Skip to content

Wilson & Alroy’s Record Reviews Reviewed

When I first gained access to the internet, the first information I sought out was record reviews. Before that, I’d been working blind, buying albums based on radio hits. While I rarely look at it now, the All Music Guide was a useful resource, but in the long run I got much more use out of Wilson and Alroy’s Record Reviews.

Rage Against The Machine 1992 DebutThe site’s nearly as old as the modern internet, founded in 1995, by David Wilson and John Alroy; while Alroy has been dormant for years, Wilson has kept the site active to this day. The pair complement each other well – both are classic rock fans, but Alroy delved more into 1980s college rock, while Wilson explores jazz, Latin, hip hop, metal, and R&B. I always gravitated closer to Alroy’s tastes, but Wilson covers ground that most other amateur review websites never touch.

The pair’s succinct, no-nonsense reviews certainly rubbed some readers the wrong way – their rating system is less generous than most other review sites (even four out of five stars is used sparingly), and it’s probably frustrating to see a favourite album dismissed with a single paragraph.

Rage Against The Machine (1992)
The debut of the phenomenally popular hardcore/nü-metal band. Vocalist Zack de la Rocha sounds like he really wanted to be Chuck D, but he’s not black, so he has to settle for yelling his political lyrics over snarling speed metal backing (“Killing In The Name”). He ends up with a bewildering mix of hip hop clichés, repetitive gun/bullet metaphors, and occasionally clever indictments of modern capitalist society and our compliance with our own brainwashing (“Silence can be violent/Sorta like a slit wrist”). Since he’s so angry about so many things, he rarely stays focused, shifting from topic to topic within each song, but there are a few exceptions: “Take The Power Back” about Eurocentric curriculums, “Bullet In The Head” about the Gulf War, “Wake Up” about assassinations of political leaders. But his delivery is mindnumbing. The musical backing is facile and loud, with servicable though derivative riffs; the best effort is “Take The Power Back,” where they turn down the distortion, add funky bass, and end up sounding like Living Colour with a hangover. Otherwise, the production, arrangement and instrumentation is nearly identical on every track. The band put out a few big-sellers over the next few years, broke up, and recently reformed. (DBW)

The Replacements Let It BeBecause they did most of the work on their site in the era before streaming and scoured most of their albums from second hand bins, it’s sometimes frustrating to encounter significant discography gaps, like a Replacements page which skips over Let It Be and a Robyn Hitchcock page without three of his key albums (Underwater Moonlight, I Often Dream of Trains, and Fegmania!).

While Alroy’s knowledgeable on guitar rock from the 1960s through to the 1980s, he’s only really enthused about Radiohead and The Posies from the 1990s onward. On the other hand, Wilson’s stayed abreast with modern music well enough to write Janelle Monáe a deservedly positive page.

But generally I’m enough on Wilson and Alroy’s wavelength not to mind all these minor quibbles – they’re a great resource for music recommendations, and I exhausted most of the pop and rock recommendations from their favourites list a long time ago: http://www.warr.org/5stars.html. I discovered lots of favourites, like XTC, Joni Mitchell, Fairport Convention and Richard Thompson, and The Zombies’ Odessey and Oracle from their site.

Have you come across this site before? Are you a fan?

12 thoughts on “Wilson & Alroy’s Record Reviews Reviewed Leave a comment

  1. I have never heard of it but I’m checking it out seems entertaining and informative. It also definitely looks like 1990s Internet form 😀 – no frills just info

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hmmm. Interesting site. i’ll spend some time exploring it. The larger question, of course, is when exactly do they dismiss a favorite album of mine in a paragraph? I hate that. That’s why I stopped – or never even really started reading – Christgau. A tremendous self-important jerk. Of course others may say the same of me. But they are peasants! 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Obviously CB is still living in his cave. The review on Rage is a good example on how opposite my opinion is with this reviewer. Maybe I should check out a few more takes to get a better idea. (Had a quick glance at their faves. We have some common ground on albums I dig)

    I had a few reviewers I trusted back when but for the most part my ear did the choosing or people I knew gave me a nudge to some good stuff.. The folks on this thing (blogs) we do have steered me onto some really good music. Like Jim S saying about the reviewer he noted (in his unique way), I really don’t have time for that kind of review. Doesn’t interest me. Over the years I have leaned more and more to the positive takes and why the music moved the individual. I remember some guy (ant at the picnic as Mamet said) give a review on TV on ‘Nebraska’. It didn’t bother me that he trashed (he did break the album) the record, his opinion wasn’t going to change my mind it was that he thought he was funny, insightful and hip. CB didn’t think so. I little rant.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I don’t really like RATM that much either – they’re a great burst of adrenaline for a song or two, but a whole album is tough going for me.

      I mostly review things I like, but I will probably hit some things like big name acts I’m pretty lukewarm about, or local acts that I’m bombarded with but don’t really appreciate.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Now that tittle review you just gave on Rage is not as heavy handed and I get it. Totally. They are a bit of energy drain as far as listening but like most artists I like when I choose to listen to them I’m in for the ride (usually an albums worth. Just listened to Renegades the other day).
        I like your takes, why I drop by. There is so much good music out there that giving time to the stuff you’re talking about takes listening time and enjoyment away from CB’s ears.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Yes and yes. This site, more than any other, influenced my outlook on popular music and my approach to writing about it. The no-bullshit aesthetic and the focus on music over lyrics were a breath of fresh air after years of reading hoary magazine reviews.

    This is where I discovered so much of the music I enjoy. I think I have cited them in each episode I’ve done of the Discord & Rhyme podcast, because invariably their site is where I learned about the artist being discussed. In fact, tonight we are recording an episode about Funkadelic; and where else would I have learned about Funkadelic?

    I met up with David (Wilson) a few times during visits to New York in the early 2000s; and when I moved there in 2006, we hung out every few months and went to concerts together. I even inherited a big chunk of his CD collection when he gave it away a few years ago.

    I wish they were still doing what they did so well.

    Another excellent choice, Graham.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yeah, I have a few more planned for sometime – Creative Noise and Disclaimer Music Review Archives are on the list.

      I’m pretty sure I learnt about Parliament from them. It would have been great if Alroy had written for a few more years – I’m pretty sure he would have found a few more things from the 1990s and 2000s to enjoy, and it would have been interesting to see what they were.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Rockinsamantha's Blog

Just another WordPress.com site

ReviewHub

Quality Music, Movie and TV reviews

Up Musically

Candid Discussion On Music and The Like

The Music According to Merry

Website & blog of rock music journalist, fiction writer, and ambitious trainwreck Merry Mercurial

ASSHOLES WATCHING MOVIES

Our opinions don't stink!

CirdecSongs

Music for Eclectic Ears

Loud Alien Noize

Revealing the True Origins of Silence

The Lonely Minotaur

Music & Concert Reviews

PowerPop... An Eclectic Collection of Pop Culture

An Eclectic Collection of Pop Culture

Soundtrack To My Year

Fandom Scrapbook

%d bloggers like this: