One glance at Mark Knopfler’s bandana will tell you that Dire Straits have never been a fashionable band. Emerging in 1978, at the height of punk, their literate bar-band rock appealed to conservative listeners not enamoured by the upstart sounds of The Sex Pistols and The Clash.
Despite their lack of critical cachet, Dire Straits are accomplished album artists – almost all of their albums have their own identity, from the stripped down four-piece sound of their debut to the hi fi blockbuster Brothers in Arms. I’ve only ranked their studio albums, but fans often vouch for the 1984 live album Alchemy.
Mark Knopfler grew up in Newcastle, and formed Dire Straits in London in 1977. The original lineup also featured Pick Withers on drums, Mark’s brother David on rhythm guitar, and John Illsley on bass, the band’s only other constant member. The lineup grew over time, and the addition of keyboards from 1980’s Making Movies helped to flesh out Knopfler’s slow-paced songs. Knopfler was always the focal point, with his distinctive finger-picked lead guitar and his songs tinged with folk, blues and country.
After Knopfler wound down Dire Straits in 1995, he’s continued making music but he’s often gravitated to low key work like instrumental soundtracks. It seems evident that Knopfler loves making music, but didn’t appreciate the pressure of fronting one of the world’s most popular bands.
Dire Straits Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best
#6 – On Every Street
1991
In 1985 Dire Straits were huge, but by 1991, reformed after a hiatus, they were far less relevant. On Every Street is more like a Knopfler solo album, and suffers from 1990s CD bloat. Nonetheless it’s a respectable swansong – the riff of ‘Heavy Fuel’ recalls ‘Money for Nothing’ and the title track is pretty.
#5 – Communique
1979
Shortly after their debut was released, Dire Straits were back in the studio recording a follow-up. The songs are largely fine, but it’s so close in tone to its predecessor that it feels like a facsimile; I enjoy ‘Lady Writer’, but it’s very reminiscent of ‘Sultans of Swing’. The bluesy ‘Where Do You Think You’re Going’ and the folkish ‘Portobello Belle’ do break some new ground for the group.
#4 – Dire Straits
1978
It’s a little churlish placing the group’s successful debut in the bottom half of the list, but the four-piece sound is limiting despite Mark Knopfler’s prowess as a writer and guitarist. The lack of diversity dulls the impact of well-written songs like ‘Six Blade Knife’ and ‘Southbound Again’. The breakthrough hit ‘Sultans of Swing’ still sounds great, despite the efforts of buskers and amateur bands, with its smooth riff and solos.
#3 – Brothers in Arms
Dire Straits’ fifth album was an unexpected blockbuster in the early CD era. It’s their first album without drummer Pick Withers, and they sound more like a studio project than a band. There are terrific tracks like the riff rocker ‘Money for Nothing’ and the elegiac title track with Knopfler’s emotive guitar soloing. There’s also a rough stretch on the first side with the played out ‘Walk of Life’ and the cheesy lounge of ‘Your Latest Trick’.
#2 – Making Movies
1980
Knopfler kicked his brother, rhythm guitarist David Knopfler, out of the band during the recording of their third album. Guest keyboardist, Roy Bittan of the E-Street Band, fills out their sound with his piano. As the title suggests, the record is full of cinematic songs that recall Springsteen’s romantic 1970s epics. Lengthy workouts like ‘Tunnel of Love’ and ‘Romeo and Juliet’ are among the band’s most beloved tracks. Points are deducted for the closer ‘Les Boys’, a misguided homophobic shuffle.
#1 – Love Over Gold
1982
Dire Straits peaked with their fourth album, consisting of five lengthy songs. The key track is ‘Telegraph Road’, a fourteen minute historical epic with plenty of space for Knopfler’s guitar soloing, but there are treasures everywhere. The film noir atmosphere of ‘Private Investigations’, with its spasms of guitar noise, and the dark humour of ‘Industrial Disease’ are also excellent. My favourite Dire Straits song, though, is the pretty title track.
Do you have a favourite Dire Straits album? Or song?
Read More
- Dire Straits album reviews
- Worst to Best lists
I would rate the debut higher. Communique was a little disappointing. My favorite song of theirs- “Romeo And Juliet” in my Top 100 songs ever list.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I looked at Rate Your Music communal ratings, and their only difference was that Dire Straits was two places higher (and my #2 and #3 slid down a spot).
LikeLiked by 2 people
I think you nicely captured it, Graham. Ranking albums is tough, in my opinion, and always subjective at the end of the day. If I had to do it, my order for numbers 1, 2 and 3 would be “Dire Straits”, “Making Movies” and “Brothers in Arms.”
On “On Every Street,” which I generally agree is Dire Straits’ worst album, relatively speaking, the tune I dig the most is a track I initially felt lukewarm about: “Calling Elvis.” I just think it’s got a cool sound, and working in the titles of various famous Elvis songs in the lyrics is a fun idea.
Another artist who is on my mind due to his upcoming 80th birthday tomorrow did the same thing for the title track of his 2015 studio album “Postcards From Paradise,” except he used titles of Beatles songs: Ringo Starr. He even co-wrote tune, together with Todd Rundgren.
LikeLiked by 2 people
We had a Beatles pastiche song named “Saint Paul” make it big in New Zealand – it helped spark the Paul is dead rumour.
I often don’t like debut albums as much as everyone else – I often prefer bands when they expand in the studio a bit.
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I first heard the song, “Sultans of Swing,” it blew my mind. However, I was very disappointed when I saw them live in 1985 that they didn’t play “Skateaway” nor “Industrial Disease.”
LikeLiked by 2 people
Both of those songs are really good without cracking my ten favourites from Dire Straits. But from my two favourite albums.
LikeLiked by 1 person
For the casual listeners like me, Brothers In Arms is “The album” catapulted by the huge single Money For Nothing. A very good band contemporary to post punk and new wave but with a different style. It could be my second favorite period in rock music history (1978 – 1984) only surpassed by the classic years 1966 – 1972.
LikeLiked by 2 people
1978-1984 was kind of a rebirth, right? I wonder if we’ll ever get another period of guitar music like that,
LikeLike
Making Movies would be my 1 with the debut second…followed by Love over Gold and then Brothers in Arms. The only album I didn’t have was On Every Street…it sounds as if I don’t want it.
1990s CD bloat…great term.
This list is good though. Sometimes with them, it depends on the mood.
LikeLiked by 2 people
On Every Street isn’t that bad – just a bit long, and after their peak, but it could have been a lot worse. I think most 1990s albums are too long.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Brothers in Arms is really the only album I know in any detail. Tons of songs overall I like, but never album dived. Someday that will change. Great list!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cool! They’re a pretty good album band, I reckon – good album tracks as well as singles.
LikeLiked by 1 person
#4 & #3 are on the 1001 list – encouraging that there are a couple more that might be even stronger.
And I’ll never forget the fill-in-the-blanks Sultans of Swing lyric quiz that you hosted, a song I thought I knew reasonably well. To my credit, I earned double digits. Though it was a paltry 11/70!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like their middle period best, but that’s quite common for me. I hear Sultans of Swing all the time from buskers.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I liked your phrasing of despite their best efforts!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The first album remains the classic for me. In 1977 I had heard about the band from a friend who was living in North London and had seen them at the Hope and Anchor. The next year I was in London with my own band, dreaming of success. The Dire Straits album came out and our bass player and I bought it, took it back to our hovel in Streatham and put it on. By the end of side one we were both depressed. How could we ever hope to make it when there was a band like this – and particularly a guitarist like Mark Knopfler – showing what musicians should really be able to do?
Listening to it now, I agree that the instrumentation is a little restrictive and there was no real attempt to influence the sound through production, but at the most basic level – here’s two guitars, a bass and a drum kit, now show me something – it’s incredible.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Did your band ever record anything? Sounds like Knopfler kicked around for a while before he was able to record anything.
LikeLike
I wouldn’t argue with your list. I’d have the debut at one, but those first four are all great, so it depends on the day for me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sounds like everyone loves the debut!
LikeLike
On all of their albums there are such great songs that you wish the whole album could be that good. On each of their albums there are at least two super-great ones and sometimes three. I would probably say that Making Movies has the highest percentage of good stuff on it. Also, I rather like Walk of Life. And Les Boys, even though I’m gay. You’re right it’s a dumb song, but it’s a good record at the same time. I don’t let dumb lyrics get in my way of rnjoying something that’s good.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I had the Money for Nothing 1988 compilation for ages before I heard the individual albums. It did a pretty good job of highlighting the best stuff from the first five albums, including live versions of Portobello Belle and Telegraph Road.
LikeLike
I think we’ve been down this road before . Those first few albums all sound real good to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Unlike most people I know I’m actually a huge fan of compilations. I don’t know why people look down on them as being inferior to albums. I started collecting them like crazy years ago and anytime I see one at a decent price I buy it. It’s become like a special interest of mine. I compare them and rate them the same way that people rate regular albums. It’s just as hard to make a good compilation as it is to make a original album. And there are some artists who you can only get the full effect of their music by listening to a compilation. Money for Nothing is actually a pretty good comp. Their later best -ofs had too much on them, which is usually what happens over time. They get diluted by including too many weak tracks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Money for Nothing is good – looks like someone just tried to choose their twelve best songs. It’s cool how there are a couple of live versions (Portobello Belle, Telegraph Road) on it.
LikeLike
Yeah, but it could have been a 5 star compilation if it included Lady Writer, So Far Away, Industrial Disease, Solid Rock and Skateaway. All of which were actual singles. Even the later compilations Sultans of Swing and Private Investigations didn’t get it right when they had a chance to. You’d think it would be the easiest thing in the world to make a great compilation. But for some reason it just isn’t.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think it does a pretty good job of hitting most of the highlights – it maybe could have squeezed a couple of extra songs on. I have heard ‘Lady Writer’, ‘So Far Away’, and ‘Industrial Disease’ on the radio, unlike some of the songs here, though.
LikeLike
They’re definitely an ‘albums band’ but weirdly I’ve always just really liked a few tracks per album, not liked any of them all the way through. But, song for song, I’d go for Brothers In Arms as my favourite album and ‘Private Investigations’ my favourite track.
LikeLiked by 1 person
For me, if you take away Walk of Life and Your Latest Trick, Brothers in Arms is a whole lot better.
LikeLike
I’m with you on ‘Walk Of Life’ but not ‘Your Latest Trick’ – that’s a classic song. I don’t care if I never hear ‘Money For Nothing’ again though…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I could do without the homophobic verse.
LikeLike
Interesting. I thought it was just a kind of ‘neo-noir’ with the usual femme fatale kind of stuff.
LikeLike
I fully applaud your efforts here. I have no issues with the ordering you choose, or your reasonings. For me, they are all interchangeable. I love them all unconditionally. Yes, I am biased and blind, I know, but when Mark Knopfler picks up a guitar I’d follow him anywhere. Well done!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Do you like any of his solo stuff? I haven’t really heard anything, except watching movies he’s done.
LikeLike
Oh yes. I have several here: golden heart, kill to get crimson, local hero, music by mark knopfler from the film cal, privateering 2cd, sailing to philadelphia, tracker, neck and neck (with chet atkins), all the roadrunning (with emmylou harris). I even have a David Knopfler album here (ship of dreams). Yeah, I’m a bit of a fan. Enjoy!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve always been a sucker for Brothers In Arms but I cannot argue with Love Over Gold at #1.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Brothers in Arms drags a bit for me – Love Over Gold interests me the whole way through.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I won’t argue the order/ranking – it’s all subjective I suppose. For me, the album “Making Movies” is track for track, their best. I do however like all of their albums and happen to think they have some great, great songs in their catalogue. I am apparently in the minority with re: to “Communiqué” as I have become more fond of it over the years. Some personal favorite songs include, “Romeo and Juliet” , “Ride Across the River”, “News” , “Wild West End”. Least favorite, “Money for Nothing”. Overall, great band, happy to still have them on vinyl.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I think it would be a very tough call deciding on my favourite from Making Movies and Love Over Gold, but ‘Les Boys’ makes the decision for me.
LikeLike
I deleted Les Boys from my music library, so long ago that I’d forgotten it existed. And it never should have existed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Deleting it is a good idea – I don’t really see any redeeming qualities in it.
LikeLike
I would put the excellent debut album higher. Making Movies is let down by the old “side two”, for me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, ‘Les Boys’ is truly dreadful, isn’t it?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Mark Knopfler is in danger of being “cancelled” maybe. Although I think all the retrospective cancellations for things that happened years ago are unfair.
LikeLike