Mitski: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

Japanese-American indie-rock musician Mitski is one of the most interesting figures currently working in popular music – Iggy Pop famously labelled her as “the most advanced American songwriter that I know”. While guitar rock can sometimes feel stale in the 21st century, Mitski’s fascinating. Her music often feels like the work of an outsider looking in; her father worked for the US state department and she moved frequently as a child. This feeling of disconnection has inspired an ardent fanbase.

Mitski’s work has gone through significant stylistic shifts – her first two records are brief piano-based albums that she recorded as projects while studying music, while she also served as vocalist for the progressive rock band Voice Coils. But she’s best known for her alternative guitar-rock – in this writer’s opinion, ‘Your Best American Girl’, which recalls the Pixies with its quiet-loud dynamics, is the best rock song of the 2010s.

With Mitski’s new album, Laurel Hell, just released, here are her first six records ranked from worst to best.

Mitski Albums Ranked

#6 Lush

It’s a little unfair to include Mitski’s first two albums on this countdown – they’re essentially student projects from her time at Purchase College’s Conservatory of Music. They’re different from her later work, based around piano and orchestration. Lush, her debut, is brief and succinct. There’s a clear debt to Björk on songs like ‘Eric’, while the guitar rocker ‘Brand New City’ is indicative of her future direction.

#5 Retired from Sad, New Career in Business

Mitski’s second record is similar to the piano and orchestration of her debut, but it’s more sophisticated and confident. The loopy orchestration on ‘Goodbye, My Danish Sweetheart’ provide more personality than anything on her debut, while the dramatic strings of ‘Shame’ are also effective. There’s mournful piano on ‘Humpty’ and the upbeat ‘Strawberry Blond’ – plenty of musical ideas, but it’s brief and lightweight compared to her later work.

#4 Puberty 2

Puberty 2 is a little overshadowed by the records released before and after it, but it’s still very good. Mitski steers close to punk on ‘My Body’s Made of Crushed Little Stars’, while ‘I Bet On Losing Dogs’ is pretty. ‘Your Best American Girl’ is her definitive song, packing her alienation thems into a soaring and viciously intelligent rock song.

#3 Laurel Hell

There was an unusually large pause between Mitski’s fifth and sixth albums. When she finally returned with Laurel Hell, Mitski still employed the sophisticated pop textures of Be The Cowboy. But where that album felt intoxicated with the endless possibilities of the studio, Laurel Hell feels unsatisfied. On the lead single ‘Working for the Knife’, Mitski sings “Now at twenty-nine, the road ahead appears the same”. The use of dance beats on tracks like ‘Stay Soft’ and the excellent closer ‘That’s Our Lamp’ are a welcome addition to Mitski’s catalogue.

#2 Bury Me At Makeout Creek

Released only a year after Retired from Sad, New Career in Business, Mitski is a fully-fledged recording artist on Bury Me At Makeout Creek. Named after a quote from The Simpsons, Bury Me At Makeout Creek explores a retro-1990s alt-rock sound. The opener ‘Texas Rezkivnoff’ starts gently before exploding mid-song. There’s an enjoyable balance between cathartic rockers like ‘Townie’ and gentler material like ‘Last Words of a Shooting Star’.

#1 Be The Cowboy

The guitar-heavy attack of Mitski’s previous albums is present on songs like ‘A Pearl’ and ‘Geyser’, but Be The Cowboy is closer to art-rock. It’s her most diverse record yet – ‘Why Didn’t You Stop Me?’ veers close to synth-pop while ‘A Horse Named Cold Air’ is moody and sparse. Be The Cowboy is fast-moving, packing 14 tracks into 33 minutes. And it might just be the best record of its decade.

Are you a Mitski fan? What’s your pick for her best record?

What Is Your Favourite Mitski Album?

Read More


Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.


  1. I only know Be The Cowboy and I like it loads. Without a doubt a great album, but I don’t know about it being the best record of it’s decade!

    • I love it – lots of good records in 2018 (Kacey Musgraves, Julia Holter, and Janelle Monae all had really good ones) but it’s my favourite. Hits that arty yet poppy zone for me.

  2. I do know some of her music off of blogs. Be The Cowboy I’ve heard a few times. I did like it…I should give the rest a try.

  3. 100% in agreement with you Be the Cowboy is the best one yet. I also really like “Happy” and “Your Best American Girl” on Puberty2. She’s put out some really good videos also. Can’t wait to see what’s next with her. First time hearing Iggy’s assessment of her stuff — that’s pretty impressive.

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

Buzzcocks Singles Going Steady
Punk and New Wave Miscellany

These punk and new wave artists are covered briefly below:The B-52’s | Buzzcocks The B-52’s Time Capsule: Songs for a Future Generation 1998, 7/10Despite ubiquitous songs like ‘Love Shack’ and ‘Roam’, The B-52’s are an acquired taste. I blame it on Aqua; the Swedish pop band had their five minutes […]
Home, Land and Sea Trinity Roots
Trinity Roots Album Reviews

Prominent popular music from New Zealand in the late 20th century was often Caucasian in origin, with the most internationally recognised musicians coming either from the Flying Nun stable of twisted guitar pop or the mainstream pop of the Finn Brothers. The early 21st century saw a proliferation of reggae-influenced […]
Fairport Convention Liege and Lief
Fairport Convention Album Reviews

Fairport Convention are the focal point for British folk-rock of their generation. While they started their career as a sixties folk-rock band, like a London equivalent to Jefferson Airplane, they started wading through the archives of British folk songs and electrifying them. With an impressive pool of talent, Fairport Convention […]
Emmylou Harris Album Reviews

Emmylou Harris started as a folkie – born in Alabama, she dropped out of college to perform folk songs in Greenwich Village. She recorded an unsuccessful debut album, 1969’s Gliding Bird, and as a divorced solo mother she dropped out of the folk scene. She was spotted performing by Chris […]
Straitjacket Fits Album Reviews

While it has a comparatively minuscule population base to draw from and is located in the deep south of New Zealand, Dunedin’s Flying Nun record label produced a string of critically acclaimed and influential guitar bands throughout the 1980s including The Chills, The Clean, The Bats, and The Gordons. Straitjacket […]
Stereo Paul Westerberg Review
Paul Westerberg

His work in the 1980s with the beloved Replacements left leader Paul Westerberg with colossal expectations to meet with his solo career. Despite some valiant attempts, Westerberg’s never managed to meet the artistic levels of The Replacements trio of Let It Be, Tim, and Pleased To Meet Me. But his […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme - Simon and Garfunkel
A Listening Biography in 10 Albums

I recently participated in an album draft, run by Hans from Like everyone else I picked 10 albums, but I used mine to also tell a story about music fandom. Here are ten albums that broadened my horizons about popular music. Parsley, Sage, Rosemary & Thyme – Simon & […]
The Smiths 1984 Debut
The Smiths: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

The two figures at the centre of 1980s English indie-rock band The Smiths were an unlikely pairing. Vocalist Morrissey was socially awkward, literate, and camp, while guitarist Johnny Marr was an aspiring football player who trialled with Manchester City. Bonding over a shared interest in The New York Dolls, they […]
10 Best Big Star Songs

Alex Chilton was already a star when he joined forces with the Icewater. Icewater’s members – singer/guitarist Chris Bell, bassist Andy Hummel, and drummer Jody Stephens – had been playing in Memphis garage-rock bands. Despite the city’s heritage of blues and soul, and Chilton’s history as lead singer of The […]
Steely Dan Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Steely Dan were major album artists of the 1970s, releasing a string of quality records that blurred the lines between rock and jazz. They started the decade as a self-contained rock band and ended as the duo of Donald Fagen and Walter Becker, supported by a revolving cast of session […]
Sault Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

British soul collective Sault have broken almost every rule of album-making during their brief career. Debuting in 2019, they’ve already released 11 studio albums; yet they’ve never played live or given an interview. Their already sizeable catalogue has taken in everything from smooth R&B to raw post-punk, gospel-tinged soul to […]
Wilco Kicking Television
Album Battle – Wilco vs Radiohead

A game I like to play on my cycle commute from work is figuring out the best band of each ten year era. For instance, The Beatles and Bob Dylan are contenders for 1960-1970, while 1985-1995 has a few contestants, including Pixies, Sonic Youth, and Public Enemy. I’ve been covering […]
%d bloggers like this: