Transatlantic: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

The progressive rock supergroup Transatlantic played the last concert of their Absolute Universe tour in July 2022. The group have hinted that it might be their final tour, so it’s possible that their studio catalogue might remain as the five albums they’ve recorded between 2000 and 2021.

It was such a special night last night. The last show of the tour and who knows maybe the last show forever. We’ve had a good run that’s for sure.
The European leg has been really great and to end it in such an iconic venue will be a very special memory for us all.
Thank you Paris you as always special.

Pete Trewavas, Facebook

That Transatlantic managed to make five albums is impressive – all four members started in other notable bands, and Transatlantic has largely remained a part-time venture, fitted in between other activities. Mike Portnoy was Dream Theater’s founding drummer, while bassist Pete Trewavas has played with Marillion for more than forty years. Guitarist Roine Stolte also leads The Flower Kings, while singer and keyboardist Neal Morse started his career in Spock’s Beard. Despite their part-time nature, there’s a good argument that Transatlantic are the premiere progressive rock band of the 21st century.

Here are their five studio records ranked.

#5 Kaleidoscope

As the title implies, Transatlantic’s fourth album takes some cues from 1960s psychedelia – on the deluxe version there are covers of The Moody Blues’ ‘Nights in White Satin’ and The Small Faces’ ‘Tin Soldier’. The two epics, ‘Into The Blue’ and the title track, are impressive. The middle sags a little with sentimental Morse tracks, although his Moog soloing on the Stolt-led ‘Black as the Sky’ is enjoyable. Touring guitarist Daniel Gildenlöw, from Pain of Salvation, contributes vocals on ‘Into the Blue’.

#4 SMPT:e

Transatlantic’s debut album was a quickly realised side-project – the tracks were written and largely recorded in two weeks. The fan favourite ‘All of the Above’ is one of the band’s weaker epics in this writer’s opinion, but Stolt’s ‘My New World’ is enjoyable. The album ends with a cover of Procol Harum’s ‘In Held (‘Twas) In I’, often held to be the first recorded progressive rock song.

#3 The Absolute Universe: Forevermore

Transatlantic’s fifth album has a convoluted history – the band recorded a 90-minute album before the COVID-19 pandemic. When Morse revisited the album, he created a stripped-down 64-minute version. The band was divided into two camps, with Stolt and Portnoy preferring the longer version. Portnoy suggested releasing both – there’s also a 96-minute edition that combines both versions. It started as a sequel to The Whirlwind but became an exploration of how Morse’s Ayn Rand-inspired libertarian beliefs were replaced by Christianity. It’s more inspired by 1970s progressive rock than other Transatlantic records – Stolt’s guitar licks on ‘The World We Used To Know’ evoke Yes’ Relayer. If it’s indeed their final album, The Absolute Universe is a fine way to go out.

#2 Bridge Across Forever

Transatlantic refined their approach for their second album, purposefully balancing the four members’ contributions after critics suggested the debut was dominated by Morse. The record’s dominated by three lengthy epics – ‘Duel With The Devil’, the surprisingly funky ‘Suite Charlotte Pike’, and ‘Stranger in Your Soul’ are all tier one Transatlantic pieces. Morse’s gorgeous, piano-led title track is his best solo spotlight in the band.

#1 The Whirlwind

More isn’t always more when it comes to progressive rock – think Yes’ laborious Tales From Topographic Oceans. But Transatlantic’s best album is their most ambitious – The Whirlwind is a single 78-minute track, divided into 12 sections for listening convenience. Morse left Transatlantic after finding God in 2002, but upon their reformation, he brings God into Transatlantic – the grand finale is titled ‘Dancing With Eternal Glory’. Most crucially, the musical themes are the band’s most memorable – in particular the descending bass chord sequence on “We’re on a trip in a foreign land/Reach for home, where the kingdom stands” is my favourite Transatlantic moment.

Read More


Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.


  1. I agree with your choice for their best and their weakest albums, but the three in the middle are all equally brilliant. I still recall my excitement leading up to the release of their debut, as I was already a huge fan of the members’ main bands, and it lived up to the hype. I’m amazed they lasted beyond one or two albums, which is how most of these projects end up. They may never top The Whirlwind but I hope they keep trying.

    • They’ve been making noises that their run might be over – they’ve only been making albums every 6-8 years since Bridge Across Forever, and Stolt will be well into his 70s if they keep doing that. They’ve achieved a lot for a side project. I prefer them to what I’ve heard from the parent bands, apart from the last two albums Fish made with Marillion.

  2. I didn’t know that you could do shit over on this WordPress thing. I didn’t even know this existed. I just clicked Reader cuz I didn’t know what it was and then it came up. How come it looks different than your blog though? I never really understood how all this blog stuff works. Is this comment going to show up on your regular thing too or just here? Does it send messages to email and stuff? This is so weird to me cuz I never saw any of this stuff before. I don’t know this band either. I see it has something to do with Marillion, whom I sort of know who they are. Kind of.

    • The Wordpress reader is pretty useful for keeping up with all the blogs I follow. It messes with some of the formatting though – it simplifies it and makes it more uniform, which is understandable.

      The comment came through to my blog fine.

      Transatlantic have (or had?) the Marillion bass player as a member.

  3. Interesting. Don’t know Whirlwind, but Morse’s relentless piety would be enough to put me off, I’m afraid. And I must ask you to step outside to discuss Tales From Topographic Oceans. It is rich, inventive, and rewarding over decades of listening (for some). ?

    • The debut STMP has much less religious content than the others and might be worth a crack. Morse is a really good vocalist – prog needs strong singers.

      To be fair I’ve owned a physical copy of TFTO for more than two decades at this point.

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Led Zeppelin Houses of the Holy
Led Zeppelin Album Reviews

Led Zeppelin was hastily formed by Yardbirds’ guitarist Jimmy Page in order to tour to fulfil contractual obligations. Page grabbed another session veteran, John Paul Jones, on bass, and recruited singer Robert Plant and drummer John Bonham from a local band. Given the circumstances of this pragmatic and sudden formation, […]
New Zealand Miscellany

Fat Freddy’s Drop | Fly My Pretties | Aldous Harding | Kerry Logan | L.A. Mitchell | Supergroove Fat Freddy’s Drop Based On A True Story 2005, 6/10Polynesian dub band Fat Freddy’s Drop hit the mainstream in New Zealand in the early 21st century; their music becoming a favourite for live […]
Nick Drake Bryter Layter
Nick Drake Album Reviews

A gentle-sounding English folk-artist, Nick Drake hardly made a ripple during his short lifetime. He was too shy to play live and barely sold a record. Posthumously, his small catalogue has earned plenty of attention; his delicate and measured approach produced some of the most timeless music of his generation. […]
Recent Additions

I usually add a couple of artist pages to this site each month. Refer to Upcoming Reviews for a list of artists that I’m planning to review. Planned pages for the near future include The Chills, Dawn Richard, and Curtis Mayfield. I’m also planning to create mini-pages for newer artists […]
James Taylor Album Reviews

Introduction With his warm voice, pretty guitar-picking, and introspective songwriting, James Vernon Taylor was the figurehead of the singer-songwriter movement in the early 1970s. His 1968 debut album on The Beatles‘ Apple label flopped, despite featuring one of his best songs ‘Carolina In My Mind’, as well as ‘Something In The Way […]
Taylor Swift Album Reviews

When I started this site, I wouldn’t have considered reviewing a country-pop teenage starlet, but Taylor Swift has enjoyed a phenomenally successful career where she’s transcended genre boundaries. Named after James Taylor, even as she’s left the country genre, Swift has retained the confessional, story-telling narratives of country in her […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

10 Best Kate Bush Songs

English art-pop artist Kate Bush is a creative genius, who siphoned her influences into her own unique blend. The folk music from her Irish mother, the progressive rock that her older brothers listened to as teenagers, and radio-friendly pop like Elton John were all melded into Kate Bush’s music. Literature […]
10 Best Parry Gripp Songs

My 8-year-old daughter decided that it was her turn to write this weekend, offering to prepare a post about Parry Gripp. Thankful for a weekend off, to celebrate my 15th wedding anniversary, I agreed. She’s even more succinct than I am. Gripp’s known for his songs for children, which are […]
10 Biggest Snubs from the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame

If I were in charge, The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame would have capped membership years ago. There’d be a small and select field of fifty entrants, limiting it to household names like Elvis Presley, James Brown, and The Beatles. But it’s soldiered on, with 351 inductees to date. […]
Led Zeppelin III
Led Zeppelin Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Led Zeppelin were the archetypal hard rock band. They streamlined the sound of 1960s rock bands like Cream and The Who; an important innovation was John Bonham’s crisp, groove-based drumming, which contrasted with the busy style of The Who’s Keith Moon and Cream’s Ginger Baker. Led Zeppelin continuously delved into […]
10 Best Paul Simon Songs

Paul Simon’s songs are part of the American landscape, a thoughtful man documenting his inner dialogue in popular song. From Simon and Garfunkel songs like ‘America’ and ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ to solo songs like ‘American Tune’ and ‘Graceland’, his songs capture both the American zeitgeist and his own personal […]
Pink Floyd Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Formed by London architecture students in 1964, Pink Floyd are one of the most beloved classic rock bands. While most attention is given to stadium-rock blockbusters like Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall, they enjoyed a lengthy career on either side of the 1970s. Pink Floyd started recording in the psychedelic 1960s, […]