Wilco The Album

Wilco: Five Best Albums

When Uncle Tupelo split up after 1993’s Anodyne, guitarist and primary song-writer Jay Farrar seemed the best bet for a successful career with his new act Son Volt. But Jeff Tweedy formed Wilco with the remnants of Uncle Tupelo – bassist John Stirratt, drummer Ken Coomer, and multi-instrumentalist Max Johnston. After the unremarkable debut A.M., they gained guitarist and studio wizard Jay Bennett, who was the perfect foil for Tweedy, and who helped shape their second album Being There into a masterpiece. From there they went from strength to strength, even after the acrimonious departure of Bennett after the sessions for 2002’s Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.

The band have continued as a going concern, even with Tweedy and Stirratt as the only original members. Even though I’m less excited about their recent studio output, they’ve remained a popular live attraction, with stellar musicians like guitarist Nels Cline and drummer Glenn Kotche.

Tweedy’s plaintive voice and plaintive songs pull at the heart strings, while Wilco explore influences from country and rock, augmenting their rootsy sound with guitar wizardry and electronic experimentation. Here are five and a half of my favourite Wilco studio albums:


Wilco Summerteeth#6, 1999
I’m adding a bonus entry to this list, since my #3 entry is only 50% a Wilco record. I regard Summerteeth as is one of Wilco’s lesser albums from the Jay Bennett era – I don’t think the pristine studio pop style suits Jeff Tweedy’s voice as much as their more rootsy records. Even so, there’s plenty of strong material, particularly the opening one-two punch of the uptempo ‘I Can’t Stand It’ and the gorgeous ‘She’s A Jar’.

The Whole Love

Wilco The Whole Love#5, 2011
The years from 1996’s Being There to 2004’s A Ghost is Born were the band’s peak as recording artists, even though they’ve remained an excellent live act. But of their post Ghost is Born albums, The Whole Love is my pick as their best, book-ended by two ambitious tracks – the closing ‘One Sunday Morning (Song for Jane Smiley’s Boyfriend)’ is twelve minutes of gentle acoustic exploration. In between there are plenty of gorgeous songs, and space for plenty of frenzied Nels Cline solos.

A Ghost Is Born

Wilco A Ghost Is Born#4, 2004
The followup to the acclaimed Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, A Ghost Is Born is in need of an editor, particularly the fifteen minute ‘Less Than You Think’, most of which is dedicated to a musical recreation of the severe migraines that Jeff Tweedy was suffering from at the time. But while it feels sprawling and indulgent in places, there are plenty of terrific tracks, like the ten minute guitar jamming of ‘Spiders (Kidsmoke)’, off-kilter but melodic material like ‘Company In My Back’ and ‘Hell Is Chrome’, and effortless pop like ‘The Late Greats’.

Mermaid Avenue (with Billy Bragg)

Mermaid Avenue Wilco and Billy Bragg#3, 1998
Folk legend Woody Guthrie wrote a wealth of unrecorded material during the last twenty years of his life, and his daughter Nora arranged for Billy Bragg to set Guthrie’s lyrics to music. Bragg recruited Wilco as his backing band, and lead vocals are shared between Bragg and Jeff Tweedy. The results are often magical, with the record capturing diverse moods from the whimsy of ‘Walt Whitman’s Niece’ to the sombre ‘Another Man’s Done Gone’. Natalie Merchant guests on the beautiful ‘Birds and Ships’, and provides backing vocals on the lovely ‘Way Over Yonder in the Minor Key’.

My absolute favourite Wilco song comes from the less enthralling, but still worthwhile, Mermaid Avenue II, released in 2000 – ‘Remember the Mountain Bed’.

Yankee Hotel Foxtrot

Wilco Yankee Hotel Foxtrot#2, 2002
Wilco’s most acclaimed album had the most troubled genesis – musical lynch-pin Jay Bennett was forced out of the band after the album’s completion, clashing with Tweedy and producer Jim O’Rourke. Yankee Hotel Foxtrot was also bogged down in record company politics, with the band’s label Reprise declining to release it, before it was eventually released by Reprise subsidiary Nonesuch, effectively meaning that the same label paid for it twice. In the wake of Radiohead’s Kid A, the band’s sonic experimentation is at its peak here, with Tweedy’s emotive songs buried under layers of electronic twiddling. Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is often gorgeous, and fun rockers like ‘Heavy Metal Drummer’ and ‘I’m The Man Who Loves You’ help to keep a contemplative record moving.

Being There

Wilco Being There#1, 1996
The addition of Jay Bennett immediately took Wilco into the big leagues; Being There is a sprawling double album that is steeped in rock heritage. The extraordinary tracks that open each disc reference the redemptive yet hollow power of music: “Music is my savior/I was maimed by rock and roll” Tweedy sings in ‘Sunken Treasure’. Elsewhere, there’s everything from the introversion of ‘Say You Miss Me’, the clavinet laden ‘Kingpin’, and the power pop of ‘I Got You (at the End of the Century)’. Later Wilco albums were more adventurous, but Being There was their career peak.

Do you have a favourite Wilco record? Or song?

Read More:
– Wilco album reviews
Five of the best lists


Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.


  1. An excellent overview of some of Wilco’s best work. My order is somewhat different from yours, though – I also exclude the Bragg collaborations. My favourite is likely Summerteeth, as it’s the first Wilco album I fell in love with.
    The rest: #2 Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, #3 Being There, #4 A Ghost is Born, #5 The Whole Love. Sky Blue Sky and the self-titled albums are nice enough, if unremarkable, and I really need to spend time with Schmilco.

      • Yeah, exactly the same five. Sky Blue Sky is a really good album, but it just doesn’t get going. It’s a safe record, I guess. The album that just keeps the releases ticking over without doing or saying anything in particular.

  2. I love Wilco! I’ve seen them many many times, including Jeff solo (again in 2 weeks in LA) and even Nels Cline several times. I’m kind of obsessed.
    My stack would be something like:
    Being There
    Star Wars

    Those top 5 are fantastic from start to finish. Then the rest in no particular order – all have great moments but a few less engaging tracks IMO. The Tweedy album Sukirae is also amazing – would be in my top 5 if it were a proper Wilco album.

    • Sounds like there’s a bit of consensus so far on the best Wilco records – generally the Jay Bennett era. I need to hear Tweedy’s solo stuff, I’d be more interested in it than Wilco at this point.

      • With all due respect to Jay’s talent and contributions to Wilco, I think its most reasonable to refer to the entirety of the Wilco catalogue as the Jeff Tweedy era. Regardless of my list of favorites or yours or anybody’s, the weight of Wilco’s best and worst belongs to Jeff’s vision and choices. Yankee Hotel Foxtrot succeeded in spite of Jay’s spiraling substance abuse and erratic behavior because of Jeff’s strength as an artist and band leader. Jay was very talented but his contribution to the overall success of Wilco as a concept is often overstated IMO.

  3. Good work. I’m similar to catchgoove on the “mood” thing. I just like Tweedy’s choices. You know how I feel about he Guthrie thing.I went for a car ride a while back and my youngest son had Being There on the music box. Helped the trip..

Leave a Reply

More from Aphoristic Album Reviews

Aphoristic Album Reviews is almost entirely written by one person.

Graham Fyfe is probably the only music blogger to appreciate both Neil Diamond and Ariana Grande. Based in Fleet Street (New Zealand), he's been writing this blog since around 2000. Aphoristic Album Reviews features reviews and blog posts across a growing spectrum of popular music.

Review Pages

Read about the discographies of musical acts from the 1960s to the present day. Browse this site's review archives or enjoy these random selections:

The Smiths Album Reviews

The unlikely pairing of socially awkward Steven Morrissey and guitarist Johnny Marr, extroverted and four years Morrissey’s junior, formed the nucleus of The Smiths, whose witty and stripped-down music was an influential force throughout their brief existence. Inspired by punk (according to legend, Morrissey’s musical epiphany can be traced back to the […]
The Velvet Underground Album Reviews

1960s New York band The Velvet Underground have been cited as an influence by a legion of followers. Even if the ground rules of the rock album as an art form had been largely written by the time the Velvets’ debut arrived in 1967, there is still a strong argument for […]
Chairlift Album Reviews

Caroline Polachek formed Chairlift with her college boyfriend Aaron Pfenning. The pair initially planned to make music for haunted houses but ended up following the time-honoured path – recording an EP. In 2006 they moved to Brooklyn and recorded their debut album, joined by new member Patrick Wimberly. The trio […]
Little Simz Album Reviews

Little Simz is a London-based rapper, singer, and actor with Nigerian heritage. She became a public figure in her mid-teens; in 2010 she appeared in the TV series Spirit Warriors and released her first mixtape Stratosphere. Her first full-length albums, released in her early twenties, received little attention. 2019’s Grey Area […]
The Police Album Reviews

English trio The Police released their first album in 1978. Despite the timing, they weren’t especially punk, something that’s immediately apparent from their choice of band name. The Police were already music industry veterans when they formed – guitarist Andy Summers was already in his mid-30s and had played with […]
Brian Eno Another Green World
Brian Eno Album Reviews

Brian Eno started his musical career as a member of Roxy Music, where he used his synthesiser to treat Phil Manzanera’s guitar and Andy Mackay’s saxophone and oboe. After leaving Roxy Music he built up an impressive catalogue as a producer, with significant albums for David Bowie, Talking Heads, Devo, […]

Blog Posts

I add new blog posts to this website every week. Browse the archives or enjoy these random selections:

10 Best LCD Soundsystem Songs

New Jersey’s James Murphy obviously has a terrific record collection – his favourite artists include The Fall, Yes, The B-52’s, David Bowie, and Can. LCD Soundsystem’s music echoes these influences, along with electronic pioneers like New Order and Kraftwerk. Murphy turned down the opportunity to write for Seinfeld in order […]
Jason Isbell Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

If you’re an old man, shouting at the clouds about how modern music isn’t the same as it was in your heyday, you would probably enjoy the recent output of Jason Isbell. Isbell’s an Americana artist, whose sincere albums are timeless and elegant, and could have been made any time […]
Crowded House The Very Best Of Recurring Dream
Neil Finn's Five Best Albums

Until the emergence of Lorde, song-smith Neil Finn was New Zealand’s most recognisable pop export. Born in Te Awamutu, Finn was enamoured by the tuneful pop of The Beatles and Elton John. Still a teenager, he joined his brother Tim Finn in Split Enz in 1977, originally as a guitarist. […]
Simon & Garfunkel Albums: Ranked from Worst to Best

Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel started their recording career as Tom & Jerry in 1957, making teen-oriented Everly Brothers style pop. After a temporary split, they re-branded as Simon & Garfunkel, an earnest folk duo. Their debut album, 1964’s Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M., was unsuccessful, and a frustrated Simon relocated to […]
Stevie Wonder Songs in the Key of Life
Ten worst pop stinkers ever – A Letter to the Editor

Ten worst pop stinkers ever I wrote this in response to a list published in a major New Zealand weekly magazine (The NZ Listener). It was published, despite its unusual format, in February 2002: Even though the enjoyment of a pop song is highly subjective, depending on the listener’s age […]
The Smiths 1984 Debut
The Smiths: Albums Ranked from Worst to Best

The two figures at the centre of 1980s English indie-rock band The Smiths were an unlikely pairing. Vocalist Morrissey was socially awkward, literate, and camp, while guitarist Johnny Marr was an aspiring football player who trialled with Manchester City. Bonding over a shared interest in The New York Dolls, they […]
%d bloggers like this: