The Anne of Green Gables Series: Ranked

My grandmother was a dedicated L.M. Montgomery fan. She had an entire display cabinet filled with Montgomery’s work and made the pilgrimage from Christchurch, New Zealand, to Canada to visit Prince Edward Island. The appreciation of the Anne books has passed down the generations – I’m now reading them to my pre-teen daughter.

The series chronicles the adventures of Prince Edward Island orphan Anne Shirley, accidentally adopted by a pair of aging siblings. The series chronicles her life from her adoption at age 11, around the mid-1870s, until the end of the First World War, when Anne is in her early fifties.

Unusually for a book series, Montgomery returned to Anne in her later years and filled in some gaps in her chronology. The two later-written books are much weaker – if you’re reading the eight books in order of Anne’s life, it’s easy to get discouraged mid-series. If you take away anything from this article, it’s that it’s worth skipping some of the lesser books in the middle of Anne’s arc to reach the stronger books at the end of the series – Rainbow Valley and Rilla of Ingleside.

Anne Books Ranked

#8 Anne of Ingleside

Book #6, published 1939
L.M. Montgomery is a natural short-story writer, and the Anne series is weakest when she lapses into a series of vignettes with no over-arching narrative. This is especially true of Anne of Ingleside – it does little more than tell some inconsequential stories between Anne’s House of Dreams and Rainbow Valley. There’s little at stake and the closing pages contain an unwelcome spoiler for a major event in Rilla of Ingleside. As Montgomery aged, she became more inclined to feature grumpy old ladies in her stories.

#7 Anne of Windy Poplars

Book #4, published 1936
Like Ingleside, Windy Poplars is a later book that fills in a chronological gap in Anne’s story – this time, the period between her engagement and marriage. The format of the story, often told in letters from Anne to her fiancé, makes it a messy read. But there are worthy plot ideas all the same – Anne’s relationships with colleague Katherine Brooke and the Pringle family are both filled with delightful tension. For some reason, the book was originally titled Anne of Windy Willows in some countries.

#6 Anne’s House of Dreams

Book #5, published 1917
A newly married Anne moves away from Avonlea to Glen St. Mary. There’s an interesting narrative around Anne’s new friend, the distant Leslie Moore, while man-blaming Miss Cornelia is fun. But Captain Jim is an unwelcome intruder, hogging the spotlight away from Anne. He prattles on so much that the book could have been titled Captain Jim’s Lighthouse of Dreams. It’s unrealistic that a hardened sea captain is so genteel – Montgomery is much better at portraying female characters and children. The absence of children and adolescents in House of Dreams makes it more serious than most other books in the series.

#5 Anne of Avonlea

Book #2, published 1909
The second Anne book covers her tenure as a teacher in Avonlea’s school for two years. It’s less eventful than the books on either side, with little at stake to push the narrative forward, but it’s charming anyway. Anne has largely outgrown youthful hi-jinks. To compensate, Marilla adopts twins, Davy and Dora Keith, and the naughtiness of Davy provides much of the humour of the book. Grumpy neighbour Mr Harrison is another welcome addition to Avonlea.

#4 Rainbow Valley

Book #7, published 1919
Anne is merely a supporting character in the seventh book of the series. The focus shifts to the motherless family who has shifted into the manse of Glen St. Mary. Rainbow Valley chronicles their adventures alongside Anne’s own children. Rainbow Valley was inspired by Montgomery’s own life as a minister’s wife. It was my grandmother’s favourite Anne book – she enjoyed the antics of the children.

#3 Anne of Green Gables

Book #1, published 1908
The first Anne chronicle features the series’ most iconic characters. Alongside the talkative orphan Anne Shirley, the shy Matthew Cuthbert, his acerbic sister Marilla, and their opinionated neighbour Rachel Lynde are all among Montgomery’s best creations. The story loses momentum around the middle as it chronicles a series of Anne’s misadventures, but it still features some of Anne’s most iconic moments. The story relies upon Anne’s confused relationship with Gilbert Blythe to keep a common thread.

#2 Anne of the Island

Book #3, published 1915
Anne enters adulthood in the third book in the series, and accordingly, Anne of the Island ratchets up the tension. By my count, she receives six offers of marriage during the four years that she spends at Redmond College in Kingsport. There’s not only marriage at stake – a childhood friend passes away, while another becomes a mother. The pacing is a little odd at times – it spends more time on her packing for Redmond than it does on entire years of college. But the final few chapters are some of the most emotional in the series, as Anne makes significant life decisions. Davy’s letter writing recalls the childhood charms of the earlier books.

#1 Rilla of Ingleside

Book #8, published 1921
Like Rainbow Valley, Anne is merely a supporting character in Rilla of Ingleside. Her youngest daughter, Rilla, is the focus, while the family’s housekeeper Susan Baker also enjoys the limelight. Rilla of Ingleside is notable as a contemporary Canadian book written by a female author about World War I. It’s darker than the other Anne books – the events of the war cast a shadow over Glen St. Mary, with young men going to war. Rilla of Ingleside is fiercely patriotic – the outbreak of World War II upset Montgomery intensely. In a 1940 letter, she wrote, “This nightmare that has been loosed on the world… unfair that we should have to go through it again.”

Do you have a favourite book in the Anne series?

Read more

The Chronicles of Prydain ranked


Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.


    • I’ve actually read The Blue Castle, but didn’t know about the plagiarism case. Seems pretty clearcut, right?

      • Basically everything on the CBC TV is:
        1. News
        2. Hockey
        3. Curling
        4. Anything to do with Anne – “Road to avonlea”, “Wind at my Back “ etc
        5. Coronation Street.

        But as far as plagiarism in the arts goes:

        It’s relatively easy to put two books or two works of art side by side.

        It’s harder with music, much more subjective. But that didn’t stop people from going after George Harrison (successfully) and RHCP and Coldplay.

        I find it all very interesting

        • Music has more elements too – there’s rhythm, chord structure, instrumentation etc, as well as the melody. I don’t think ‘She’s So Fine’ had a particularly strong plagiarism case.

  1. I never read the books but I saw the old movie from the 30s or something and I could never figure out why the actress who played her had the same name as the character. First I thought maybe she was the author who wrote the book, but she looked too young and the author’s name wasn’t Anne Shirley. I guess it was just a coincidence that they had the same name. But that sounds too weird.

  2. I haven’t read Montgomery so don’t have a favorite book (I read books in the Hardy Boys series) but I think it’s great you are reading these books to your daughter. Book reading is on the decline, unfortunately. And I’m sure your daughter will have great memories of your spending private time with her.

    • Both our daughters are pretty keen readers – older one loves Harry Potter (as do her friends at school). Younger one had her light on past her bedtime reading quietly, which I guess is OK.

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

The Front Lawn Album Reviews

Growing up in Auckland’s North Shore, Don McGlashan and Harry Sinclair wished to defer their careers when they returned from their Overseas Experiences. McGlashan had already drummed for the Auckland post-punk trio, Blam Blam Blam, penning the music for ‘There Is No Depression In New Zealand’. Sinclair’s background is in […]
Jason Isbell The Nashville Sound
Jason Isbell Album Reviews

Jason Isbell joined Patterson Hood and Mike Cooley as a guitarist and vocalist in acclaimed Southern Rock band, The Drive-By Truckers, in 2002. He immediately impressed with songs like ‘Outfit’, which details his father’s advice to him upon joining the band (“Don’t worry about losing your accent, a southern man […]
Bressa Creeting Cake

Ed McWilliams and Geoff Maddock met in art class at high school in Auckland, New Zealand, and formed the trio Breast Secreting Cake with drummer Joel Wilton. The group were forced to change the name of their band, and chose Bressa Creeting Cake. Each member took a part of the […]
Led Zeppelin Houses of the Holy
Led Zeppelin Album Reviews

Led Zeppelin was hastily formed by Yardbirds’ guitarist Jimmy Page in order to tour to fulfil contractual obligations. Page grabbed another session veteran, John Paul Jones, on bass, and recruited singer Robert Plant and drummer John Bonham from a local band. Given the circumstances of this pragmatic and sudden formation, […]
Erika de Casier Album Reviews

Smooth R&B artist Erika de Casier was born in Portugal with a Belgian mother and Cape Verdean father. She’s now based in Copenhagen, Denmark, starting her career working in a kindergarten. She spent time in the duo Saint Cava – they never released a full-length album but played the Roskilde […]
Dave Dobbyn Album Reviews

Every country has a songwriter who’s very successful in their own territory, but hasn’t translated well elsewhere; Australia has Paul Kelly, and Canada had Gord Downie from The Tragically Hip. New Zealand’s equivalent is Dave Dobbyn, a songwriter who emerged in the pub rock scene of the late 1970s. Dobbyn […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

Joni Mitchell Clouds
Joni Mitchell: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

Joni Mitchell emerged at a time when the women’s rights movement was still building steam and had to fight for recognition as a serious artist. Her image was often defined in terms of whom she was dating – a Rolling Stone article dubbed her “The Queen of El Lay”. As Mitchell’s […]
Simon & Garfunkel Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel started their recording career as Tom & Jerry in 1957, making teen-oriented Everly Brothers style pop. After a temporary split, they re-branded as Simon & Garfunkel, an earnest folk duo. Their debut album, 1964’s Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M., was unsuccessful, and a frustrated Simon relocated to […]
Creedence Clearwater Revival Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Creedence Clearwater Revival emerged in 1968, seemingly from a Florida swamp but actually from El Cerrito in California. Rebelling against the psychedelic music that was prevalent at the time, Creedence began their career playing stripped-down and bluesy swamp rock. As CCR’s career progressed, frontman John Fogerty’s writing grew in confidence, […]
10 Best Gene Clark Songs

Gene Clark is best-known as an original member of The Byrds. He was the first to leave the group – with a fear of flying he disliked touring, while the other members resented his song-writing royalties. The most accomplished songwriter in the original line-up, it’s not surprising that he went […]
The Police: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

Stewart Copeland, Sting, and Andy Summers were all veteran musicians when they formed The Police in London in 1977. Copeland had drummed for progressive rock band Curved Air, Sting had played in the jazz fusion band Last Exit, while Summers’ career as a guitarist dated back to the 1960s when […]
The Anne of Green Gables Series: Ranked

My grandmother was a dedicated L.M. Montgomery fan. She had an entire display cabinet filled with Montgomery’s work and made the pilgrimage from Christchurch, New Zealand, to Canada to visit Prince Edward Island. The appreciation of the Anne books has passed down the generations – I’m now reading them to […]
%d bloggers like this: