Famously, The Monkees started as a band created for a TV show – they were sometimes referred to as the Prefab Four. But as their career progressed, they asserted more influence over their career. On their third album, Headquarters, The Monkees played most of the instruments themselves, becoming almost a self-contained band. The two musicians in the group, Peter Tork and Mike Nesmith, continued to play on Monkees records, but Mickey Dolenz largely gave up the drums.
‘Goin’ Down’ is taken from the sessions from the band’s fourth album, Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn & Jones Ltd.. It was released as the b-side to the #1 single ‘Daydream Believer’. The group took the chord progression from Mose Allison’s ‘Parchman Farm’. They handed their piece to songwriter Diane Hildebrand. and asked her to write lyrics. She wrote about a man, distraught about the end of a relationship had ended, who jumps into the river. Fortunately, there’s a happy ending.
Just movin’ slow and floatin’ free There’s a river swinging under me Waving back to the folks on shore I should have thought of this before I’m floatin’ on down to New Orleans And pick up on some swingin’ scenes
It’s a lot of effort for a non-album single – it’s detour into big band jazz with an impressive Dolenz lead vocal. Wrecking Crew member Bud Brisbois contributed the trumpet solo.
‘Goin’ Down’ was featured on a 2012 episode of Breaking Bad, bringing it to a new audience. It was also added to later editions of Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn & Jones Ltd.
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
37 Comments
I never heard that one before, it’s pretty good.
Yeah, I was impressed by the vocal,
So was I
I don’t even have to listen to it. I know it very well and it’s one of my favorite Monkees songs of all time. I pretty much knew that Mickey wasn’t playing drums. But who cares? His singing is great on this and he’s every bit the singer (if not more) than Davy Jones. What an unusual song for a pop band to do back in the Sixties.
I don’t really mind about who did what in music, as long as the finished product is interesting. But it’s hard not to get into that train of thought with The Monkees. Allowing Tork and Nesmith to play and have more input was a positive, but Dolenz didn’t really need to drum. But it’s cool that the group had the idea for this one – it’s pretty unique.
Yeah, love it. “Tapioca Tundra” is another oddball favorite. “Valleri” is a great tune with a flamenco-like run by some studio guy. Truthfully, a lot of stuff we think is played by a given band is actually played by studio musicians either because the guy in a band can’t play it or the studio musician can do it faster (equals cheaper.)
More of a 1960s thing, right? Jimmy Page turned up on all sorts of records, even by established bands.
Probably correct although I wouldn’t be surprised if it didn’t spill into the Seventies. I think you saw the Page book I’m reading. He was on everything from “Goldfinger” to Joe Cocker to “Hard Day’s Night.” (Orchestral version of “That Boy.”) And I just found out he played the solo on the Stones’ “One Hit to the Body.” He was ubiquitous. And everything he learned there he applied to Zep records. He is a very smart, quite unique figure in rock history.
It feels like some of the 1960s stuff was kind of secretive, jumping in with an existing band to shore them up (something that was maybe less necessary as technology got better and multi-tracking became easier?). While in the 1980s, he’s more like a high-profile guest star.
I heard that Jimmy Page played the great guitar solo on Donovan’s Hurdy Gurdy Man, and even though that is one of my favorite records ever, I never knew that before. I’m always surprised to find out all the different things he played on. Stuff that you never would have guessed in a million years.
Actually, I just looked it up and it said that it’s disputed whether or not Jimmy Page played on that. Donovan swears that it was him, but other people say that it wasn’t. And I have no idea what he says himself.
Wikipedia says “On Jimmy Page’s website, he lists this song as one on which he plays.” Apparently Allan Holdsworth was around too.
Oh, okay. I guess I should have checked there but I just read the first thing that came up on Google. I wonder why there would be such disagreement about who played on the record. That’s weird. It couldn’t be all that hard to remember.
Apparently people are confused about whether the other guitarist on the track (besides Page) was Alan Parker or Allan Holdsworth. John Paul Jones reckons it was Parker.
Those two names are new to me. I never heard them before. Probably the reason I never bothered to see who played guitar on the record is because I probably just presumed they were just musicians who Donovan always played with and I wouldn’t know who they were anyway. Otherwise I might have found out earlier if it was Jimmy Page or not.
Allan Holdsworth was pretty well-known, but played on more jazz/prog stuff – he was a member of the prog band U.K..
I grew up with this one. Dolenz really makes this come alive. When you put them in perspective…many bands didn’t play on their records at the time. I’m glad they grabbed some control though. This one is a super B side.
Dolenz does write my favorite song on this album…Randy Scouse Git
The narrative about them playing on their records fitted the article, but I don’t usually get too hung up on the rockist narrative of bands needing to be self contained. More important that the final product is engaging.
I wish more people thought that way. They did have some great pop songs in the sixties…. Although I always thought Nesmith was the most gifted…Dolenz had the best voice to me.
It’s so elaborate for a Monkees record. He sings it really well too. I wonder why it wasn’t on the album. But actually I like the Monkees better when they didn’t have control over their music. I like the first two albums better than the later ones, cuz somebody used to find more good songs for them to do. I think the later albums have fewer good ones on them, although the good ones are real good.
I only know some records from the middle era; I need to go back and hear the early ones.
That’s where all the biggest and best ones are. Steppin Stone, I’m a Believer, Last Train to Clarksville. All those ones.
I didn’t know this one. Love the Monkees (but I guess not that much since I don’t know this one)
It is a non album bside; so forgiven.
That’s a pretty cool tune I had not known and frankly not expected from the Monkees. This sounds quite different from songs like “Last Train to Clarksville”, “I’m a Believer” or “Pleasant Valley Sunday”. It’s got more of a soul and jazz vibe.
I probably need to go right through their discography sometime – or at least everything involving Nesmith. I’ve always liked them, but my latest dip into their discography has me a bit more enthused.
Headquarters was one of the more pleasant surprises from the 1001 list – I didn’t realize I was a Monkees fan!
I have that one but don’t know it very well – need to spend more time with it.
Not a bad single that, ‘Daydream Believer’ w/ ‘Goin’ Down’. A pretty cool sounding track. The Monkees from ‘Headquarters’ to ‘Head’ is a very interesting period for them as the material are intriguing and cool, with not only them being psychedelic but also their usual songwriters having to be with the times as well.
Thanks for mentioning it – o should have given you a shout out.
Interesting and unusual song for a band like The Monkees to have done, but it works. As others have previously noted, they were more talented than initially given credit for, and Mickey Dolenz was a fine singer.
Never heard it before, but it’s jazzy enough for me. How he sings that without tripping over the words is beyond me.
Yup, it’s pretty impressive – a lot of work for a non-album b-side, I reckon.
Maybe they recorded it thinking it wasn’t a b-side, you know? I mean if you’re in a studio recording, going into something knowing it’s filler sort of kills the vive, I’d say. It should all be singles!
I think there are some b-sides that are purposely silly throwaways, but you’re right that we should all be striving for excellence.
If you’re in the studio to make a record, and you don’t have ten solid songs ready to go, what are you doing in the studio?
Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.
Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.
Review Pages
Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:
The 1970s are beloved by music nerds; artists in a variety of genres cranked out a 40-minute album every year. The late 1960s staked out the territory for many genres; the 1970s was when they were explored fully. Artists like Marvin Gaye and Stevie Wonder broke free from the Motown […]
Kimbra Johnson was earmarked for stardom early. There are videos online of her singing as a pre-teen, while she placed second in New Zealand’s national secondary school rock quest at the age of 14. But after a generic debut single ‘Deep For You’, she took time out and became more […]
There are many examples in popular music of stripping away the superfluity and getting back to basics, but it doesn’t get much more basic than Detroit’s The White Stripes. Dispensing even with a bass player, the purported brother and sister duo delivered direct, blues-inflected rock. Their first album was released […]
The first decade of the 21st century feels like my home territory. I spent my teenage years in the 1990s catching up with the 1960s and 1970s, so the 2000s were the first decade in which I actively engaged with new music. In the 2000s music splintered further into sub-genres […]
Gram Parsons, or as 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die describes him, “Keith Richards’ citrus-heir drug-buddy”, is remembered as a country-rock pioneer. While this description is certainly apt, I was generally a little taken aback by his music at first. It’s not the commercially oriented country offered by […]
Ezra Koenig and drummer Chris Tomson started playing together in a rap collaboration named “L’Homme Run” while attending Columbia University. The pair were interested in punk and African music and named their band after a short film Koenig attempted to make about a vampire invasion of Cape Cod. Koenig and […]
Blog Posts
I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:
Published in 1931–32, with 12 volumes, 7 million words, 9,000 pages and 50,000 articles, the second edition of Everyman’s Encyclopedia was edited by Athelstan Ridgway. We recently inherited our family’s set. I’ve been bemused by their section on jazz, and thought I’d preserve it here for posterity. I’ve broken up […]
The band Television emerged from the same CBGB scene that produced Talking Heads, The Ramones, Blondie, and Patti Smith. The group was started by Tom Verlaine, Richard Hell, and drummer Billy Ficca. Verlaine and Ficca were childhood friends, while Hell met Verlaine at high school in Delaware. Hell was replaced […]
Of the indie guitar bands proffered by Dunedin’s Flying Nun label in the 1980s, Straitjacket Fits were the most likely to break through to a mass audience. The Fits were based around two vocalists and songwriters who were an unlikely combination but who complemented each other beautifully; Shayne Carter had […]
Adult contemporary superstar and Hebrew Hunk Neil Diamond is a fascinating figure to me. His music is an uncomfortable blend of Brill Building pop, gospel, and confessional writing, like he can’t make up his mind whether he wants to be Elvis Presley or James Taylor. As an adolescent, I was […]
Bassist Ashley Hutchings and rhythm guitarist Simon Nicol formed Fairport Convention in 1967. They named the band after Nicol’s father’s medical practice, above which they rehearsed, on the same Muswell street as the Davies brothers of The Kinks grew up. Lead guitarist Richard Thompson and drummer Martin Lamble joined the group, along […]
Bob Dylan needs no introduction – he’s one of the key figures in rock music. He helped to define the genre as it matured, especially as a lyricist. He broadened the scope of rock lyrics, utilising both social issues and surreal poetry. Through the 1960s, Dylan never stood still, initially […]
I never heard that one before, it’s pretty good.
Yeah, I was impressed by the vocal,
So was I
I don’t even have to listen to it. I know it very well and it’s one of my favorite Monkees songs of all time. I pretty much knew that Mickey wasn’t playing drums. But who cares? His singing is great on this and he’s every bit the singer (if not more) than Davy Jones. What an unusual song for a pop band to do back in the Sixties.
I don’t really mind about who did what in music, as long as the finished product is interesting. But it’s hard not to get into that train of thought with The Monkees. Allowing Tork and Nesmith to play and have more input was a positive, but Dolenz didn’t really need to drum. But it’s cool that the group had the idea for this one – it’s pretty unique.
Yeah, love it. “Tapioca Tundra” is another oddball favorite. “Valleri” is a great tune with a flamenco-like run by some studio guy. Truthfully, a lot of stuff we think is played by a given band is actually played by studio musicians either because the guy in a band can’t play it or the studio musician can do it faster (equals cheaper.)
More of a 1960s thing, right? Jimmy Page turned up on all sorts of records, even by established bands.
Probably correct although I wouldn’t be surprised if it didn’t spill into the Seventies. I think you saw the Page book I’m reading. He was on everything from “Goldfinger” to Joe Cocker to “Hard Day’s Night.” (Orchestral version of “That Boy.”) And I just found out he played the solo on the Stones’ “One Hit to the Body.” He was ubiquitous. And everything he learned there he applied to Zep records. He is a very smart, quite unique figure in rock history.
It feels like some of the 1960s stuff was kind of secretive, jumping in with an existing band to shore them up (something that was maybe less necessary as technology got better and multi-tracking became easier?). While in the 1980s, he’s more like a high-profile guest star.
I heard that Jimmy Page played the great guitar solo on Donovan’s Hurdy Gurdy Man, and even though that is one of my favorite records ever, I never knew that before. I’m always surprised to find out all the different things he played on. Stuff that you never would have guessed in a million years.
Actually, I just looked it up and it said that it’s disputed whether or not Jimmy Page played on that. Donovan swears that it was him, but other people say that it wasn’t. And I have no idea what he says himself.
Wikipedia says “On Jimmy Page’s website, he lists this song as one on which he plays.” Apparently Allan Holdsworth was around too.
Oh, okay. I guess I should have checked there but I just read the first thing that came up on Google. I wonder why there would be such disagreement about who played on the record. That’s weird. It couldn’t be all that hard to remember.
Apparently people are confused about whether the other guitarist on the track (besides Page) was Alan Parker or Allan Holdsworth. John Paul Jones reckons it was Parker.
Those two names are new to me. I never heard them before. Probably the reason I never bothered to see who played guitar on the record is because I probably just presumed they were just musicians who Donovan always played with and I wouldn’t know who they were anyway. Otherwise I might have found out earlier if it was Jimmy Page or not.
Allan Holdsworth was pretty well-known, but played on more jazz/prog stuff – he was a member of the prog band U.K..
I grew up with this one. Dolenz really makes this come alive. When you put them in perspective…many bands didn’t play on their records at the time. I’m glad they grabbed some control though. This one is a super B side.
Dolenz does write my favorite song on this album…Randy Scouse Git
The narrative about them playing on their records fitted the article, but I don’t usually get too hung up on the rockist narrative of bands needing to be self contained. More important that the final product is engaging.
I wish more people thought that way. They did have some great pop songs in the sixties…. Although I always thought Nesmith was the most gifted…Dolenz had the best voice to me.
It’s so elaborate for a Monkees record. He sings it really well too. I wonder why it wasn’t on the album. But actually I like the Monkees better when they didn’t have control over their music. I like the first two albums better than the later ones, cuz somebody used to find more good songs for them to do. I think the later albums have fewer good ones on them, although the good ones are real good.
I only know some records from the middle era; I need to go back and hear the early ones.
That’s where all the biggest and best ones are. Steppin Stone, I’m a Believer, Last Train to Clarksville. All those ones.
I didn’t know this one. Love the Monkees (but I guess not that much since I don’t know this one)
It is a non album bside; so forgiven.
That’s a pretty cool tune I had not known and frankly not expected from the Monkees. This sounds quite different from songs like “Last Train to Clarksville”, “I’m a Believer” or “Pleasant Valley Sunday”. It’s got more of a soul and jazz vibe.
I probably need to go right through their discography sometime – or at least everything involving Nesmith. I’ve always liked them, but my latest dip into their discography has me a bit more enthused.
Headquarters was one of the more pleasant surprises from the 1001 list – I didn’t realize I was a Monkees fan!
I have that one but don’t know it very well – need to spend more time with it.
Not a bad single that, ‘Daydream Believer’ w/ ‘Goin’ Down’. A pretty cool sounding track. The Monkees from ‘Headquarters’ to ‘Head’ is a very interesting period for them as the material are intriguing and cool, with not only them being psychedelic but also their usual songwriters having to be with the times as well.
Thanks for mentioning it – o should have given you a shout out.
Interesting and unusual song for a band like The Monkees to have done, but it works. As others have previously noted, they were more talented than initially given credit for, and Mickey Dolenz was a fine singer.
Never heard it before, but it’s jazzy enough for me. How he sings that without tripping over the words is beyond me.
Yup, it’s pretty impressive – a lot of work for a non-album b-side, I reckon.
Maybe they recorded it thinking it wasn’t a b-side, you know? I mean if you’re in a studio recording, going into something knowing it’s filler sort of kills the vive, I’d say. It should all be singles!
I think there are some b-sides that are purposely silly throwaways, but you’re right that we should all be striving for excellence.
If you’re in the studio to make a record, and you don’t have ten solid songs ready to go, what are you doing in the studio?
*Vibe