Sheryl Crow Album Reviews

Sheryl Crow was already on the wrong side of 30 when she released her debut album. After attending the University of Missouri with Brad Pitt, Crow spent her twenties working as a music teacher, writing advertising jingles, and performing as a backing singer for Michael Jackson and Don Henley.

When her 1993 debut album Tuesday Night Music Club emerged, spearheaded by the single ‘All I Wanna Do’, it was notable for Crow’s traditional approach. Ignoring the grunge prevalent at the time, Crow’s music instead drew on 1960s and 1970s classic rock, like The Rolling Stones, Fleetwood Mac, and The Small Faces.

While I find her albums inconsistent, Crow’s been influential on the next generation of artists. HAIM have covered ‘Strong Enough’ live, while Crow’s influence looms large over indie acts like Soccer Mommy.

Sheryl Crow Album Reviews

Tuesday Night Music Club | Sheryl Crow | The Globe Sessions | (Sheryl Crow has released at least eight more studio albums but her first three are her most acclaimed so I’m not keen to venture any further….)

Tuesday Night Music Club

1993, 5.5/10
Sheryl Crow’s debut album is named for the group of musicians who convened every Tuesday night to work on material. The sessions were organised by Bill Bottrell, who’d previously worked with Madonna, Tom Petty, and Electric Light Orchestra – he produced this record. Crow’s first single, ‘Leaving Las Vegas’ was unsuccessful. The third single ‘All I Wanna Do’, belatedly released in April 1994, and based on Wyn Cooper’s poem ‘Fun’, propelled Crow into the big-time.

Tuesday Night Music Club opens with a fascinating line – she singles out 22 November 1963 as the day that Aldous Huxley died, an interesting choice given that John F Kennedy and CS Lewis died on the same day. Unfortunately, it’s all downhill from there; despite some competent songwriting, Tuesday Night Music Club suffers from long track running times and a lack of originality. Song titles ‘What I Can Do For You’, ‘All I Wanna Do’ and ‘We Do What We Can’ all in a row raise questions. What is Crow doing? What can Crow do? I don’t know, but she does drop us a hint with her song title ‘No One Said It Would Be Easy’.

Tuesday Night Music Club successfully launched Sheryl Crow’s career, but her next two records are much stronger.

Sheryl Crow

1996, 7.5/10
As with her debut, Sheryl Crow is often derivative and her songs are overlong, but her writing is very solid here. Although she’s generally associated with the guitar, Crow largely plays keyboards and bass here and she does an excellent job. Unsurprisingly, given her degree in classical piano, Sheryl Crow features nice Wurlitzer and Hammond organ parts. Despite the keyboards, Sheryl Crow lives up to its dishevelled rock-chick cover art; it’s tangibly grungier and rougher than her other work.

‘Hard To Make A Stand’ is the best song here, a concise and universal declaration, while ‘Home’ uses Crow’s pure upper register to good effect. ‘If It Makes You Happy’, ‘A Change Would Do You Good’ and ‘Everyday Is A Winding Road’ were all over the radio in 1996; Crowded House’s Neil Finn, with whom Sheryl Crow used to tour as a support act, contributes audible backing vocals in the latter.

It’s hardly surprising that Crow demonstrates a healthy appreciation of classic rock in ‘Ordinary Morning’, compressing snatches of Lennon, The Beatles and Pink Floyd into “But when I awoke/The dream didn’t end/Now everytime I turn around/I’m only sleeping, John/Is anybody out there?/Don’t the wounded birds still sing?” Aided by Mitchell Froom, ‘The Book’ features an unsettling orchestral arrangement that provides a respite from Crow’s usual retro rock and roll.

The long running time of Sheryl Crow, with its incessant monochromatic country-tinged, retro-rock makes it a chore to sit through. But there’s strong material here, and it’s a shame that Crow didn’t have a sympathetic producer to chop down her tracks’ running time and push for more variety.

The Globe Sessions

1998, 6.5/10
Sheryl Crow started writing on bass for The Globe Sessions, in an effort to place more emphasis on melody. The Globe Sessions benefits from a broader stylistic palette and a more relaxed sound. Guests include Lisa Germano on violin, Benmont Tench on keyboards, and Wendy Melvoin.

The Globe Sessions also features my favourite Crow song; the opening track ‘My Favourite Mistake’ bursts out of the starting gate with a great guitar riff that’s Crow’s greatest contribution to musical posterity. Bob Dylan gave Crow the Time Out Of Mind outtake ‘Mississippi’ to cover and she does a great job – Dylan’s own version showed up on Love And Theft. Conversely, The Globe Sessions are less consistent than Sheryl Crow; songs like the repetitive riff of ‘Resuscitation’ and ‘Members Only’ aren’t among Crow’s best.

‘My Favourite Mistake’ is brilliant, but if you’re looking into Crow’s catalogue, a compilation is probably a good option.

Five Best Sheryl Crow Songs

My Favourite Mistake
Hard To Make A Stand
Everyday Is A Winding Road
Run Baby Run


  1. Nice summary.
    I think Music Enthusiast did a piece on Tuesday Night Music Club not so long ago which inspired me to revisit Ms Crow’s work which I eventually managed to do recently. I’d be tempted to add another couple of points to Sheryl Crow (that production really does help and make for a compelling listen) and Globe Sessions (though There Goes The Neighbourhood is a duff note). Beyond these I tuned out a bit but Wildflower isn’t too shabby and Be Myself (which was produced by the same team as SC and Globe) is worthwhile. The rest errs too far on the side of samey and schmaltz for my liking.

    • Thanks for reading. I think I’ve made about 130 artist pages, and Sheryl Crow is my least favourite of the artists I’ve given a page to. I wouldn’t have covered her, but I already had written the reviews back in the day from my sister’s CD collection. And ‘My Favourite Mistake’ is a great song. Wish her albums were shorter – she had the misfortune of peaking in the 1990s when everything ran for an hour.

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Sigur Rós

Iceland’s most famous post-rock band  is named after the sister of singer/guitarist Jónsi Birgisson, who was born on the same day as the band was formed in Reykjavík in 1994. The group combine Jonsi’s high pitched, gorgeous voice with pretty melodies and atmospheric backdrops. The group broke through to music […]
Nic Jones Album Reviews

Born in Kent, Nic Jones grew up listening to Ray Charles, The Shadows, and Chet Atkins. School friends encouraged him to frequent folk clubs where he heard artists like Bert Jansch and Shirley Collins. He joined The Halliard, releasing two albums with them in the late 1960s. When The Halliard […]
Portishead Dummy
Portishead Album Reviews

Portishead formed in the city of Bristol, where a vibrant, multi-cultural music scene spawned trip-hop in the early 1990s. Trip-hop took the beats from hip hop, and slowed them down, adding textures and songs. Alongside Portishead, essentially the entire trip-hip scene originated in Bristol, with Massive Attack and Tricky also […]
Natalie Prass Album Reviews

Natalie Prass was born in Cleveland, Ohio, and grew up in Richmond, Virginia. She went to Berklee College of Music and served as a keyboardist in Jenny Lewis’ backing band. Prass signed with Matthew E. White’s Spacebomb Records and released her debut album in 2015. Prass’ career is only two […]
Caroline Polachek Album Reviews

Caroline Polachek grew up in Connecticut and was formerly the vocalist for the indie-pop duo Chairlift. Chairlift enjoyed a surprise hit in 2008 with ‘Bruises’, which featured in an Apple commercial. Polachek’s previously flirted with a solo career, releasing albums under the aliases Ramona Lisa and CEP, but 2019’s Pang was her […]
Jamila Woods Album Reviews

Chicago’s Jamila Woods is a recording artist and writer. She graduated from Brown University with a B.A. in Africana Studies and Theater & Performance Studies. Her poetry has been featured in anthologies like Courage: Daring Poems for Gutsy Girls, and both her writing and music focus on the themes of […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

Asterix Books: Ranked from Worst to Best

The Gaulish warrior Asterix has been a French institution since he first appeared in 1961’s Asterix the Gaul. He’s accompanied by his inseparable friend Obelix and aided by the druid Getafix’s magic potion that gives superhuman strength. His cunning defends his Gaulish village from Romans, Vikings, and even aliens. Three […]
John Martyn Serendipity
10 Best John Martyn Songs

The late John Martyn never enjoyed the mass acclaim that his immense talent deserved. Nonetheless, he delivered a string of great records in the 1970s and early 1980s. He started as a folk artist, emerging in the late 1960s alongside Nick Drake and Richard Thompson. By the early 1970s, Martyn […]
The Smiths 1984 Debut
The Smiths: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

The two figures at the centre of 1980s English indie-rock band The Smiths were an unlikely pairing. Vocalist Morrissey was socially awkward, literate, and camp, while guitarist Johnny Marr was an aspiring football player who trialled with Manchester City. Bonding over a shared interest in The New York Dolls, they […]
Hokey Pokey Richard and Linda Thompson
Richard and Linda Thompson Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

English folk-rock duo Richard and Linda Thompson’s career resembled a soap opera. Active as recording artists between 1974 and 1982, they married, released three albums in quick succession, then spent three years in a Sufi Muslim commune where Richard’s religious leader forbade him from playing music. Leaving the commune, their […]
Neil Diamond's Five Worst Songs

Adult contemporary superstar and Hebrew Hunk Neil Diamond is a fascinating figure to me. His music is an uncomfortable blend of Brill Building pop, gospel, and confessional writing, like he can’t make up his mind whether he wants to be Elvis Presley or James Taylor. As an adolescent, I was […]
10 Best Echo & the Bunnymen Songs

Liverpool’s second-most famous band, Echo & the Bunnymen arrived in the post-punk era; they released their debut single in 1979. Their early career mirrors U2‘s – both released their first four albums between 1980 and 1984. Both were enjoying mainstream success in the UK by 1984 – Echo & the […]
%d bloggers like this: