Skip to content

Taylor Swift’s Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Taylor Swift is a mega-star, and her profile as a celebrity and as a marketing genius can overshadow her musical abilities. Opinions on Swift are wildly diverse – she’s sometimes dismissed as disposable music for teenage girls, and sometimes highly regarded and respected.

Swift is an adept songwriter, particularly as a lyricist, utilising her storytelling abilities to pepper her songs with interesting details and memorable phrases.  She’s equally capable with upbeat, poppy material and slower, more brooding tracks. At the same time, her songs are straightforward musically, and she operates in the mainstream contexts of pop and country-pop. It’s an interesting exercise to try to find comparisons for her in pop music’s past – Swift is equal parts a carefully manicured image-maker like Madonna and an uncluttered and robust songwriter like Carole King or Tom Petty.

Starting her career young, Swift has already built a very respectable back catalogue where each of her seven albums to date has a different flavour. She has beloved deep cuts – lots of her dedicated fans gravitate to lengthy, soul-baring tracks like ‘All Too Well’ and ‘Dear John’. Swift’s songs are robust enough to stand up to acoustic solo performances – respected alt-country star Ryan Adams covered 1989 in its entirety.

Taylor Swift’s Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

#8 – Taylor Swift

Taylor Swift Albums
Taylor Swift

Credit: Big Machine

2006
Taylor Swift was 16 years old when she recorded her debut album, launching her career. I don’t enjoy the smooth country sound, but there’s already a very talented writer here. The best number is ‘Our Song’ – she wrote it in twenty minutes for her school talent show. It benefits from the twangy arrangement and the southern affectation in Swift’s vocals (she’s actually from Pennsylvania)


#7- Reputation

2017
After a tough time with the media, Swift’s tucked away in her bunker for Reputation, firing shots at the world with songs like ‘This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things’ and ‘Look What You Made Me Do’. Swift is putting as much effort into self-expression as into crafting good songs and Reputation ends up as a disorienting mix of pop songs and darker, more personal material. I listen to Reputation more than her early country albums, but it’s a little disappointing after two near-perfect pop albums.


#6 – Speak Now

2010
2010’s Speak Now is notable as the album that Swift wrote alone, without any collaborators; it’s a fan favourite on account of personal songs like ‘Dear John’ and ‘Back to December’. There’s a lot of good material, but it’s in need of an editor, as fourteen songs stretch out to nearly 70 minutes. Like always, there are great songs like the punchy ‘Mine’ and the pretty balladry of ‘Enchanted’.


#5 – Fearless

2008
Fearless is my favourite record from Swift’s early country-pop phase. Stylistically it’s wider reaching than her debut, from upbeat material like the Olympic anthem ‘Change’ and the joyous ‘Love Story’, to gentle acoustic ruminations like ‘Fifteen’ and ‘Best Day’. My favourite is the tuneful melodrama of ‘Breathe’, a string laden ballad with Swift bidding farewell to a band-mate. If your back-catalogue is strong enough to push Fearless into the bottom half, you’re a very good recording artist.


#4 – Lover

2019
Swift bounced back from Reputation with the joyful and mature Lover. Swift describes it as a “love letter to love”, and it’s largely synth-pop with Jack Antonoff in the producer’s chair. The title track is a great torch song, while ‘Soon You’ll Get Better’ is a poignant return to country. Forget the florid single ‘Me!’ – Lover is all about deep cuts like ‘False God’ and ‘Cruel Summer’.


#3 – Folklore

2020
Swift created Folklore during the COVID-19 pandemic, surprise releasing it in July 2020. Collaborating with The National’s Aaron Dessner, Swift employs a low-key, acoustic sound – an “indie record that’s much cooler than mine”, if you will. It’s maybe a little uniform and overlong, but Swift’s vocal melodies have never been prettier on songs like ‘August’ and ‘Invisible String’.


#2 – Red

2012
Before Red dropped, I was only aware of Swift as the teenage starlet who was interrupted by Kanye West at the VMAs. After Red she was inescapable, with hits like ‘We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together’ and ’22’. Red featured a strong and wide ranging set of tracks to back up the hits – from the gentle country of ‘Begin Again’ and the epic balladry of ‘All Too Well’, to the reverb-laden, driving ‘State of Grace’ and the countrified stadium rock of the title track. The two duets are a mild blemish on an otherwise terrific record.


#1 – 1989

2014
Red was a pop album, but featured enough guitars to provide continuity from Swift’s country records. 1989 takes its inspiration from the pop sounds of the year of Swift’s birth, all glossy synths and drum machines. It’s a great set of pop songs with most of the tracks sounding like potential radio hits – even bonus tracks like ‘New Romantics’ are indispensable.

Are you a fan of Swift’s work? Do you have a favourite song or album?

Read More
Taylor Swift album reviews
More Worst to Best lists

30 thoughts on “Taylor Swift’s Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best Leave a comment

  1. I have both Red and 1989 and I’m of the opinion that 1989 is an exceptional album. Even though I’m not drawn at all to any of the other stuff, it’s clear she’s a fine songwriter. I honestly reckon she’s gonna hit the world with a great country album at some point – a Dolly or Loretta Lynn type.

    Liked by 2 people

      • I’m a sucker for some of the old stuff. Not all of it, right enough – some of it really does sound a bit slick, but Dolly has some great stuff, as does Loretta Lynn. Of course, mostly I dig Merle, George, and the outlaws (Willie, Cash, Kris, and Waylon). But yeah, some early country is exceptional before it became a Nashville pop machine.

        Liked by 1 person

        • Gram and Emmylou are great – no doubt about it. There so much great stuff there, but there’s a lot of the older stuff that gets overlooked (I know cause I used to discard it) – Patsy Cline, Dolly and Kenny Rogers have a lot of great songs.

          Liked by 1 person

        • I guess the 70’s shaped them. Kenny’s best stuff is from the late 60’s (The First Edition stuff is somewhat more adventurous than his solo stuff – though his The Gambler is a good one). Patsy was a fair bit before that, yeah.

          Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve never been much of a fan wondering how much of her popularity was (in part) based on her Barbie-doll looks. (But I suppose all entertainers trade on that.) But I’m always bugged when someone comes to my site with a closed mind. So I decided to give these a listen. And I must say while I’m not much of a country fan, I somewhat like the country stuff you’ve laid out here. I’m less enamored of the pop stuff. Too candy for me. That said, I know about the Ryan Adams cover and one night I’ll give ‘1989’ a spin.

    Liked by 3 people

    • You do need a decent share of attractiveness to play the pop game – probably been that way ever since MTV. I was thinking about this recently as I’ve been working on a 2010s page – all the pop oriented acts I’ve covered – Swift, Carly Rae Jepsen, Charli XCX, HAIM – are very attractive women. none of them are industry puppet type figures (not that there’s necessarily anything wrong with that if the end product is good) – just makes you think about less attractive people who can’t play the pop game. I guess it’s less important in other genres so that’s where they end up.

      Like

        • I don’t know how things are down there in ‘Lord of the Rings’ land, but here in the States, some artists are loathe to take any sort of political position for fear of (literally) alienating half their audience. So, good for her for finally taking a stand.

          Liked by 1 person

        • Maybe, maybe not. A lot of people don’t like Springsteen’s politics (leans left, doesn’t like Trump) but they go to his shows anyway. They love his music but hate when he talks politics. Which, in a four-hour show, he does sparingly.

          Liked by 1 person

        • I don’t know about the UK, but in New Zealand left and right are way less demarcated – both of the major parties are reasonably centrist, and we had a whole fascinating mess in the 1980s when the right wing prime minister almost bankrupted the country by overspending, then the left wing party instituted a bunch of extreme right wing financial policies that the country is still recovering from.

          Like

        • We are more polarized = both people and party – than we have been since the ’60’s. It’s due largely to one man who likes it that way and promulgates it.

          Liked by 1 person

        • There’s definitely seeds of discontent to exploit – globalisation and fast change has definitely created discontent. But it’s doesn’t feel like Trump’s going to solve anything for those people.3.

          Liked by 1 person

  3. I am a huge Swiftie and I always like to see unbiased people supporting Taylor and noticing that she really is talented! I see far too many people thinking she makes mindless music for young girls when she’s actually a fantastic lyricist and can tell an entire story in just a few lines.
    In regards to your ranking of her albums, I personally would swap around Fearless and Speak Now but other than that I totally agree! I was also a little disappointed with reputation, especially since it followed such epic albums like Red and 1989. I’m intrigued to see what her 7th album will be like, and perhaps you will update your ranking when it is released?

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Came here to check it out. I really think Folklore will rise in stature. It doesn’t have the pop sensibilities of 1989 but man is it great. I give her credit as it is a huge leap in production for the biggest pop star in the world to make. Her storytelling is always great as is her vocal delivery. I have seen people shitting on her as a “Lana del Ray-lite” on this record. Think that is unfair.

    Like it or not when you are the biggest pop star on the planet it is harder to spit out a record like this. She did it and I respect her for it.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I think it probably already stands as her most critically acclaimed record, and probably the most likely to change people’s opinions on her. I could see it eclipsing Red to become my second favourite, but I don’t know if it’s going to overtake 1989 as my favourite anytime soon.

      I do think it sounds like Lana Del Rey, but Del Rey’s never managed to hold my attention for an album as well as Folklore does.

      It will be interesting to see where she goes next. Hopefully the days of having to do a big crass single (IMO) like ‘Me!’ are behind her, like she can do another mature album next time but something a bit different to Folklore.

      Like

Leave a Reply to steveforthedeafCancel Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: