yeah
When she faces the mirror, yeah
She’s cryin’, you can’t hear her
Now the rose is still a rose
She wears a flower, tryin’ to forget about you
Cause a rose is still a rose
Baby, girl, you’re still a flower
He can’t lead you and then take you
Make you and then break you
Baby, girl, you hold the power
See a rose is still a rose
Baby, girl, you’re still a flower
He can’t lead you and then take you
Make you and then break you
Darlin’, you hold the power
Let your life be in the sunshine
Not the darkness of your sorrow
You may see your all today
When you know it’ll come tomorrow
Tough to be, but life ain’t over
Just because your man is gone
Girl, love yourself and love to love
Cause without him your life goes on
Without him your life goes on
Without him your life goes on
Cause a rose is still a rose
Baby, girl, you’re still a flower
He can’t lead you and then take you
Make you and then break you
Baby, girl, you hold the power
See a rose is still a rose
Baby, girl, you’re still a flower
He can’t lead you and then take you
Make you and then break you
Darlin’, you hold the power
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
9 Comments
While this is not my favorite Aretha Franklin tune, I’ve yet to hear a bad song from this amazing lady. She is one of those rare artists who can make even average songs sound great. Tina Turner also had that gift!
In the context of the compilation I have, it sounds like manna from heaven after ‘Who’s Zoomin’ Who’ and her Elton John duet.
Fair enough, though I have to say while it’s very mainstream pop, the “Who’s Zoomin’ Who” album does include at least a few tunes I still like. I’m thinking of “Freeway of Love” and “Sisters Are Doin’ It for Themselves” (featuring the Eurythmics). Even if these songs aren’t as great as “Natural Woman”, “Respect” or “I Say a Little Prayer”, it’s still Aretha and her incredible voice!:-)
Decent composition. At first I thought it was going to be built on that basic, pretty boring two-chord vamp, but it has some nice structure and development.
Lauryn Hill’s definitely an unfulfilled talent – she’s only made one studio album to date. Pretty generous to give away that tune, although it makes more sense coming from Franklin.
Good song, good message. Never heard it before. I was trying to place that ‘Rose is still a rose’ melody and realized it sounded like ‘When the eagle flies with the dove’ from ‘Love the one you’re with. ‘
I am a simple man. I see Aretha, I hit Like!
Why oh why didn’t Lauryn Hill become a major star , it still baffles me. I like this record a lot, and should really check the album out. Given that I lost touch with Aretha’s music after the 80s it seems like I missed out.
The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill was #1 in the U.S. and Canada, and #2 in the U.K. and Australia, she just never released another studio album. It’s really down to her personal life (six children, time in prison etc), not to public tastes.
I’m pretty sceptical that the parent album is any good – I assume that it’s a one-off success that’s mainly due to Hill’s input. But let me know if I’m wrong.
Comments are closed.
More from Aphoristic Album Reviews
Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
Review Pages
Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:
The Eagles achieved stratospheric success in the 1970s, effectively bridging the country rock and soft rock styles that were popular in the early 1970s. Songwriting team Don Henley and Glenn Frey pumped out a ton of popular singles, and their Their Greatest Hits (1971–1975) is one of the highest-selling albums […]
Amazingly, for a band divided into factions since the mid-1960s, it took until 1977 for a solo album to emerge from any of the original Beach Boys. Dennis Wilson’s lush, romantic Pacific Ocean Blue sold comparatively to The Beach Boys’ Love You, and gained a cult following after being out of […]
Richard X. Heyman started his career as a backing musician, drumming for Brian Wilson, Link Wray, and Jonathan Richman, and playing keyboards for Ben E King. A one man band, his work is tougher than early solo Paul McCartney and not as experimental as early Todd Rundgren, and more retrogressive […]
Britt Walford and Brian McMahan met in their pre-teens, and joined the punk band Squirrel Bait while still in their teens. Walford, a drummer, left Squirrel Bait after the band’s first recording sessions, but McMahan stayed on as second guitarist until their dissolution in 1987. Walford and McMahan joined forces […]
Album reviews of CCM artists who don’t qualify for their own page. Earthsuit | Tim Hughes | Solace Earthsuit Kaleidoscope Superior 2000, 7/10Judging solely from their debut album, it’s hard to tell whether New Orleans’ Earthsuit are someone’s cunning plan to provide a Christian alternative to the secular flavour of […]
Joy Division‘s lead vocalist Ian Curtis took his own life on the eve of the band’s first US tour. The band rebranded as New Order – taking their name from a newspaper article titled The People’s New Order of Kampuchea. They added Gillian Gilbert, the girlfriend of drummer Stephen Morris, […]
Blog Posts
I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:
The two figures at the centre of 1980s English indie-rock band The Smiths were an unlikely pairing. Vocalist Morrissey was socially awkward, literate, and camp, while guitarist Johnny Marr was an aspiring football player who trialled with Manchester City. Bonding over a shared interest in The New York Dolls, they […]
Elizabeth Woolridge Grant made an immediate impact on popular culture with her 2011 debut single ‘Video Games’, released under her stage name Lana Del Rey. Her haunting lower register and cinematic feel, chronicling a one-sided relationship. the single immediately established her as an artist with a unique voice. Her moody […]
Classically trained pianist Irmin Schmidt and music teacher Holger Czukay studied under Stockhausen. Both tuned into rock music as it progressed in the mid-1960s. Czukay’s student Michael Karoli played him The Beatles’ ‘I Am The Walrus’, while Schmidt discovered the music of Frank Zappa, James Brown, and The Velvet Underground […]
I spent my teenage years enamoured by the pop tunes of Billy Joel. Joel has a touch of show-tune about his work, and his work has never been as critically acclaimed as his more celebrated contemporaries like Bruce Springsteen or Elvis Costello. Nevertheless, Billy Joel has plenty of natural assets […]
Swedish quartet ABBA were massively popular from the mid-1970s to the early 1980s. They were effectively a supergroup when they formed in 1972 – Agnetha Fältskog was already a solo star in Sweden while songwriting team Björn Ulvaeus and Benny Andersson had served their apprenticeships in 1960s folk acts. The […]
The late Scott Walker was one of the most fascinating artists of the rock era, successful as both a crooner and as an avant-garde composer. Accordingly, this list of Walker favourites is scattershot, ranging from easy listening covers to his experimental later work. Scott Walker was born in Ohio but […]
While this is not my favorite Aretha Franklin tune, I’ve yet to hear a bad song from this amazing lady. She is one of those rare artists who can make even average songs sound great. Tina Turner also had that gift!
In the context of the compilation I have, it sounds like manna from heaven after ‘Who’s Zoomin’ Who’ and her Elton John duet.
Fair enough, though I have to say while it’s very mainstream pop, the “Who’s Zoomin’ Who” album does include at least a few tunes I still like. I’m thinking of “Freeway of Love” and “Sisters Are Doin’ It for Themselves” (featuring the Eurythmics). Even if these songs aren’t as great as “Natural Woman”, “Respect” or “I Say a Little Prayer”, it’s still Aretha and her incredible voice!:-)
Decent composition. At first I thought it was going to be built on that basic, pretty boring two-chord vamp, but it has some nice structure and development.
Lauryn Hill’s definitely an unfulfilled talent – she’s only made one studio album to date. Pretty generous to give away that tune, although it makes more sense coming from Franklin.
Good song, good message. Never heard it before. I was trying to place that ‘Rose is still a rose’ melody and realized it sounded like ‘When the eagle flies with the dove’ from ‘Love the one you’re with. ‘
I am a simple man. I see Aretha, I hit Like!
Why oh why didn’t Lauryn Hill become a major star , it still baffles me. I like this record a lot, and should really check the album out. Given that I lost touch with Aretha’s music after the 80s it seems like I missed out.
The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill was #1 in the U.S. and Canada, and #2 in the U.K. and Australia, she just never released another studio album. It’s really down to her personal life (six children, time in prison etc), not to public tastes.
I’m pretty sceptical that the parent album is any good – I assume that it’s a one-off success that’s mainly due to Hill’s input. But let me know if I’m wrong.